Can I ask a series of rilly stupid questions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter RobC
  • Start date Start date
R

RobC

Guest
Sadly I'm not the sharpest tool in the box and struggle with some of the explanations I've found on the board and learning from books is virtually impossible for me :(

To that end I learn from doing but could really do with a 'sanity check' on what I think I've learnt. (this is a handheld scenario, I get that a tripod helps immensely)

1. The faster the shutter speed, the sharper the image ?

2. The lower the f-stop (eg f22) the slower the shutter speed?

3. The higher the f-stop (eg f6.0 the faster the shutter speed?

4. A high f-stop or a slow shutter in poor light requires a higher ISO?


I'm asking because I only seem to get nice sharp images when there's lots of light around and if I've got this right, lots of light = fast shutter.

Sorry if I'm being daft.
 
1. Depends on the lens- the sharpest image will usually be a couple of stops slower that its widest.

2. Yeap, to get the same exposure, as a higher f-stop will let in less light- so to compensate, you would need to leave the shutter open longer

3. Yeap- the same as above but in reverse.

4. High f-stop will require a higher iso- as would a faster shutter. Not a slower shutter though. (There is a great website that shows this in practical terms, will try and find now)
 
Thanks so much for responding, I was getting into one of those chats you have with yourself whereby you end up confusing the hell outta yourself :cuckoo:

Re 4:
Because a slower shutter means lots more light and with a high ISO that means lots of noise which also means lack of sharpness :thinking:

(or am I confusing myself now?)
 
Also try and make sure that the shutter speed is higher/faster than the focal length of the lens. This means (if i have got it right) that if you have say a 50mm lens on your camera your shutter speed needs to be faster than 1/50th of a second so 1/60th, 1/70th etc etc would be better. If it were 1/40th of a second then you will have a blurry pic unless you have MEGA steady hands.

I find that low light hand held is very very hard to get sharp images. I have come to realise that a tripod is essential and if you don't want to be seen with a tripod all over the place then a monopod is great for reducing camera shake. They are cheap so give it a go or borrow one. They are alot less intrusive than a Tripod. It all depends what you are shooting.

There are tutorials on how to shoot hand held on the new.
 
I'm asking because I only seem to get nice sharp images when there's lots of light around and if I've got this right, lots of light = fast shutter. Sorry if I'm being daft.


Firstly, you are not being daft.
Many of us find things a bit confusing when we first get into photography and a major thumbs up to this forum is the willingness of people to give help.
When taking hand held shots in low light, (as you have no doubt discovered), the shutter speed will be far too slow.
If you are just using the kit lens with your 400D it will struggle in low light.
An f/2.8 lens that is constant through it's focal range would be a good choice but sadly these do not come cheap.
A lot of people rate the Canon 50mm f/1.8 prime lens (refered to as the nifty fifty).
I used one for a short while but I didn't use it in low light but I am sure someone else can give you more information about this lens.
 
My 'walkabout' is a sigma DC 18-200 (with OS(although I leave that off)).
I think I need to stop whacking it all the way out for starters.

Thanks for the replies I've certainly got some thinking to do but it appears I'm working it out albeit slowly.
 
Beaten to it by Mr Pants! Damn my slow typing.
 
all are relevant

firstly you set the asa to suit your requirements..
lowest first choice and then higher to suit the light and what speeds you anticipate you may need
then its up to the photographer
the light is not always in our control unless we are using artificial sources
so
light values will change...sometimes known as exposure values
these relate via the asa to a speed and aperture combination which will let enough light through the lens to record an image
fast speed...larger hole
slow speed ..smaller hole
if you need to freeze shots the faster speeds are mandatory
if you need pin sharp hand held shots likewise
apertures have a secondary function as making the shot seem sharper due to depth of field....this is a function of the lens only
so if you want a good apparent sharpness over a distance then small apertures will do this
its like squinting your eye to see a bit sharper...its exactly the same phenomenon
if you just want the area you focus on to be the most sharp...a portrait for instance
then more open...low numbered...apertures do the job nicely and give you some speed in hand

your questions are no more silly than
1 my answers
2 some photos taken by those who 'know' but 'forget' to use those parameters in their shots

hope this helps...
 
all are relevant

firstly you set the asa to suit your requirements..
lowest first choice and then higher to suit the light and what speeds you anticipate you may need
then its up to the photographer
the light is not always in our control unless we are using artificial sources
so
light values will change...sometimes known as exposure values
these relate via the asa to a speed and aperture combination which will let enough light through the lens to record an image
fast speed...larger hole
slow speed ..smaller hole
if you need to freeze shots the faster speeds are mandatory
if you need pin sharp hand held shots likewise
apertures have a secondary function as making the shot seem sharper due to depth of field....this is a function of the lens only
so if you want a good apparent sharpness over a distance then small apertures will do this
its like squinting your eye to see a bit sharper...its exactly the same phenomenon
if you just want the area you focus on to be the most sharp...a portrait for instance
then more open...low numbered...apertures do the job nicely and give you some speed in hand

your questions are no more silly than
1 my answers
2 some photos taken by those who 'know' but 'forget' to use those parameters in their shots

hope this helps...

