I can't get the hang of this Depth of Field lark!

EdBray,

Thank you for pointing me to this thread; you demonstrate all too well how useful the tilt function can be .. especially for landscapes :thumbs:.

I have to say, I am still struggling with the DoF and tilt function, not too sure where I am going wrong, but I figure more practice is needed :bang:.

As you've said in your other thread, the shift function was a lot easier to master.
 
EdBray,

Thank you for pointing me to this thread; you demonstrate all too well how useful the tilt function can be .. especially for landscapes :thumbs:.

I have to say, I am still struggling with the DoF and tilt function, not too sure where I am going wrong, but I figure more practice is needed :bang:.

As you've said in your other thread, the shift function was a lot easier to master.

Do you know the Scheimpflug Rule? Really easy concept. Sorted :thumbs:
 
Do you know the Scheimpflug Rule? Really easy concept. Sorted :thumbs:

Thanks Hoppy, I have read about this rule and got my head around it. What I am struggling with is knowing the best means to get a sharp picture :thinking:

With the Shift mechanism, I basically make sure that the camera is dead-level (using a level meter), compose my picture, then Shift the lens (up or down) to accommodate the hight of the object being shot.

With the Tilt mechanism, I maintain the same camera level. Why? For some reason I thought that is what out to be done. I then use the Tilt to get the Depth of Field I want. Not working so well.

From a video, from a link posted in one of the threads on this topic I saw the camera wasn't level at all :shrug:. As a matter of fact, it was angled at about 45 degrees towards the subject.

Hence, why I am planning to head out tomorrow and spend the whole day practising, taking all this reading material along too.

For the life in me, I can't seem to figure out what I was doing wrong, other than maintaining the camera level :help:
 
I have found that the best thing for tilt (and shift come to that) is the use of Live View.

Very similar to view camera use, you can magnify the image and check the focussing as required.

Once you have got used to tilt too, you will want more than one T/S lens. They are just so versatile.
 
Thanks Hoppy, I have read about this rule and got my head around it. What I am struggling with is knowing the best means to get a sharp picture :thinking:

With the Shift mechanism, I basically make sure that the camera is dead-level (using a level meter), compose my picture, then Shift the lens (up or down) to accommodate the hight of the object being shot.

With the Tilt mechanism, I maintain the same camera level. Why? For some reason I thought that is what out to be done. I then use the Tilt to get the Depth of Field I want. Not working so well.

From a video, from a link posted in one of the threads on this topic I saw the camera wasn't level at all :shrug:. As a matter of fact, it was angled at about 45 degrees towards the subject.

Hence, why I am planning to head out tomorrow and spend the whole day practising, taking all this reading material along too.

For the life in me, I can't seem to figure out what I was doing wrong, other than maintaining the camera level :help:

Don't know why you were keeping the camera level for max depth of field :thinking: In a word, don't.

Keeping the camera level is only necessary for the controlling converging verticals with the shift function which, TBH, is not the most useful feature of this lens given how easy it is to correct converging verticals in post processing these days (and you can get more correction that way), although of course shift is slightly different and has other uses too.

Tilt is much more generally useful IMHO. To get max depth of field, once you have framed the shot pretty much the way you would normally, tilt the lens Scheimplug-style so that the angle of the lens disects the plane of the subject you want sharp, and the plane of the sensor. That's the position of maximum DoF at any given f/number.

Eg, bed of flowers effectively horizontal at zero degrees, camera angled down for the best frame at 40 degrees, tilt the lens to 20 degrees :)
 
Don't know why you were keeping the camera level for max depth of field :thinking: In a word, don't.

I honestly haven't the faintest idea why I did that; it's just something I've presumed. Obviously, with great error.


Keeping the camera level is only necessary for the controlling converging verticals with the shift function which, TBH, is not the most useful feature of this lens given how easy it is to correct converging verticals in post processing these days (and you can get more correction that way), although of course shift is slightly different and has other uses too.

As I don't like to do much Post Processing, prefer to get things right out of the camera, Shift opened up a whole new line of photography that I wasn't too keen on (architectural). True, as you say, this is an easy thing to correct in PP; but as indicated, I'm not too keen on that.

An added bonus to the lens's abilities, as far as I'm concerned.


