Have you seen a misleading "lenses for hire" advert?

Messages
11,513
Name
Stewart
Edit My Images
Yes
I've had my attention drawn to a new UK lens hire company which seems to be trying to exploit the good reputation I've built up over the last couple of years. Whilst I'm quite relaxed about competition - indeed I think it's good for the industry as a whole if there are a number of suppliers, so long as they do it well - I'm less relaxed about the idea that they're trying to profit from our name.

If you see an advert for "lenses for hire" which isn't from us (all our adverts look pretty much like the banner in my signature here), I'd be very grateful if you could grab a screenshot for me and let me know when and were you saw it. I'm aware that they're advertising on Facebook, but they may be doing so elsewhere as well.

So far the owners of this new business seem to be pretty co-operative. When I pointed out to them that their home page was liberally sprinkled with references to "lenses for hire" and that there were any number of equally descriptive phrases in the English language which they could use, they did rewrite it quite promptly. When I pointed out that their FAQ was a word-for-word copy of ours, they did rewrite it. So I'm quite reassured that we can get along happily - but I do want to ensure they stick to the straight and narrow!

Thanks for your help.
 
Yes ive seen lens pimp too, similar prices and similar ethics to you stuart
 
Is the company calling itself "Lenses For Hire" or is it advertising Lenses for Hire? If it is the former then understandably you should be losing your rag with them. If it is the latter though, then I'm not sure you can do anything about it because they aren't really doing anything illegal unless you have the phrase "Lenses for Hire" trademarked, which would never happen. I imagine the phrase "Cars for Hire" is on every single car rental firms website, but they can't really do anything about it.

More to the point though, why be bothered? Your website address matches what your business does PERFECTLY, and because of this you have gained an advantage over every single competitor you have. I've just typed in LENSES FOR HIRE into Google, and apart from the sponsored links, your top! :)
 
Surely when you register your business name it's copyright to you and your company only ?

There's a world of difference between trademark and copyright.

The company breached copyright when they copied LFH's FAQ verbatim.

The other issue is called passing off.
 
Surely when you register your business name it's copyright to you and your company only ?
No, it's not quite as simple as that.

I don't - and can't - have any kind of ownership of the phrase "lenses for hire". They're all normal words in the English language, strung together in a normal way.

I can protect my trademark, which is a combination of the phrase, font, logo, etc. But that wouldn't be terribly useful because I can't see another company realistically wanting to try to use my logo!

However, what this company is doing which is naughty is called "passing off". From Wikipedia:
Passing off is a common law tort which can be used to enforce unregistered trademark rights. The tort of passing off protects the goodwill of a trader from a misrepresentation that causes damage to goodwill.

The law of passing off prevents one person from misrepresenting his or her goods or services as being the goods and services of the claimant, and also prevents one person from holding out his or her goods or services as having some association or connection with the plaintiff when this is not true.
 
Surely when you register your business name it's copyright to you and your company only ?
Registered/trademarked/"owned"/whatever. Anybody could still start up a business and call it whatever they want until somebody complains (or they try to register it themselves). Never heard the story about the kid in Canada who used his own name as part of his business name (Mike Rowe) then got sued by guess who? :)

If I see anything Stewart, I'll let you know. :)
 
you realise you've pointed it out to people and they are cheaper for the lens I was thinking about hiring lol
 
you realise you've pointed it out to people and they are cheaper for the lens I was thinking about hiring lol
And your point is...? If you want to hire from them, hire from them. If you want the cheapest price, get the cheapest price. It's a free world.
 
I hope you can sort out your concerns Stuart. While I have not had cause to use your service, I see nothing but praise for you and your company. It would be tragic if someone was able to ruin your excellent reputation by 'passing off' as you and yours.

Good Luck :thumbs:
 
Is the company calling itself "Lenses For Hire" or is it advertising Lenses for Hire? If it is the former then understandably you should be losing your rag with them. If it is the latter though, then I'm not sure you can do anything about it because they aren't really doing anything illegal unless you have the phrase "Lenses for Hire" trademarked, which would never happen. I imagine the phrase "Cars for Hire" is on every single car rental firms website, but they can't really do anything about it.

More to the point though, why be bothered? Your website address matches what your business does PERFECTLY, and because of this you have gained an advantage over every single competitor you have. I've just typed in LENSES FOR HIRE into Google, and apart from the sponsored links, your top! :)

I have to agree. A company offering lens hire has a perfect right to use the phrase 'lenses for hire'. Sure they could use alternative phrases, but it would be a very hard job to prove 'passing off' based on that phrase alone.

Part of the problem of having a common phrase as your business name I'm afraid.
 
