I find myself criticising other photos.

Messages
322
Name
Brandon
Edit My Images
No
I've suddenly found myself criticising other photos, that whilst may look amazing to people, actually could be improved. I find this strange as I could take some of my own advice, but ofcourse 'Easier said than done'.

Don't get me wrong, they've got the shutter pressed just at the right time (as the person was doing a cartwheel) But I found myself moaning about the darkness at the bottom etc.
I think this would look better with that cropped off from the bottom.

I'm noticing things that I never use to in photos, strange ;)
 
Last edited:
Is this called learning a knowing now what to look for through all the advice on here???
 
The horizon is wonky too.
 
BrandonDouglas said:
I think that when your more of an amature, giving it an angle makes it a pro class image :p atleast thats what you think when your an amature.

I think it's more to do with not noticing tbh!

Don't knock amateur (note the spelling!) photographers too much as there are many who will give the pro's a good run for their money!

Andy
 
I think it's more to do with not noticing tbh!

Don't knock amateur (note the spelling!) photographers too much as there are many who will give the pro's a good run for their money!

Andy

Well, I use the term amateur* loosely, I meant in-experienced or someone whos not doing it for good photos, just happy snapping. And decides to add an angle thinking it makes your picture great.

I'm not 'knocking', I only know this because it's what I would do before. And I class myself as an amateur so I wouldn't knock 'em ! ;)
 
I stumbled upon this pretty good photo of a friend of a friends on Facebook.

I think this would look better with that cropped off from the bottom.

I'm noticing things that I never use to in photos, strange ;)

Have you considered that the picture you are criticizing is actually exactly how the photographer intended it to look? Photography is an art not a science. It doesn't have to conform to rules and formula and the only person it has to be right for is the person who created it (or paid to have it created in the case of commercial photography).

Be critical of your own work by all means but when looking at others work try to see it through their eyes and see what they see.
 
Have you considered that the picture you are criticizing is actually exactly how the photographer intended it to look? Photography is an art not a science. It doesn't have to conform to rules and formula and the only person it has to be right for is the person who created it (or paid to have it created in the case of commercial photography).

Be critical of your own work by all means but when looking at others work try to see it through their eyes and see what they see.

But to every piece of art there's stuff that appeals to the majority which as a photographer, you tend to use to attract as many people as you can. And you also use this to criticise other photos. There are bad photos, IMO, that may be exactly what the photographer intended, but just doesn't appeal.

I'm not trying to say it is a bad photo, and ofcourse it may be what the photographer intended. Although she isn't interested in photography and therefore I don't believe she fully knew what she wanted apart from someone cartwheeling in front of the sun, she didn't care about what else was there.

I doubt she intended the bottom to be dark, ofcourse I don't know if she did but I doubt it.

Anyhoo, I'm entitled to my opinion so whilst the photographer may or may not have intended for the picture to look a certain way. I'll always look at it and think that some things may have been better done another way. But photography is all down to opinion at the end of the day.
 
While I agree wholeheartedly with that Steve, when many people post photos for crit, they often don't give you that sort of information - What they tried to achieve, how they tried to do that etc. If you post up a photo and give no insight into that, then how on earth are people supposed to crit that?

I went through a phase of critting loads, and always asking for more information before doing so, asking people to think about what they posted and why, whether the shot was as they expected, how it could be done differently etc. In the end, people thought I was being grumpy and I felt like :bang::bang::bang: - So now I rarely bother :thumbsdown:
 
I'm gonna see what I can do with this on photoshop

Just playing devil's advocate here but have you asked if the original photographer is ok with that? Even if it is on facebook it is still copyright.
 
Just playing devil's advocate here but have you asked if the original photographer is ok with that? Even if it is on facebook it is still copyright.

I'm not using the photo for any personal benefit though ? just seeing what it looks like by changing some aspects of it. I'm not even going to upload it here. Infact, I'll probably even be deleting it after I've seen the edit of it. >.<
 
when many people post photos for crit, they often don't give you that sort of information - What they tried to achieve, how they tried to do that etc. If you post up a photo and give no insight into that, then how on earth are people supposed to crit that?
Couldn't agree more. Even something as simple as a hint in the title helps!
 