Ok, that pretty much all made sense, so it does help, thank you very much for your tuppence worth. I think you've confirmed what I stated/questioned in my OP. HOWEVER ..... "asa" - wassat ?
 
asa is film/sensor sensitivity - iso
 
asa is film/sensor sensitivity - iso


Hmmmm, I've always left it at 100. So in theory, if I can learn what ISO for what light conditions, apply my newly found and confirmed "shutter speed, f-stop, f-stop, shutter speed" (jar, spoon, spoon, jar) rule I should be well away.
 
1. Depends on the lens- the sharpest image will usually be a couple of stops slower that its widest.

I dont know if his question has been edited but if it hasnt, read it again.



To answer number one again: 1. The faster the shutter speed, the sharper the image ?

Yes and no. A faster shutter speed means objects in the photo, eg people have less time to move about, this movement will cause blurring. Also, humans cannot hold a camera perfectly still so a higher shutter speed also means the camera has less time to move about, again movement of the camera results in blurring.

You should turn OS on, that reduces camera shake dramatically, and provided the objects in your photo are stationary (a building for example) you can get away with much lower shutter speeds than you could with it off.
Regarding it making the image blurry, it has been argued that using it on tripods isn't ideal but tbh the difference will be minimal, and you might forget to turn it back on when you next use the camera handheld, so pretty much leave it on 24/7.

It is recommended that the minimum shutter speed used is the reciprocal of the focal length. So at 18mm on that lens, 1/20 would be ok (with some care taken to keep the camera as still as possible) However, when you use the long end, 200mm, try to keep the shutter speed at 1/200 or faster. This is to prevent camera shake, so as i hate to complicate things, since you have OS, you may be able to use shutter speed which are slower than those i just described. Also, if the objects in the photo are moving, and higher shutter speed may be required to 'freeze' them, or you may feel you want a bit of blurring (eg panning motorsport shots) so its best just to experiment and you'll see what works.

p.s dont be afraid to push up the iso, noise is far less noticeable in actual printed photos. Also, if the image is blurred, it wont get printed anyway so it's best just to use the ISO and see what happens ;)
 
Because I read somewhere that it causes 'fuzzy photos' - I really shouldn't read stuff, it makes my head hurt.

As far as I know, this type of system only really causes 'fuzzy photos' when used on a tripod (and, even then, when the system is one of the older ones). For most hand-held shooting where you're not trying to freeze motion, I would use the OS, if I were you.
 
Tell you what, I'll let you into a secret.

Nobody in here from a camera maker? No?
Good!

They like to tell you that the camera has lots of fancy electronics, but it isn't really like that.

You try looking into the end of the lens. See anything?
Yep. Thats right, there is someone in there. A small pixie. Yes really. Where do you think pixels came from?

This is how it works:

The pixie has a selection of paints and brushes. When you tweak the settings it alters what the pixie can use.

Aperture: The aperture sets the paint nozzle size. A small aperture means that the paint gets squeezed onto the pixie quite slowly through a small nozzle and that means that he (or she - no sexism in pixieland) has time to paint the whole view in some detail, so everything is in focus. Whereas a wide apperture nozzle means that the paint comes in really quickly as big dollops and the pixie has to do a bit of a Rolf Harris and while they try to get the main subject painted neatly everything else gets splashed on a bit and people say that your painting gets a narrow DoF.

The shutter is just a window into the pixie compartment, so if it just flaps open quickly the pixie sees a still image. If the window is open for a while though (I'm afraid that they can't get the brightest of pixies in contract) the pixie tries to paint the things that change, so you get motion blur. Oh, and of course the paint only comes out of the aperture nozzles while the shutter window is open.

Then the final part is ISO, this just changes the size of the brush the pixie uses. Low iso gives a nice small brush, so your painting gets lots of nice detail. High Iso gets your pixie an emulsion brush and while it is true that some pixies are better at using big brushes than others they all end up with what people call grain or noise.

And really, that's all there is to it.
 
Tell you what, I'll let you into a secret.

Nobody in here from a camera maker? No?
Good!

They like to tell you that the camera has lots of fancy electronics, but it isn't really like that.

You try looking into the end of the lens. See anything?
Yep. Thats right, there is someone in there. A small pixie. Yes really. Where do you think pixels came from?

This is how it works:

The pixie has a selection of paints and brushes. When you tweak the settings it alters what the pixie can use.

Aperture: The aperture sets the paint nozzle size. A small aperture means that the paint gets squeezed onto the pixie quite slowly through a small nozzle and that means that he (or she - no sexism in pixieland) has time to paint the whole view in some detail, so everything is in focus. Whereas a wide apperture nozzle means that the paint comes in really quickly as big dollops and the pixie has to do a bit of a Rolf Harris and while they try to get the main subject painted neatly everything else gets splashed on a bit and people say that your painting gets a narrow DoF.

The shutter is just a window into the pixie compartment, so if it just flaps open quickly the pixie sees a still image. If the window is open for a while though (I'm afraid that they can't get the brightest of pixies in contract) the pixie tries to paint the things that change, so you get motion blur. Oh, and of course the paint only comes out of the aperture nozzles while the shutter window is open.

