Why is a slow lens a bad thing? Sigma 150-500mm f/5-6.3

Messages
1,940
Name
Dini
Edit My Images
Yes
I am currently considering the Sigma 150-500mm f/5-6.3 OS HSM. Most of the reviews or comments i read are usually focused on how slow the lens is. i.e. the lens is limited to a maximum aperture of f/6.3 at 500mm.

Why is this a major problem? I dont understand how this 'slowness' is a big difference compared to other cameras like the 100-400mm f4.5-5.6.

I usually get confused when people say that something is better because it is one or two stops better. Is it not possible to compensate the one or two stop difference by reducing the shutter speed or increasing the ISO?

Presumabely if i do buy it and always use a monopod or a tripod, the f/6.3 limitation should not be a problem? I have seen comments that it might struggle to focus at f/6.3 at where there is not enough light. Is this also true if the lens is on a tripod?
 
If a lens is 'slow' it will be more difficult to lock onto a moving image e.g. bird in flight, so if you are shooting birds in flight the faster the lens you use the easier it will be to lock onto a good focus.
A lens at f2.8 will allow more light (obviously) so AF should be good whereas at f6.3 some AF systems might struggle.
Is that what you mean?
 
Because in lower light levels your shutter speed will be too slow to freeze the motion of what you are trying to photograph or the iso speed needed will be so high that the results are noisy and ruin the image. A tripod will eliminate lens shake from a slow shutter but not motion blur from whatever it is you're trying to photograph.

Also the wider aperture lenses tend to be better at focussing in low light as mentioned above.
 
I suppose that when high ISOs were only useable up to something like 800 or 1600 a few years ago, a slower maximum aperture like f/6.3 was a hindrance if that high ISO ceiling was reached and you couldn't get a high shutter speed. Also, AF speed and the ability to latch onto a point of focus is linked to that maximum aperture, hence why everyone is craving for fast lenses, especially in low-contrast situations where the camera's AF system is working overtime.

That said, with modern cameras able to reach heady ISO heights like 6400 and 12,800 with ease and without a loss of image quality, the slower apertures are less of an issue now, allowing the user to get fast enough shutter speed. Sensor technology have definitely made things more cost-effective.

The issue of depth-of-field is still there though and f/6.3 is obviously not going to allow you as much separation of the subject as, say, an f/4 lens. B
 
Last edited:
A "slow" lens is only a problem if the intended usage means you wouldn't be able to up the ISO, slow the shutter to expose shots correctly.

For example...... I used to use a 400D & Sigma 170-500mm. I think that was f6.5 at 500mm and the maximum ISO on the 400D was 1600.

Now during the summer when I shoot cricket matches, not really a problem...... On a cloudy afternoon in December shooting stopped at around 3PM which was before half time at most rugby matches as I couldn't get the shutter speed fast enough to freeze the action.

Using a 70-200mm f2.8 I could have carried on shooting for longer.

I now use a 7D and 100-400L so I have up to ISO6400 at my disposal and f5.6 @400mm which means I've only struggled to get shots right up to the end of a rugby match mid Dec-Jan. Without a doubt a constant f2.8 would have been better as I wouldn't have had to use such a high ISO and/or been able to use a faster shutter speed.

Slow focusing is a different matter ;)
 
If a lens is 'slow' it will be more difficult to lock onto a moving image e.g. bird in flight, so if you are shooting birds in flight the faster the lens you use the easier it will be to lock onto a good focus.
A lens at f2.8 will allow more light (obviously) so AF should be good whereas at f6.3 some AF systems might struggle.
Is that what you mean?

Yes exactly but can i not increase the ISO to allow more light?
 
ziggy©;4627441 said:
Yes exactly but can i not increase the ISO to allow more light?

No..... ISO only increases the sensitivity of the sensor, not the amount of light available.
 
I suppose that when high ISOs were only useable up to something like 800 or 1600 a few years ago, a slower maximum aperture like f/6.3 was a hindrance if that high ISO ceiling was reached and you couldn't get a high shutter speed. Also, AF speed and the ability to latch onto a point of focus is linked to that maximum aperture, hence why everyone is craving for fast lenses, especially in low-contrast situations where the camera's AF system is working overtime.

That said, with modern cameras able to reach heady ISO heights like 6400 and 12,800 with ease and without a loss of image quality, the slower apertures are less of an issue now, allowing the user to get fast enough shutter speed. Sensor technology have definitely made things more cost-effective.

The issue of depth-of-field is still there though and f/6.3 is obviously not going to allow you as much separation of the subject as, say, an f/4 lens. B

I own the 60D and i think the quality of the high ISO images from it are quite usable and if not can be fixed in photoshop.
 
ziggy©;4627454 said:
I own the 60D and i think the quality of the high ISO images from it are quite usable and if not can be fixed in photoshop.

