Whats the legal/moral situation on 'exclusivity'

Messages
1,453
Name
Duncan
Edit My Images
Yes
Hi All,
I occasionally shoot for a music webzine which gets me photopasses. They are now setting up a website for selling on images [for editorial use] and want me to give them exclusive rights to use those photos which would prohibit me from putting them elsewhere....

I can understand that they organise the photopass and that gives them some rights. But I don't get paid directly at present although the webzine say they will do a 50/50 split with the 'exclusive' deal.

I feel uneasy about this but not sure why. What are my legal rights?

Cheers,


Dunc
 
Hi All,
What are my legal rights?

whatever is stated in your contract with them... :thinking:

if you don't have one, then you should, and pronto...you working for free, and giving ONLY them the photos, just in exchange for them blagging you a press pass, is very, very steep (oh, and charge them...).

If you had not signed a contract saying so, then they could not legally enforce this 'exclusivity - you own the copyright to the photos unless contractually stated otherwise.
 
Go and read up on licencing and copyright.

You can have a contract with your client for several things including and not limited to how the images are used. You can allow them restricted use for one price and unlimited use for a higher price. It's up to you how you want to negotiate that one.
 
Yes, a contract can be written or verbal in UK law (although obviously a verbal one is more difficult to enforce in court, but it can be enforced none the less)

Your deal currently is that you are able to reuse/resell anything that you gather on their behalf to other publications. Now they want to change the terms to not allowing you that - thats a renegotiation of the contract... so you need to negotiate.

Your choices are:

1) Accept their terms
2) Propose different terms
3) Terminate the deal

Without any current clauses about notice periods for variation or termination, all of this is effect immediate - or whenever either side chooses.

So, your choice really, will their marketing efforts of your images yield more/enough money to you or do you want to find a new sponsor?

Bear in mind, it probably won't be hard for them to find a new photographer to accept their terms - get media creds for gigs and maybe make some cash? I think if you advertised that on here you'd not find it long before quite a few bite on it.
 
Hi,
Thanks foir the replies and advice, I have declined their kind offer! I have suggested a compromise but I have said a def no to exclusive rights!

Dunc
 
They're not asking you to hand over copyright. They just want to be able to sell some pics and appear willing to share the profits with you.

So you draw up a license that gives them what they want, and what you need also.

You can make it for a limited time, exclusive or non-exclusive, limited to certain media, limited to certain pictures, 99% to you 1% to them, whatever you like. It's not all or nothing.
 
They're not asking you to hand over copyright. They just want to be able to sell some pics and appear willing to share the profits with you.

So you draw up a license that gives them what they want, and what you need also.

You can make it for a limited time, exclusive or non-exclusive, limited to certain media, limited to certain pictures, 99% to you 1% to them, whatever you like. It's not all or nothing.

+1 to this.

Be careful with selling prints of artists, selling some is usually fine, but if they deem it to be too commercial it won't do you any favours.
 
+1 to this.

Be careful with selling prints of artists, selling some is usually fine, but if they deem it to be too commercial it won't do you any favours.

Can you clarify that please? Who won't it do any favours with? The webzine?

As far as the law is concerned, as you are not a paid employee of the company (webzine) you own the copyright over any of the images you make, whether they have asked you to make them or not and whether or not they give you a music pass (if you can get a press card, they tend to work nicely as well).

Now for the webzine to have exclusive rights over your work, you would need to agree to that (it's best to have it in writing) and if you don't agree (which you say you haven't) then they cannot enforce their agreement on you any more than terminating the agreement and telling you to sod off.

I would negotiate a world-wide non-exclusive license and include the rights to modify, sub-lease and distribute. But that's just me, I like to not be limited in what I can do with my work. You should also aim to put in the contract what happens to the copyright upon termination, personally I would aim to have their rights over my images terminated with the contract.
 
Can you clarify that please? Who won't it do any favours with? The webzine?

Both the webzine and the photographer. The prints usually need to be approved by management and it's extremely rare for them to approve unless they get a good slice of the profit. (Of course, if these images are of local acts this doesn't really apply.)
 
Both the webzine and the photographer. The prints usually need to be approved by management and it's extremely rare for them to approve unless they get a good slice of the profit. (Of course, if these images are of local acts this doesn't really apply.)

Management of the artist?

If I'm taking your point correctly, what your saying in effect is that the person in the picture (a performing artist) has some say in how their images are used by a photographer. This is wholly untrue if it is indeed your point. The copyright of the image belongs to the photographer, which grants them all the rights under copyright law. Just because the person in the picture is famous does not mean that they are entitled to a slice of the profits or that they have any rights over the image (such as moral rights).

::EDIT::
Moral rights defined under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act
 
Management of the artist?

