I wouldn't have a clue how to quantify the effect in terms of perceived noise, but you can pull out the WB multipliers from most raw files for different settings. These will show that R and B channels are almost always weak compared to G and need some degree of boosting. Just how much depends on how far off balance the light source is.
...snip
So switching between tungsten lighting and shaded conditions there is a big swing between the multipliers needed for the R and B channels. If you compound those natural (almost unavoidable) underexposures at the sensor with additional underexposure through poor camera operation then the potential for excessive noise is increased further.
.
Thanks Tim, yeah bad question, thanks for trying. I can see there are huge flutuations for both B and R gain as the light type changes. Ive not seen that angle of view before, very informative thanks for the details.
I took the OP's line - 'So ... why is {ISO 3200, f/1.4, 1/90th} noisier than {ISO 3200, f/8, 1/90th}, if the two photos are both
exposed correctly?' _ to mean exactly or literarily perfect light wise, or WB wise if you like. ( I tailored it because I thought Stewart probably knew about histograms pushing to the right and whatnot)
So two shots both using the same quantity of light, and the same quality of light, to achieve correct exposure.
Would you agree that in that scenario RGGB Bayer gain adjustments will be the same for both shots.
Which does only leave our first thoughts, the oof CoC will cause errors naturally, and emphasised even more by a high ISO ...Unlike good sharp CoC which wont trigger such gain/multiplier side effects like noise at the same high iso.
That's EXACTLY what I was trying to say. I think Tim/tdodd has produced some very good arguments as to why it might not be true, but that is what I was trying to say.
:Cough: I see you not included me in that good argument line. So does that mean you really didn't understand me? ... I though you'd know I was referring to Circles of Confusion and DoF.
Or more precisely the angles of the light rays within the focus clusters of light at the focal plane, which all work together to produce the DoF effect .
Yes, Tim makes some valid points, especially his point 2 (post 24) - we can't try it out though without some serious measuring gear and a laboratory.
Assuming we could accurately control the light levels to produce shots 1 & 2 (post 38) without changing the colour of the light at all, the noise in both shots should be exactly the same (ignoring 'perceived noise' due to more parts of the f1.4 shot being OOF).
Yes I agree. the only difference between the shots is one contains some oof CoC and the other doesn’t.
My thoughs are,after reading Tims stuff and refreshing myself on the interweb this morning...
Some of the light making that exposure of the f1.4 image will be poorly defined onto the Bayer array, this poor definition is then attenuated into noise when processed through at the Raw level ...leavening perhaps half the information available to produce the good noise free clarity of the f8 shot.