Hidden Danger - a word to the unwary.

Messages
1,584
Name
Barry
Edit My Images
No
Not sure if this is the correct section but felt OOF wasn't.

Attended an interesting course today that , for me, re-highlighted a hidden danger that maybe we aren't all aware of as photographers of a certain genre.
I am also not given to scare mongering:D

There have been a number of threads with shots taken in dilapidated buildings both with models and without. Fine, some would say, apart from the obvious danger of possible collapse, or getting nicked for trespass ;). There is, however a danger that most would not realise, which would not be immediately apparent in it's results.

The vast majority of commercial buildings, built or renovated pre 1980, will undoubtedly contain varying levels of Asbestos. In it's undamaged state it presents little or no risk - conversely it can be an unseen killer. Damage, particularly from partial collapse can cause clouds of Asbestos fibre to float in the air for days on end - for the unwary visitor to breath in.

Chances of it killing you directly - slim, as we will all have varying degrees of Asbestos contamination in our bodies when we die in any event. I used to work with a guy who died of lung cancer brought on by Asbestosis so am well aware of it's worse conclusions.
Prolonged exposure, especially if you are smoking in the same environment means you are more likely to succumb.

Apart from anything else, and this refers directly to posters to a website devoted to photographing dilapidated buildings - hospitals and asylums being favourites, there are companies actively involved in monitoring that particular site who are in contact with the HSE who are well aware of the risks and dangerous risks being taken by some photographers:thinking:

Certainly made me think twice.
 
Last edited:
Moved to talk photography ;)
 
Just been reading about some of the risks with urbex and it would seem that asbestos is just one of many risks, but I'd have said that sharp objects, falls and having things fall on you are probably greater risks
http://www.urbanxphotography.co.uk/page13836.html
having said that it's no doubt the element of risk that attracts people to urbex in the same way that extreme sports enthusiasts are attracted by a certain element of risk.
 
Apart from anything else, and this refers directly to posters to a website devoted to photographing dilapidated buildings - hospitals and asylums being favourites, there are companies actively involved in monitoring that particular site who are in contact with the HSE who are well aware of the risks and dangerous risks being taken by some photographers:thinking:

Everyone on those sites knows that they are monitored, but not many are going to believe that the HSE would take a direct interest in individuals engaged in urbex. The HSE would only be interested in the owners/occupiers of the site for a breach of their duty (specifically the Occupiers Liability Act 1984). Matters relating to trespass (a civil matter) would be dealt with by the police.

I sincerely hope the rest of the presentation was more accurate, asbestos is a very serious subject. As are other risks associated with derelict structures.
 
Matters relating to trespass (a civil matter) would be dealt with by the police.

I would doubt that the police would do anything in a case of simple trespass (as you say, a civil matter) and short of the trespasser committing a criminal offence while trespassing (like criminal damage or theft) the police probably wouldn't even bother to turn up.

The only time it really becomes a police matter is under Section 61 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, but again, it involves other circumstances that wouldn't apply to urbex.
 
I would doubt that the police would do anything in a case of simple trespass (as you say, a civil matter) and short of the trespasser committing a criminal offence while trespassing (like criminal damage or theft) the police probably wouldn't even bother to turn up.

The only time it really becomes a police matter is under Section 61 of the Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994, but again, it involves other circumstances that wouldn't apply to urbex.

It's certainly not unusual for them to turn up in response to a report from a site owner, security or a concerned member of the public. Under these circumstances it's not possible to identify if it's a photographer, graffiti tagger or a metal thief until they ask questions. They have to turn up to determine whether or not it is a criminal matter rather than just civil.
 
Everyone on those sites knows that they are monitored, but not many are going to believe that the HSE would take a direct interest in individuals engaged in urbex. The HSE would only be interested in the owners/occupiers of the site for a breach of their duty (specifically the Occupiers Liability Act 1984). Matters relating to trespass (a civil matter) would be dealt with by the police.

I sincerely hope the rest of the presentation was more accurate, asbestos is a very serious subject. As are other risks associated with derelict structures.

Not what I said - but you are correct that the HSE would not be interested in individuals. It would the safety, or not, of the site which would interest them.