If I'm taking your point correctly, what your saying in effect is that the person in the picture (a performing artist) has some say in how their images are used by a photographer. This is wholly untrue if it is indeed your point. The copyright of the image belongs to the photographer, which grants them all the rights under copyright law. Just because the person in the picture is famous does not mean that they are entitled to a slice of the profits or that they have any rights over the image (such as moral rights).

They have moral rights. You cannot do 'anything' with it. Derogatory representation will get you into trouble.

As far as copyright goes, you're probably okay by the sounds, but one danger area is that if someone else can claim that they 'employed' you in any formal way then they might own copyright.

I don't think it applies here, but if you do any photography for your employer then they might well own the copyright (if they pay your income tax, then they're probaly your employer, but other definitions apply). Employer's rights are much wider than people think, and can even extend to what you might normally consider personal out of hours photography in some cases.
 
They have moral rights. You cannot do 'anything' with it. Derogatory representation will get you into trouble.
Would that not come under libel and slander? The moral rights I was talking about are specifically outlined in the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act.

As far as copyright goes, you're probably okay by the sounds, but one danger area is that if someone else can claim that they 'employed' you in any formal way then they might own copyright.

I don't think it applies here, but if you do any photography for your employer then they might well own the copyright (if they pay your income tax, then they're probaly your employer, but other definitions apply). Employer's rights are much wider than people think, and can even extend to what you might normally consider personal out of hours photography in some cases.

Employers own copyright over work which is created during the course of one's employment, but when you do create artist works during the course of your employment then your employer owns the rights.
 
Re the rights of the artist and your / the webzine's ability to sell prints - you need to check the conditions of entry to the concert and any specific conditions relating to the press pass. if the management company have their heads screwed on they will prevent commercial exploitation of any photos taken.
 
Re the rights of the artist and your / the webzine's ability to sell prints - you need to check the conditions of entry to the concert and any specific conditions relating to the press pass. if the management company have their heads screwed on they will prevent commercial exploitation of any photos taken.

Which is the only way they could impose rights over a photographer's work, if indeed it could, I've never seen or heard of landlords being able to impose that as a condition of entry but then I don't go to concerts much :).
 
Which is the only way they could impose rights over a photographer's work, if indeed it could, I've never seen or heard of landlords being able to impose that as a condition of entry but then I don't go to concerts much :).
Landlords can and DO impose restrictions on photographers - just see all the posts about togs being asked to leave shopping centres. But I wasn;t referring to landlords, I was referring to the artists management company, who are the people who grant the press passes, and thus who can decide what restrictions apply.
 
Landlords can and DO impose restrictions on photographers - just see all the posts about togs being asked to leave shopping centres. But I wasn;t referring to landlords, I was referring to the artists management company, who are the people who grant the press passes, and thus who can decide what restrictions apply.

Oh certainly, I've seen landlords impose restrictions on photographers before, but I've never seen a clause which takes rights from the photographer before, although like I said, I rarely go to concerts.
 
Would that not come under libel and slander? The moral rights I was talking about are specifically outlined in the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act.

Yes, sorry, I meant moral in the general sense, not the legal meaning in the context you refer to.

But derogatory use can be very serious. You must not misrepresent people. It usually happens when an image is used, sometimes accidentally, in a completely inappropriate context. Eg, be very careful about what pictures you use to illustrate an article about prostitutes!

Employers only own copyright over work which is created during the course of one's employment, but when you do create artist works during the course of your employment then your employer owns the rights.

The point I make is that "the course of one's employment" is very extensive. It extends way beyond normal working hours and away from the place of work.

Oh certainly, I've seen landlords impose restrictions on photographers before, but I've never seen a clause which takes rights from the photographer before, although like I said, I rarely go to concerts.

Anyone can impose restrictions on what happens on their property, or at their events. But that has to be agreed before, not retrospectively.

That's the theory anyway. What happens in practise is more like rough justice and if you mess people about (or they think you're messing them about, which is often not the same thing) they will just rip you off anyway, and doors will start closing. Watch your fingers!
 
Yes, sorry, I meant moral in the general sense, not the legal meaning in the context you refer to.

But derogatory use can be very serious. You must not misrepresent people. It usually happens when an image is used, sometimes accidentally, in a completely inappropriate context. Eg, be very careful about what pictures you use to illustrate an article about prostitutes!
Oh certainly, you must be careful when using images to ensure that you do not present a story which is completely made up otherwise you can end up in hot water.

The point I make is that "the course of one's employment" is very extensive. It extends way beyond normal working hours and away from the place of work.
Yes it is, it's hard sometimes to prove that it wasn't during the course of your employment as well and I've seen people taken advantage of that way.

Anyone can impose restrictions on what happens on their property, or at their events. But that has to be agreed before, not retrospectively.

That's the theory anyway. What happens in practise is more like rough justice and if you mess people about (or they think you're messing them about, which is often not the same thing) they will just rip you off anyway, and doors will start closing. Watch your fingers!
In a perfect world many things would be different...
 
Back
Top