Tilt is much more generally useful IMHO. To get max depth of field, once you have framed the shot pretty much the way you would normally, tilt the lens Scheimplug-style so that the angle of the lens disects the plane of the subject you want sharp, and the plane of the sensor. That's the position of maximum DoF at any given f/number.

Eg, bed of flowers effectively horizontal at zero degrees, camera angled down for the best frame at 40 degrees, tilt the lens to 20 degrees :)

This is the reason I got these T/S lenses, and thank you so much for the example and for the clarification. Puts the whole thing into good perspective (excuse the pun).
 
I honestly haven't the faintest idea why I did that; it's just something I've presumed. Obviously, with great error.

As I don't like to do much Post Processing, prefer to get things right out of the camera, Shift opened up a whole new line of photography that I wasn't too keen on (architectural). True, as you say, this is an easy thing to correct in PP; but as indicated, I'm not too keen on that.

An added bonus to the lens's abilities, as far as I'm concerned.

This is the reason I got these T/S lenses, and thank you so much for the example and for the clarification. Puts the whole thing into good perspective (excuse the pun).

Hang on a minute! See below :eek:

All good reasons for using a T&S lens. They are brilliantly useful for still-life and product photography where you can do a lot with perspective control (both correction and distortion) plus depth of field. I imagine that if you're doing a lot of this kind of thing professionally, the ability to do everything in camera and output direct from the camera with out any post procesing at all must be a very big benefit.

The only problem is, the advice I gave about Scheimplug above is rubbish, or at least the example of how to tilt the lens is! :eek: Haha, so sorry. I'll try to get it right this time - simply, what you have to do is angle the lens so that the lens plane, the sensor plane and the subject plane meet at the same point.

That is not the same thing as I described above! The best way is by illustration, as per this link. http://www.trenholm.org/hmmerk/HMbooks3.html As you can see, it's not quite the same as bisecting the angle. Actually, I think it's even easier than that in practice, no measuring invloved - just visualise it and swing the lens so the points meet up in your mind's eye. Apologies.
 
Actullay you have been swung!
Tilt when used horizontally is usually referred to as swing!

like in the 50's bands

wow my lower extremities seem to be bruised:lol:
 
Hang on a minute! See below :eek:

All good reasons for using a T&S lens. They are brilliantly useful for still-life and product photography where you can do a lot with perspective control (both correction and distortion) plus depth of field. I imagine that if you're doing a lot of this kind of thing professionally, the ability to do everything in camera and output direct from the camera with out any post procesing at all must be a very big benefit.

The only problem is, the advice I gave about Scheimplug above is rubbish, or at least the example of how to tilt the lens is! :eek: Haha, so sorry. I'll try to get it right this time - simply, what you have to do is angle the lens so that the lens plane, the sensor plane and the subject plane meet at the same point.

That is not the same thing as I described above! The best way is by illustration, as per this link. http://www.trenholm.org/hmmerk/HMbooks3.html As you can see, it's not quite the same as bisecting the angle. Actually, I think it's even easier than that in practice, no measuring invloved - just visualise it and swing the lens so the points meet up in your mind's eye. Apologies.

No need to apologies at all; if anything this is all very helpful and demonstrates my inept abilities to master this.

Thank you for the link, it makes it very clear; I have seen this and understood this from reading the various posts / links posted here and elsewhere. The thing that I was doing stupidly was making the presumption that the camera had to be dead-level. I plan to go out all day tomorrow to shoot and try this out. I have to master this, I just have to. Hopefully I am now in a better position to get my head around it.

On a personal note, I don't shoot professionally; it's only a hobby, but keeps me busy from other mischiefs :p and cuts down on time, and money, I can spend on other more silly things.

Again, thank you so much for the link to the diagram.
 
Ed have you used an LF camera before? How do the movements of an LF camera (tilt, swing and the other movements whose names I don't know) compare to a TS lens for an SLR?

From my youtube lessons on LF camera movemements you lean the film plane forwards/backwards to fix converging verticals and you move the lens element to control the focal plane in the horizontal and vertical axis. Am I right in thinking the movement to get the focal plane of the line of batteries moving away from the camera is the swing and if you were using a taller object such as a cereal box you'd use the tilt?

I was under the impression that shift was used as compositional aid so that you didn't have to move the camera/tripod to make minor adjustments, do SLR T lenses have this feature too?

cheers,
Kev
 
Ed have you used an LF camera before? How do the movements of an LF camera (tilt, swing and the other movements whose names I don't know) compare to a TS lens for an SLR?

