- Messages
- 11,513
- Name
- Stewart
- Edit My Images
- Yes
I'm confused. I'd be grateful if someone could help me become unconfused.
The background
There's a discussion on another thread (which I don't want to hijack) which has touched on the suitability or otherwise of a Nikon D90 for low-light photography such as weddings.
One contributor argued that ISO 3200 is quite useable:
That photo was actually taken in decent light, and using ISO 3200 was an accident by the photographer. But then lots of other people weighed in to say that it in low light there would be much more noise:
Why I'm confused
The photo which I've included above was taken at {ISO 3200, f/8, 1/90th}. I'd say it looks quite reasonably exposed, so those parameters are clearly about right for the prevailing light level.
Now, suppose that shot had been taken in a dim church where there was 5 stops less light (ie only about 3% of the light available in that photo). But suppose that the photographer also had an f/1.4 lens available to him. By a fortunate coincidence f/1.4 is 5 stops faster than the f/8 he actually used. So he could shoot at {ISO 3200, f/1.4, 1/90th} and the exposure would be correct.
So ... why is {ISO 3200, f/1.4, 1/90th} noisier than {ISO 3200, f/8, 1/90th}, if the two photos are both exposed correctly?
The background
There's a discussion on another thread (which I don't want to hijack) which has touched on the suitability or otherwise of a Nikon D90 for low-light photography such as weddings.
One contributor argued that ISO 3200 is quite useable:
This is at 3200 on the kit lens (18-105) straight out the camera with no noise reduction
![]()
Not perfect but usable
That photo was actually taken in decent light, and using ISO 3200 was an accident by the photographer. But then lots of other people weighed in to say that it in low light there would be much more noise:
... with the light you have noise will be less than if taken in a dark church.
... in a brighter room the noise will be far less than in a dark room.
Yes totally agree
I see this quite a lot, even some of the bloggers who test new kit show ISO tests in a lit room in normal circumstances and say 'Yeah no noise at ISO6400 blah blah this camera is really great blah blah"
It all changes when you turn the lights off....
Correct, there is a difference in taking a shot at 3200ISO in nice light or a dark church.
Why I'm confused
The photo which I've included above was taken at {ISO 3200, f/8, 1/90th}. I'd say it looks quite reasonably exposed, so those parameters are clearly about right for the prevailing light level.
Now, suppose that shot had been taken in a dim church where there was 5 stops less light (ie only about 3% of the light available in that photo). But suppose that the photographer also had an f/1.4 lens available to him. By a fortunate coincidence f/1.4 is 5 stops faster than the f/8 he actually used. So he could shoot at {ISO 3200, f/1.4, 1/90th} and the exposure would be correct.
So ... why is {ISO 3200, f/1.4, 1/90th} noisier than {ISO 3200, f/8, 1/90th}, if the two photos are both exposed correctly?