To be honest, if I ran "Company X", and I offered "Lenses for Hire", you can be 100% sure that if someone googles "Lenses for Hire" I would pay to have my site displayed....without wanting to offend, you have chosen a business name which is EXACTLY the same as the term used for searching for said service....

For example.

Burger King becomes Fast Food Burgers
Nike becomes Sports Shoes
Play.com becomes DVD's and CD's

So whilst I can understand how upset / annoyed you must be, in my opinion, if hiring lenses is what they do, then "Lenses for Hire" is fair play - it's a valid search string / ad title, as it says exactly what it does on the tin.

Of course the whole EX Customer / ripped content from your site makes this even more difficult to swallow, but still, a valid search string & ad title - not sure if anything can be done or even should be done about it?

Gary.
 
And your point is...? If you want to hire from them, hire from them. If you want the cheapest price, get the cheapest price. It's a free world.

Stewart,
As one of your customers, I can see your concerns with your branding, but remember this "people buy from people they trust" and for the quality of service, and your company offers exceptional service on all counts:)
 
Stewart,
As one of your customers, I can see your concerns with your branding, but remember this "people buy from people they trust" and for the quality of service, and your company offers exceptional service on all counts:)

The trouble is, because of the company name being identical to a generic search string, it's very easy for someone to sit up top on google for a few pence a click, and as long as they make all the right sounds, take away business - completely legit too.

Gary.
 
Well the name 'Lenspimp' puts me off, it just doesn't sound right to me :shrug:
 
And your point is...? If you want to hire from them, hire from them. If you want the cheapest price, get the cheapest price. It's a free world.



my point is that while they may have copied some of your txt which I agree is wrong from what I've seen they are not trying to using your reputation in their advertistments. I could see they are a different company straight away there is nothing misleading about it.
 
To be honest, if I ran "Company X", and I offered "Lenses for Hire", you can be 100% sure that if someone googles "Lenses for Hire" I would pay to have my site displayed....without wanting to offend, you have chosen a business name which is EXACTLY the same as the term used for searching for said service....

For example.

Burger King becomes Fast Food Burgers
Nike becomes Sports Shoes
Play.com becomes DVD's and CD's

So whilst I can understand how upset / annoyed you must be, in my opinion, if hiring lenses is what they do, then "Lenses for Hire" is fair play - it's a valid search string / ad title, as it says exactly what it does on the tin.

Of course the whole EX Customer / ripped content from your site makes this even more difficult to swallow, but still, a valid search string & ad title - not sure if anything can be done or even should be done about it?

Gary.

When I first saw the name "LensPimp" I thought it was your doing, Gary :lol:

I had a similar situation years ago with a former business, another garage opened up in the next town doing exactly the same sort of work and with a similar name. It also didn't help that both businesses were located in streets with almost identical names.

The first I knew about it was when an irate customer phoned up complaining about the service at our "other" branch ......
 
Well the name 'Lenspimp' puts me off, it just doesn't sound right to me :shrug:

I thought that too until I realised there has been a new meaning for PIMP recently as in the TV series "Pimp my ride" as in to make better or improve I think.

Having said that some of the cars they turn out they would not be out of place in a pimps garage :D

David
 
When I first saw the name "LensPimp" I thought it was your doing, Gary :lol:

I had a similar situation years ago with a former business, another business opened up in the next town doing exactly the same sort of work and with a similar name. It also didn't help that both businesses were located in streets with the same name. The first I knew about it was when an irate customer phoned up complaining about the service at our "other" branch ......

EgoPimp :D Close but no cigar!
 
I've just checked out their prices, as I might be hiring a lens next month, and they seem considerably cheaper Stewart!!?? :o

If I do decide to hire, it will be with you guys, but they are obviously a threat!! :) :(
 
PS - Their site, and wording, especially the bit about delivery and returns is very similar to yours!!
 
... I'm not sure you can do anything about it because they aren't really doing anything illegal unless you have the phrase "Lenses for Hire" trademarked, which would never happen.

I have to agree. A company offering lens hire has a perfect right to use the phrase 'lenses for hire'. Sure they could use alternative phrases, but it would be a very hard job to prove 'passing off' based on that phrase alone.

Part of the problem of having a common phrase as your business name I'm afraid.

Mmmm. Legally it's a grey area. The advice I've received is that:
  • their repeated use of the phrase "lenses for hire"
  • PLUS their non-use of other equivalent phrases such as "cameras for hire", "lens hire", "camera and lens hire", etc
  • PLUS the fact that they copied our FAQ word-for-word
  • PLUS the fact that they copied other data from our web site word-for-word
does constitute grounds for a complaint regarding "passing off". But like I said earlier, they've been quite decent so far about changing it all when I asked. I don'rt want to sue anybody. I just want to encourage them to play fair, and that's what I'm doing.
 