Then the final part is ISO, this just changes the size of the brush the pixie uses. Low iso gives a nice small brush, so your painting gets lots of nice detail. High Iso gets your pixie an emulsion brush and while it is true that some pixies are better at using big brushes than others they all end up with what people call grain or noise.

And really, that's all there is to it.

:clap::clap::clap::clap::clap: THANK YOU :thumbs:
 
Tell you what, I'll let you into a secret.

Nobody in here from a camera maker? No?
Good!

They like to tell you that the camera has lots of fancy electronics, but it isn't really like that.

You try looking into the end of the lens. See anything?
Yep. Thats right, there is someone in there. A small pixie. Yes really. Where do you think pixels came from?

This is how it works:

The pixie has a selection of paints and brushes. When you tweak the settings it alters what the pixie can use.

Aperture: The aperture sets the paint nozzle size. A small aperture means that the paint gets squeezed onto the pixie quite slowly through a small nozzle and that means that he (or she - no sexism in pixieland) has time to paint the whole view in some detail, so everything is in focus. Whereas a wide apperture nozzle means that the paint comes in really quickly as big dollops and the pixie has to do a bit of a Rolf Harris and while they try to get the main subject painted neatly everything else gets splashed on a bit and people say that your painting gets a narrow DoF.

The shutter is just a window into the pixie compartment, so if it just flaps open quickly the pixie sees a still image. If the window is open for a while though (I'm afraid that they can't get the brightest of pixies in contract) the pixie tries to paint the things that change, so you get motion blur. Oh, and of course the paint only comes out of the aperture nozzles while the shutter window is open.

Then the final part is ISO, this just changes the size of the brush the pixie uses. Low iso gives a nice small brush, so your painting gets lots of nice detail. High Iso gets your pixie an emulsion brush and while it is true that some pixies are better at using big brushes than others they all end up with what people call grain or noise.

And really, that's all there is to it.
terry pratchett fan?
 
Some entertaining answers provided already.

This is a nice explanation of how changing one thing affects the other settings. (click on the small pictures for more info)
 
Thanks to everyone who contributed, I read, re-read and messed with my camera in the kitchen till the wee hours before retiring to my bed with a headache, BUT I think I finally get it. Now to put it into practice.

I may also break with tradition and grab a copy of 'Understanding Exposure' and just hope it does'nt confuse me.

Aligibbs - the webpage is cracking and helped no end.
 
:clap::clap::clap::clap::clap: THANK YOU :thumbs:

As long as it helps.:D

terry pratchett fan?

Not really, but I see where you're coming from.

When I first started I read lots and the usual story is the filling a bucket:

To get a good exposure you need to fill the bucket with water. The aperture is how much the tap is on, the shutter speed is how long the tap is on and the iso is the bucket size.

That gives you the inter-relationship between the three, but leaves out the impact of varying one rather than the other. You could say that the amount of turbulence on the surface of the bucket reflects the DoF, but it isnt a great analogy.

The first film I took, I went out to a local site and took a load of photos varying the shutter speed and aperture keeping the exposure indicator as being correct. I screwed up because the thing I took pics of didnt actually demonstrate the variation - which left me not understanding (was a rock formation at brimham), because there was no motion and it didn't show the dof variation. It wasn't until I bought a dslr and played around that I realised the real impact.

To my mind you can think of the sensor (or film) as being the image painter, ISO is sensitivity - so brush size, aperture sets how much light gets in at once so paint flow, and shutter speed is how long the painting takes.
The pixie paints for as long as the shutter is open, but has to use the brush you chose and deal with as much paint as you throw at him/her. Which lets me think about the results of over/under exposure as well as getting it exactly right. Too much paint, either because he paints for too long or you use big dollops or a huge brush and your picture is over done. Too little and you don't get the canvas covered properly.
It is just using paint as an analogy for light in what was I hope an amusing way.
 
Also try and make sure that the shutter speed is higher/faster than the focal length of the lens. This means (if i have got it right) that if you have say a 50mm lens on your camera your shutter speed needs to be faster than 1/50th of a second so 1/60th, 1/70th etc etc would be better. If it were 1/40th of a second then you will have a blurry pic unless you have MEGA steady hands.

I find that low light hand held is very very hard to get sharp images. I have come to realise that a tripod is essential and if you don't want to be seen with a tripod all over the place then a monopod is great for reducing camera shake. They are cheap so give it a go or borrow one. They are alot less intrusive than a Tripod. It all depends what you are shooting.

There are tutorials on how to shoot hand held on the new.

This is very true, but also bear in mind the working focal length of your lens will be much longer with a cropped sensor so a 50mm lens on a cropped body will require a shutter speed of 1/80 rather that 1/50 (50mm x 1.6 = 80mm).
 
as a newbie, thanks for a great post goes to robc :thumbs: and thanks to all who replied:clap: enjoyed reading and hopefully learnt a lot just got to remember it now :cuckoo:
 
Back
Top