How to deal with a breach of release form.

It hasn't been reproduced, they're still located at the same place they were always at.

How does a link or an img tag make a difference? They are both referencing a remote URL.
 
It hasn't been reproduced, they're still located at the same place they were always at.

How does a link or an img tag make a difference? They are both referencing a remote URL.

It isn't cut and dry and the circumstances of each case would affect the outcome. But as a broad rule, you could certainly be found guilty of copyright infringement whilst leaving the image in its original location.

For a more obvious example, imagine if this thread used the images as it did, but was entitled "Photoshopping Services For Hire" - a judge would decide in the favour of the artist every time in that case. Here it is less definite...but it doesn't hurt to play on the safe side of things.
 
It hasn't been reproduced, they're still located at the same place they were always at.

How does a link or an img tag make a difference? They are both referencing a remote URL.

It makes all the difference. That's how images get orphaned :nono: And it's a breach, regardless of the original location.
 
But regardless of the rights and wrongs of that, the OP posting them here is a clear and knowing infringement of the new joint copyright. I'm amazed that so many people seem to be unaware of what has happened there. And the OP's and others' comments made alleging the model's unprofessionalism and the artist's poor work only make matters worse.

I would hope to think that you accidentally missed my reply rather than ignored it...

I don't believe you can call the adaptations new and original pieces of artistic work as the main design of the image has remained the same. That is the test under the law (S. 64 Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988). If they were indeed new and original pieces of artistic works, there would be no joint authorship and we would not be having this discussion.

We already know they are copies of the original artistic works produced by the OP. Therefore, if the main design of the image is the same and they are copies, it stands to reason that they are infringing copies under S. 27 of the Act and the artist who created the adaptations does not own copyright over them.

Adaptations of artistic works are not covered under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, only Dramatic, Literary and Musical so we cannot use those sections to apply to this case.

All I see is you shooting down everyone else for not believing that these are new and original pieces of work, yet providing no support for your case as to why they are. We can argue until we are blue in the face, but a judge would be the only one deciding this case.

I would also like to reiterate my point on the ambiguity of the model release. It does not clearly state that under personal use, she cannot modify the works, it only states that under another section which could be argued does not apply to her.
 
I would hope to think that you accidentally missed my reply rather than ignored it...

RevOnline answered that reply, for which I thanked him. Perhaps you missed it in post #36.

I don't believe you can call the adaptations new and original pieces of artistic work as the main design of the image has remained the same. That is the test under the law (S. 64 Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988). If they were indeed new and original pieces of artistic works, there would be no joint authorship and we would not be having this discussion.

We already know they are copies of the original artistic works produced by the OP. Therefore, if the main design of the image is the same and they are copies, it stands to reason that they are infringing copies under S. 27 of the Act and the artist who created the adaptations does not own copyright over them.

Adaptations of artistic works are not covered under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, only Dramatic, Literary and Musical so we cannot use those sections to apply to this case.

All I see is you shooting down everyone else for not believing that these are new and original pieces of work, yet providing no support for your case as to why they are. We can argue until we are blue in the face, but a judge would be the only one deciding this case.

I would also like to reiterate my point on the ambiguity of the model release. It does not clearly state that under personal use, she cannot modify the works, it only states that under another section which could be argued does not apply to her.

I'm not trying to shoot anybody down, just explaining some basic fundamentals of copyright. If I believed there was any doubt about what I am saying, I would say so.

Joint ownership is very common these days, as even the slightest bit of photoshop retouching by a third party can theoretically claim independent copyright on that aspect of the image. Which is why when I have any photoshopping done, I have all rights to it assigned to me.

As you say, only a court can decide whether of not any such post production consitutes a new and original artwork, but in my experience (and I have worked in magazine publishing for a very long time where this happens literally everyday) there is no doubt whatsoever with the images originally posted by the OP.

Edit: the only alternative possibility is that the changed images do not consitute new and original artworks, and that the artist has merely tinkered with them, and not changed them in any significant or substantial way, and that therefore the copyright remains with the OP. Is this what you're saying? It strikes me as an unsustainable proposition.
 
Edit: the only alternative possibility is that the changed images do not consitute new and original artworks, and that the artist has merely tinkered with them, and not changed them in any significant or substantial way, and that therefore the copyright remains with the OP. Is this what you're saying? It strikes me as an unsustainable proposition.

From my understanding of the law, the main design of the images would need to be different. Now one could argue that the main design of the images, especially the second one, are the model, as these haven't been changed in my opinion, the adaptations can't be considered original artistic works. Now that's my understanding and interpretation of the law and also taking my opinion of what is the main design of the image.

Of course, all of that is my opinion and interpretation, a judge could decide completely differently and I would be wrong. I'm not aware of any case law which could be relied upon to decide here, although I doubt none exists, I just don't have access to it.
 
From my understanding of the law, the main design of the images would need to be different. Now one could argue that the main design of the images, especially the second one, are the model, as these haven't been changed in my opinion, the adaptations can't be considered original artistic works. Now that's my understanding and interpretation of the law and also taking my opinion of what is the main design of the image.

Of course, all of that is my opinion and interpretation, a judge could decide completely differently and I would be wrong. I'm not aware of any case law which could be relied upon to decide here, although I doubt none exists, I just don't have access to it.

There are three separate works relating to each of the two images posted by the OP.

One is the original photograph - copyright OP; the second is the artwork overlay - copyright the artist; the third work is the combined image of photograph and overlay - joint copyright.
 
Back
Top