Another disappointing performance from England yesterday. Yes they won, and yes Portugal are ranked higher than us by FIFA (although that ranking would presumably be based on playing with 11 men including Ronaldo). But it's so painfully obvious that Roy Hodgson is continuing to play payers out of position, and thereby nullifying the reasons that got them into the squad in the first place. Vardy didn't score all those goals from the wing. Kane didn't score all those goals by taking corners. Alli didn't put in such a string of great performances by playing out wide. But Hodgson is forcing them into unfamiliar positions in order to accommodate Rooney, and it isn't working.
One obvious solution is to drop Rooney. But I have another idea.
Recently I was re-reading 'All Played Out' by Pete Davies. It's a great book about the Italia 1990 World Cup, and without doubt the best football book I have ever read. Highly recommended if you haven't read it. But anyway in the book Davies describes how England accidentally hit on their best formation. After the 1-1 draw against Ireland, our next opponents were Holland, and manager Bobby Robson was worried about the Dutch attacking threat. So he decided to play an entirely new formation, with 3 centre backs (Terry Butcher, Mark Wright, Des Walker). His idea was that 5 at the back would give us a solid defensive platform, but the surprising effect was that it allowed the two full backs (Stuart Pearce and Paul Parker) to get forward much more easily. 5-4-1 turned into 3-4-3 very fluidly. We had the best of the game and deserved to win it.
Robson's formation:
Shilton / Parker - Butcher - Wright - Walker - Pearce / Barnes - Robson - Gascoigne - Waddle / Lineker
So could something like this work for England? Something like:
Hart / Walker - Stones - Cahill - Smalling - Rose / Alli - Dier - Rooney / Vardy - Kane
Or you could put Dier in the back three and use someone like Milner or Wilshire in midfield. Let's face it, we're not short of midfield options.
My thinking is that it would allow Walker and Rose to get forward without leaving the back too exposed. They would provide the width we need, so Vardy and Kane wouldn't get dragged all over the pitch. And everyone is playing more-or-less in their regular positions.
It might be a crap idea, but at least it's an idea. Roy Hodgson doesn't seem to have any.