Then "you" don't need a fast lens.

Everyone is different though, other's might not want to or have time to spend hours in photoshop reducing the noise in their images.

Take Kipax and the other guys that are pro-sports photographers. They have to send images from pitch-side to the newspapers or agencies. They definitely don't have time to play with NR so need to get as much right in camera as possible.

f6.5 just wouldn't cut it in their game hence why some people "need" fast glass and others (such as yourself) don't.
 
This is england, 1/500 is a tricky shutter speed to get at anytime after about 2pm, I rarely get it with f2.8 lenses!
 
ziggy©;4627460 said:
So increasing the ISO has no impact on how the focusing system works?

Nope!

But a wider apeture would allow more light into the lens and potentially help it focus quicker.
 
ziggy©;4627454 said:
I own the 60D and i think the quality of the high ISO images from it are quite usable and if not can be fixed in photoshop.

You're sorted then. The high ISO on the 60D is good, a great little camera :)
 
ziggy©;4627441 said:
Yes exactly but can i not increase the ISO to allow more light?

No,by increaseing the ISO,you increase the camera addbilty to read more light,but it does not help,the lens to AF any better. :)
 
Then "you" don't need a fast lens.

Everyone is different though, other's might not want to or have time to spend hours in photoshop reducing the noise in their images.

Take Kipax and the other guys that are pro-sports photographers. They have to send images from pitch-side to the newspapers or agencies. They definitely don't have time to play with NR so need to get as much right in camera as possible.

f6.5 just wouldn't cut it in their game hence why some people "need" fast glass and others (such as yourself) don't.

The biggest problem for me is that i just cannot afford the faster lenses. If i can get similar results with a little bit more work (e.g tripod and some patience) i really do not mind. Maybe if i was doing it as part of my job then maybe the cost is justifiable but i don't think it is for a weekend hobby :)
 
Last edited:
ziggy©;4627497 said:
If i can get similar results with a little bit more work (e.g tripod and some patience) i really do not mind.

Bird sitting on a branch = fine.
Red Kite swooping down on food = probably not fine, you won't rectify the blur in Photoshop :D
 
ziggy©;4627497 said:
The biggest problem for me is that i just cannot afford the faster lenses. If i can get similar results with a little bit more work (e.g tripod and some patience) i really do not mind. Maybe if i was doing it as part of my job then maybe the cost is justifiable but i don't think it is for a weekend hobby :)



Try before you buy would be my advice, we had a 400D and found its Af a limiting factor as it wasnt particularly good with slower lenses.

Matt
 
Bird sitting on a branch = fine.
Red Kite swooping down on food = probably not fine, you won't rectify the blur in Photoshop :D

+1!

As I said in my first reply, it all depends on the circumstances and what you're shooting ;)

I know a 400mm L f2.8 would give me a lot better shots than my 100-400mm L BUT for the amount I use the lens and for what I use it for I can't justify the cost ;)
 
I have a Sigma 150-500mm and try to avoid having to use it at f6.3 as it is MUCH sharper at f8 or f9.

I think it is a great lens for the money if you are aware of its limitations and the OS to me is essential.

It was a big learning curve and they are not easy to use but totally worth it (short of winning the lottery!)

Heather
 
In real terms the Sigma at f6.3 is only 1/3 of a stop slower than the ubiquitous Canon 100-400 at f5.6 which is insignificant. I've recently swapped to an 120-300 f2.8 and whilst the extra stops are welcome it hasn't made a great deal of difference to my shooting to be honest. Yes we would all like a f2.8 500mm that was cheap and also light, but it isn't going to happen, so learn to use the tools you have which if applied properly can still give you great shots.
 
The sigma 500 f2.8 zoom is about 16kg and £16,000 RRP so definitely neither cheap or light : P
 
What I don't really understand is, say I bought a 300mm 2.8 but needed to get 500mm I'd have to put a 1.7 converter on it, would that not lose me a couple of stops anyway?
 
What I don't really understand is, say I bought a 300mm 2.8 but needed to get 500mm I'd have to put a 1.7 converter on it, would that not lose me a couple of stops anyway?

Probably about right. The point is if the 300mm was f4 to start with you'd be even worse off ;)
 
But lenses like the Sigma can still capture action, this for example is at f8 iirc


Gulls Feeding by ACW#, on Flickr

If your shooting a fast lens and a slow lens both at f8 then (broadly speaking) you could have a lot more money left in your pocket by just having the slow one. It's only, as has already been mentioned when you need to be able to take pictures whatever the conditions that fast glass becomes essential.

