Why are my images coming up more saturated on fb

Messages
277
Name
Shane dennigan
Edit My Images
No
Hi

Wondering why my images come up more saturated on fb even though I upload them as srgb format either by photoshop or LR 3 is it something to do with Facebook? Noticed Flickr also buy it isn't as heavy on that

My screen is set to srgb setting I shoot in raw j. Adobe rgb and save as tiff for more editing in photoshop then for web I save as jpg to srgb.....
 
Adobe RGB is for printers not screens or web use...there is your problem.
 
Raw is neither AdobeRGB or sRGB. It's raw sensor data. The setting on the camera only affects JPEGs created in camera.

Maybe facebook is adding a "punch" curve?
 
Yes I save to srgb for web but shouldn't they come up the same???
 
I don't see why the browser should b the problem I upload the same images for proof for printing to print lab and they work film not as saturated like fb and Flickr
 
Extra compression added during up load?

Different browsers do different things with jpg's I think. Should be easy enough to check though.
 
Steveo

U could be right I can't remember the size they were but I think they were alot bigger than the average size for online whats your opinion on solving this ?
 
Think IE9 partially supports colour profiles (sorry can't explain anymore) but I know Firefox which I use can as I have an extension installed to use srgb for all images!
 
I'm not sure what the maximum file size is on fb, you can probably check how big the files are currently. The "best" solution is probably to use your photo editor of choice to do the compression, its likely to be more sympathetic to image quality than the fairly brutal methods the on-line services use. Crop if you can. Reduce resolution to some thing more browser friendly (think 800x600) then compress it to match the file size before you upload it.

or just live with it.... :D

Apologies for egg sucking advice if this is all a bit too obvious.
 
The answer would be post your pics up on TP for proper C&C :D ;)
 
Ok I tried vieing Facebook under google chrome & safari and it appeared the image was normally saturated and not over but Internet explorer still is????
 
iamchrisphoto said:
It depends on what browser you are using. Some don't support colour profiles, other do. Sorry I can't remember which ones.

I think ur spot on in my Internet explorer its off but when I use safari or google chrome is seems fine is this normal???
 
I think its probably a MS feature. IE has had so many quirks and foibles its difficult to tell what MS meant to do and what they've accidentally messed up. Stick to chrome or firefox your sanity will thank you.
 
I think its probably a MS feature. IE has had so many quirks and foibles its difficult to tell what MS meant to do and what they've accidentally messed up. Stick to chrome or firefox your sanity will thank you.

as said above somewhere IE9 supports some colour profiles so its probably that. incidentally sRGB images should display the same in all browsers.

OP upload the image to photobucket or similar (with EXIF) and let us have a look.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top