It is also extremely unlikely that the police would get involved and would undoubtedly cite manpower, or lack of, together with unrealistic workload to get a conviction by way of a reason.
 
Not what I said - but you are correct that the HSE would not be interested in individuals. It would the safety, or not, of the site which would interest them.

there are companies actively involved in monitoring that particular site who are in contact with the HSE who are well aware of the risks and dangerous risks being taken by some photographers

Sounds like that's what you said. Otherwise why are "certain companies" in contact with the HSE?

It is also extremely unlikely that the police would get involved and would undoubtedly cite manpower, or lack of, together with unrealistic workload to get a conviction by way of a reason.

If you read the urbex sites you would see that the police do get involved. They have even been known to arrive in force before the forum members arrive on site..
 
not too big a deal - Have you seen the sort of people that go around taking pics of dilapidated buildings :lol:


no tresspass in scotland though

Not sure if this is the correct section but felt OOF wasn't.

Attended an interesting course today that , for me, re-highlighted a hidden danger that maybe we aren't all aware of as photographers of a certain genre.
I am also not given to scare mongering:D

There have been a number of threads with shots taken in dilapidated buildings both with models and without. Fine, some would say, apart from the obvious danger of possible collapse, or getting nicked for trespass ;). There is, however a danger that most would not realise, which would not be immediately apparent in it's results.

The vast majority of commercial buildings, built or renovated pre 1980, will undoubtedly contain varying levels of Asbestos. In it's undamaged state it presents little or no risk - conversely it can be an unseen killer. Damage, particularly from partial collapse can cause clouds of Asbestos fibre to float in the air for days on end - for the unwary visitor to breath in.

Chances of it killing you directly - slim, as we will all have varying degrees of Asbestos contamination in our bodies when we die in any event. I used to work with a guy who died of lung cancer brought on by Asbestosis so am well aware of it's worse conclusions.
Prolonged exposure, especially if you are smoking in the same environment means you are more likely to succumb.

Apart from anything else, and this refers directly to posters to a website devoted to photographing dilapidated buildings - hospitals and asylums being favourites, there are companies actively involved in monitoring that particular site who are in contact with the HSE who are well aware of the risks and dangerous risks being taken by some photographers:thinking:

Certainly made me think twice.
 
@ Alastair

Sorry to be pedantic but again I didn't say 'certain companies', however I do mean companies having a vested interest. Read into that what you will.

I have scanned the site you mention but have no interest in it's content.

The point made in my original post was about hidden danger - not to support or otherwise the people who do that type of thing or visit the site, or the companies who may monitor it or police action/inaction. I mention the site as a side-comment.

If it floats peoples boats to photograph in dangerous or illegal situations c'est la vie.
 
Last edited:
I've been an electrician for 20+ years and have been exposed to asbestos while installing lighting in false ceilings containing the "white" variety, also pipe lagging in older boiler rooms which has since been encapsulated.

Unfortunately there is a 30+ year incubation period with it and no known cure so as worrying as it is unless symptoms begin there is very little I can do about it. Not going to dwell on it though, could quite easily get run over by a bus tomorrow :)
 
Not sure if this is the correct section but felt OOF wasn't.

Attended an interesting course today that , for me, re-highlighted a hidden danger that maybe we aren't all aware of as photographers of a certain genre.
I am also not given to scare mongering:D

There have been a number of threads with shots taken in dilapidated buildings both with models and without. Fine, some would say, apart from the obvious danger of possible collapse, or getting nicked for trespass ;). There is, however a danger that most would not realise, which would not be immediately apparent in it's results.

The vast majority of commercial buildings, built or renovated pre 1980, will undoubtedly contain varying levels of Asbestos. In it's undamaged state it presents little or no risk - conversely it can be an unseen killer. Damage, particularly from partial collapse can cause clouds of Asbestos fibre to float in the air for days on end - for the unwary visitor to breath in.

Chances of it killing you directly - slim, as we will all have varying degrees of Asbestos contamination in our bodies when we die in any event. I used to work with a guy who died of lung cancer brought on by Asbestosis so am well aware of it's worse conclusions.
Prolonged exposure, especially if you are smoking in the same environment means you are more likely to succumb.