From my youtube lessons on LF camera movemements you lean the film plane forwards/backwards to fix converging verticals and you move the lens element to control the focal plane in the horizontal and vertical axis. Am I right in thinking the movement to get the focal plane of the line of batteries moving away from the camera is the swing and if you were using a taller object such as a cereal box you'd use the tilt?

I was under the impression that shift was used as compositional aid so that you didn't have to move the camera/tripod to make minor adjustments, do SLR T lenses have this feature too?

cheers,
Kev

The big difference with large format cameras is that they inherently have very little depth of field, but large depth of focus. This is the reverse of a DSLR.

As a result, the movements you get on large format are much more extensive. Because they need to be to get more depth of field, and they can be because of the depth of focus available.
 
Ed have you used an LF camera before? Yes, in the past both at college and I also had a field camera for personal use., How do the movements of an LF camera (tilt, swing and the other movements whose names I don't know) compare to a TS lens for an SLR? The Tilt/Shift lenses are similar to the camera movements possible with a field camera, but not so as with a monorail which has camera back movements also available, this is much more versatile but requires much more knowledge and practise.

From my youtube lessons on LF camera movemements you lean the film plane forwards/backwards to fix converging verticals and you move the lens element to control the focal plane in the horizontal and vertical axis. No, to correct converging verticals the back has to be straight/in-line with the subject. Altering the front of the lens will alter the plane of focus only. Am I right in thinking the movement to get the focal plane of the line of batteries moving away from the camera is the swing Yes and if you were using a taller object such as a cereal box you'd use the tilt? Or a combination of both tilt and swing as well as possible shift to get the focus and perspective you require.

I was under the impression that shift was used as compositional aid so that you didn't have to move the camera/tripod to make minor adjustments, do SLR T lenses have this feature too? Yes, by turning the shift feature through 90 degrees to give you a horizontal shift rather than a vertical one you can move the compostion to suit without moving the camera.
cheers,
Kev

The 24L TSE MkII and the 17L TSE are the best of the available tilt/shift lenses as they are the first available to allow rotating of the tilt and shift functions independantly of each other through the various planes including 30, 45, 60 & 90 degrees (this offers a degree of both tilt & swing at once if needed). On the 24L TSE, 45 TSE & 90 TSE you can only change the plane of the tilt/shift by unscrewing the mount and twisting it through 90 degrees before screwing it back up again.
 
I'm currently waiting for a sleet shower to pass, so I thought I'd grab the opportunity to write down a few thoughts from two intensive days out with the 24mm TS-E.
You can see some of the resultant TS-E images over in my Diary from the Isle of Canna.

Firstly, I'll admit to struggling with the Schweinhund Rule. Probably too academic for me. Playing with the lens and seeing what happens works much better for me.

My rules of thumb for tilt that I posted in an earlier thread seem to be holding up remarkably well. I occasionally use Live View to double check but my guesses seem to be plenty good enough to get on with the shot without worrying about tilt.
1 deg - Standing with horizon on top third of landscape frame.
2 deg - Unextended tripod with horizon on top third of landscape frame.
3 deg - Low-ish tripod (approx 12") framed in portrait with horizon near top of frame.

I tried 4 degrees in an image where the horizon was right at the top of a portrait frame. The camera was about 12" above the ground. The focal plane went from on the ground at the base of the tripod to significantly below the horizon - in other words 4 degrees was way too much tilt.

Landscape/Portrait orientation only matters because the horizon at the top framing results in a different camera angle to keep the horizon in the same place. A good rule of thumb seems to be to add half a degree when going from landscape to portrait and vice-versa.

I found that with the framing described above that focus gets increasingly closer with increased tilt.
Fortunately focussing is easy!
After having set the tilt, half press the shutter and move the focus ring until something goes beep. It doesn't really matter which focus point scores a hit - because if we have got the tilt right then they should all be in focus! I find that on my 5DII a 'typical' subject usually flashes about half the focus lights.

One good bit of news is that my rules of thumb seem to hold when the TS-E is used with a 2x converter - YAY :D
 
Excellent post there, :thumbs:; thank you for taking the time for the couple of links (one of which I recall reading, the other is new to me).

Unfortunately, a recent family downturn meant my "playtime" has been postponed. Once all this is past, I will give this more field testing.

You just got to love the results :love::love::love:
 
Back
Top