Mmmm. Legally it's a grey area. The advice I've received is that:
  • their repeated use of the phrase "lenses for hire"
  • PLUS their non-use of other equivalent phrases such as "cameras for hire", "lens hire", "camera and lens hire", etc
  • PLUS the fact that they copied our FAQ word-for-word
  • PLUS the fact that they copied other data from our web site word-for-word
does constitute grounds for a complaint regarding "passing off". But like I said earlier, they've been quite decent so far about changing it all when I asked. I don'rt want to sue anybody. I just want to encourage them to play fair, and that's what I'm doing.


I did say "it would be a very hard job to prove 'passing off' based on that phrase alone."

I don;t see the problem in repeating the phrase 'lenses for hire' and not using 'cameras for hire' afterall, most people will search for the former.

The other items are certainly underhand and i hope you get it resolved amicably.
 
One other thing I would add, you have just advertised this lot to a photography forum with several thousand members....

Why?
Because I was asking the members here if they could alert me to examples of misleading advertising.

It's not as if I can hide their existence from view or pretend they don't exist.

... they are obviously a threat!! :) :(

I don't think so.

As I've said before, competition isn't something to be afraid of. For example I get on very well with the people who run HireACamera.com, because they provide a good service and they look after theor customers. If I have a customer who wants something we don't have, I'll happily pass them on to HAC, and vice versa. By doing so I think we're both helping to make the concept of hiring a lens (or a camera) seem respectable and routine.

On the other hand there are companies out there (I don't need to name them) who don't seem to share the same commitment to customer service that LFH and HAC have. The real threat is that if too many people get let down by these cowboys, then the whole hiring industry gets tarred with the same brush.

So, given that this new company exists, I hope they do well. I hope they look after their customers like we do. And if they can do all that and maintain low prices, that will act as a spur to all of us to think hard about our market offerings and to innovate.
 
Mmmm. Legally it's a grey area. The advice I've received is that:
  • their repeated use of the phrase "lenses for hire"
  • PLUS their non-use of other equivalent phrases such as "cameras for hire", "lens hire", "camera and lens hire", etc
  • PLUS the fact that they copied our FAQ word-for-word
  • PLUS the fact that they copied other data from our web site word-for-word
does constitute grounds for a complaint regarding "passing off". But like I said earlier, they've been quite decent so far about changing it all when I asked. I don'rt want to sue anybody. I just want to encourage them to play fair, and that's what I'm doing.

Echoing what has already been said, regardless of how closely they mimmick your site the trading name would immediately put me off dealing with them - I have a picture in my mind of this guy being at the other end of the phone.....

Pimp.jpg



:lol:
 
I've just checked out their prices, as I might be hiring a lens next month, and they seem considerably cheaper Stewart!!?? :o

That's because the way they derived their prices was basically to copy all ours and then take x% off.

Another difference is that we now show our prices including insurance, because >95% of our customers want it, but they show their prices excluding insurance.
 
PS - Their site, and wording, especially the bit about delivery and returns is very similar to yours!!
When I first came across their site it was 100% the same as ours. I asked them to rewrite it in their own words, and they have done so - more or less. Some bits still bear a noticeable resemblance to the "original" version.
 
I notice they offer flashguns, which is something I've thought you should offer for a while.
Mmmm. They offer a lot of stuff. It would be interesting to know how much of this stuff they actually have. If they've got one of everything that's shown on their web site, I reckon they've spent about £150k to launch. That's a lot of money.
 
If you trade under a descriptive name that 'Does what it says on the tin' then you always run a risk of confusion. And passing off is rife in all markets and businesses. (Inspire? Venture? :D ) TBH, if you don't research your best competitors and copy as much of the good things they do as closely as possible, and try to better them if you can, then you'll not get far. I don't suppose Stewart that you came up with your own terms and conditions without checking the competition very carefully, but then made your own version.

You'll not get far in any passing off action unless you can at least present some solid evidence of genuine customer confusion. Looking at the LensPimp site, it is a million miles from yours Stewart. No possible confusion there at all.

The fact that they might have copied some of your text a little too closely is entirely different, and more than a little moot. Without checking, I'm pretty sure most lens hire firms will have quite similar terms, and the same phrases will come up because they're generic. I don't doubt for a second that some pretty obvious copying has been going on, but that's life. Embarrassing mistake, they change it, issue resolved.

If their prices are lower, it's probably a launch marketing tactic. And unless you are making a bit too much margin on your business, which is always dangerous because it allows room for competitors to come in, then they will have to raise them.
 
Back
Top