Apart from anything else, and this refers directly to posters to a website devoted to photographing dilapidated buildings - hospitals and asylums being favourites, there are companies actively involved in monitoring that particular site who are in contact with the HSE who are well aware of the risks and dangerous risks being taken by some photographers:thinking:

Certainly made me think twice.

A very valid point :thumbs: However I doubt many of those into Urbex would even give it a second thought :shrug: Asbestos is everywhere and costs a fortune to replace or get rid of, thus gets left where it is and more fool those who choose to play around it. It only takes a minuscule amount to do the damage..... Each to their own, I guess
 
I've been an electrician for 20+ years and have been exposed to asbestos while installing lighting in false ceilings containing the "white" variety, also pipe lagging in older boiler rooms which has since been encapsulated.

Unfortunately there is a 30+ year incubation period with it and no known cure so as worrying as it is unless symptoms begin there is very little I can do about it. Not going to dwell on it though, could quite easily get run over by a bus tomorrow :)

I'm with you there - I worked for a Thermal Insulation company during the late 70's when the big deal with 'deadly' Asbestos really hit.

Like you I prefer not to think about it:thumbs:
 
Last edited:
Yep asbestos is only a problem if it's disturbed as long as you leave it well alone you should be fine. Heavy metals and other contaminants would probably be a greater risk unseen risk. Some fantastic images can be created in these buildings so I see the attraction.
 
Yep asbestos is only a problem if it's disturbed as long as you leave it well alone you should be fine. Heavy metals and other contaminants would probably be a greater risk unseen risk. Some fantastic images can be created in these buildings so I see the attraction.

Indeed! but how does anyone know if it's been disturbed? it could be anything from wind to floor boards, etc!
 
not too big a deal - Have you seen the sort of people that go around taking pics of dilapidated buildings :lol:


no tresspass in scotland though

Actually there is, but even so there are plenty of other things one could be charged with in it's place, Malicious Mischief, Opening lockfast places with intent to steal, or that classic Scottish catch-all, Breach of the Peace......
 
Last edited:
It's not only asbestos though, life itself is a risk, just getting out of bed in the morning is probably more hazardous (especially if you have kids!). Too much emphasis on risk assessment and risk management nowadays, I get fed up with all the paperwork now involved in carrying out what can be a very simple task, sometimes the paperwork takes longer to complete than the ruddy job!.

If you are happy with the risks you are taking and will be the one who suffers for your actions then you only have yourself to blame. There is probably more chance you will be stabbed and killed for your camera gear in an old warehouse than suffer from asbestos related disease later in life :)
 
i was quite worried for myself and otheres after looking on theses sites.
guys i used to work for rented/used a large burnt out bunker in the middle of edinburgh for airsofting.
there were loads of us running around inside and coming out covered in black soot. this.was.going.on for months.
looking on these sites it seem that this place(barton quarry) is a very nasty place with lots of aspestos fibers floating around.
i can also garentee that the owner new about it and was still letting us use it many of us kid aswell as young as 16. he is now supposidly getting ut all removed to rebuild the place...

i woukd like to know where we qould stand legaly on this.
 
Last edited:
I do a spot of ubex-ing myself, theres a lot of other dangers as well as Asbestos.
 
Sorry to take this offtopic but what do you mean by no tresspass in Scotland?
 
I do a spot of ubex-ing myself, theres a lot of other dangers as well as Asbestos.

When needed, wear appropriate PPE.

There's a thread very high up in the 'general chat' section of a certain well known urbex forum about this exact matter. Worth a read for anyone interested.
 
Last edited:
much like our old pig sty and outside loo block, noted as requiring decontamination for asbestos before it was demolished....Knocked down with a JCB and loaded in the back of the buulders' transit. Job done.
 
much like our old pig sty and outside loo block, noted as requiring decontamination for asbestos before it was demolished....Knocked down with a JCB and loaded in the back of the buulders' transit. Job done.

And probably dumped at the side of the road somewhere.
 
Back
Top