If I don't think my lens can handle the conditions and I was only shooting for fun then it doesn't matter. But if a pro sports tog can't get the pictures they rely on getting paid for because their lens is only as fast as f5.6, then it becomes another matter entirely.
 
Last edited:
ziggy©;4627497 said:
The biggest problem for me is that i just cannot afford the faster lenses. If i can get similar results with a little bit more work (e.g tripod and some patience) i really do not mind. Maybe if i was doing it as part of my job then maybe the cost is justifiable but i don't think it is for a weekend hobby :)

That's the point exactly, but you need to understand that if you're making compromises, there will be a consequence.

AF works much better with faster lenses, faster lenses will give you images at lower ISO, if the cost of faster lenses isn't worth this to you, then it's not worth it.

But don't try to pretend that there's no point in buying them.
 
In real terms the Sigma at f6.3 is only 1/3 of a stop slower than the ubiquitous Canon 100-400 at f5.6 which is insignificant

It is very significant when you take into account that Canon only rate their autofocus system to work with lenses with a maximum aperture of f/5.6 or larger.

YMMV.
 
In real terms the Sigma at f6.3 is only 1/3 of a stop slower than the ubiquitous Canon 100-400 at f5.6 which is insignificant. I've recently swapped to an 120-300 f2.8 and whilst the extra stops are welcome it hasn't made a great deal of difference to my shooting to be honest. Yes we would all like a f2.8 500mm that was cheap and also light, but it isn't going to happen, so learn to use the tools you have which if applied properly can still give you great shots.

:plusone:
Well put Ken.:thumbs:
 
Musicman said:
It is very significant when you take into account that Canon only rate their autofocus system to work with lenses with a maximum aperture of f/5.6 or larger.

YMMV.

Which the Sigma fools the camera into thinking it is at the long end.
 
There are several different things to be aware of here...
1. Autofocus either won't work at all or won't work well if the lens doesn't have a large max aperture and if the camera isn't a high end model.
2. Manual focus isn't as easy and intuitive on modern cameras that are designed for autofocus as on older cameras, and photographers who don't have a lot of experience of manual focus find it both slow and difficult to do well.
3. Just because a camera can shoot at high ISO settings doesn't mean that the results will be good - very few cameras can produce what I would call acceptable results at high ISO, even at web resolutions. You can reduce noise on computer but that isn't anywhere near as good as not having the noise there.
4. Only the very best lenses produce decent results at their largest apertures. A 'cheap' f/5.6 lens will probably only produce halfway decent results at around f/11, amplifying all the problems listed above.

That's why people buy better lenses. But for hobby use, sometimes you just have to work within a budget - just don't expect to be able to produce the same quality of results and range of results.
 
There are several different things to be aware of here...
4. Only the very best lenses produce decent results at their largest apertures. A 'cheap' f/5.6 lens will probably only produce halfway decent results at around f/11, amplifying all the problems listed above.

And then you start running into "fringing" at small apertures on cropped cameras, fun isnt it?

Matt
 
I wouldn't be without my Sigma 150-500 OS now. I bought it in january, when I had a 5D2 and a 7D, and paired it with a Canon 100-400 IS L. When I sold both bodies to get a 5D3 I decided to let one of the lenses go and after much testing I kept the Sigma and sold the Canon (something I never thought I'd do).
The IQ of both is very similar, the Sigma is very sharp wide open at f6.3@500mm and even improves at f7.1 - f11, the Canon was best at f8. The OS/IS system battle was easily won by the Sigma, I managed to get a good handheld shot as low as 1/10sec where 1/30sec was dodgy on the Canon. The AF on both was similar in speed and accuracy, but IMO the Sigma handled failing light better than the Canon seemed to.
 
I think it's all been said in this thread already. I think the crux of the matter is that the Sigma (and it's cousins) is a decent lens at a very low price compared to just about any alternative. To get a significantly faster 500mm lens will cost many times more so for most people, it simply is not practical.

So, yes there are good reasons to want faster but it's going to cost you lots and lots of cash. I think the Sigma does a pretty good job at an amateur level.
 
In a Gerry Springer style summary......

"Why is a slow lens a bad thing?"

A slow lens is only a bad thing if you need a fast lens ;) :lol:
 
Which is exactly the same reason phase detect autofocus systems have trouble with slow lenses.
 
Which is exactly the same reason phase detect autofocus systems have trouble with slow lenses.

It's not entirely the amount of light that causes trouble. F/8 won't work in the day when 5.6 works in less overall light in the evening. It's to do with the aperture and phases.... I think... More light helps but only to a point.
 
Back
Top