I'm not using the photo for any personal benefit though ? just seeing what it looks like by changing some aspects of it. I'm not even going to upload it here. Infact, I'll probably even be deleting it after I've seen the edit of it. >.<

Fair enough - as I said, I was just playing devil's advocate. It's the sort of thing where you have to think whether you would be happy with others doing the same with your images. If you are then no problem.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough - as I said, I was just playing devil's advocate. It's the sort of thing where you have to think whether you would be happy with thers doing the same with your images. If you are then no problem.

No worries ;)

I'd be happy for people to do what they want with my photo.
As long as they didn't take credit for it and/or use it for promotion/money etc.

For personal use is fine.
 
I like it, nice shot :shrug:

I've got more critical since joining this site :lol: I agree with Bristolian that it's an art not a science, I think it's completely possible to enjoy photos without picking them apart if they don't fit the widely accepted view of what is "normal". If they'd posted it for C&C then fair play to give some feedback though :D

There's a great site somewhere with people giving crit to pictures by Cartier-Bresson and similar in a modern style, complaining that their horizons weren't straight and they focused on the wrong thing, unfortunately I can't find the link.
 
While I agree wholeheartedly with that Steve, when many people post photos for crit, they often don't give you that sort of information - What they tried to achieve, how they tried to do that etc. If you post up a photo and give no insight into that, then how on earth are people supposed to crit that?

I went through a phase of critting loads, and always asking for more information before doing so, asking people to think about what they posted and why, whether the shot was as they expected, how it could be done differently etc. In the end, people thought I was being grumpy and I felt like :bang::bang::bang: - So now I rarely bother :thumbsdown:

Sara, you've hit the nail on the head ... It's often hard for someone - even the photographer - to describe in words the feelings and vision they had when taking the picture so they don't bother and just ask for comments and how it could be improved.

When a picture is posted especially to elicit criticism then it's fair game for others to post what they think and how they think it could (in their opinion) be improved. This picture though wasn't presented for crit - it was just a random picture lifted from someone's FB page.

I'm also surprised to see a picture lifted like - this with no credit to the copyright owner - on a site that is reknown for crying about copyright theft :shrug:
 
I'm also surprised to see a picture lifted like - this with no credit to the copyright owner - on a site that is reknown for crying about copyright theft :shrug:

mods will probably change it to a link when they catch up with this thread , that seems to be the protocol
 
I think that when your more of an amature, giving it an angle makes it a pro class image :p atleast thats what you think when your an amature.

the key to doing that is to have it so out of true that its obvious it was done deliberately - like having the horizon at 45 degrees - doing it a little bit just looks like sloppy camera work
 
I think you've gotten the wrong idea from what I was saying. This often happens to me and people straay a tad off-topic. If it makes you happier I will inform my friend that her photo is being used as part of a discussion on a photography forum.

My reason for posting this thread was purely because I surprised myself to be looking at someons photos and suddenly be thinking there's something I feel that (In my opinion!) could have been improved. I did NOT post this to state that people are photographing things wrong etc. or to have you all criticise the photo.

I obviously must be taking some advice in if I'm now thinking about how I'd have liked to taken that photo etc.
 
the key to doing that is to have it so out of true that its obvious it was done deliberately - like having the horizon at 45 degrees - doing it a little bit just looks like sloppy camera work

4


Well this is an example of when I've slanted an image. In this one I done it to get as much of the sculpture in (close up) without it being a completely vertical photo.

There's further editing I'd like to do to that image such as crop off some of the right and dull down the highly exposed sky & background. (Before anyone else decides to point it out) ;)
 
I think i'd have tilted it even further so the lines went corner to corner , which you can still do if it crops to square
 
Edit: Well I would have tried it if I had the right software or knew how to do it on Photoshop :p

there you go - tis easy just image-rotate-free rotate layer then crop

brandon_douglas_tilt.jpg


tho personally i think it works better in B&W

brandon_douglas_tiltbw.jpg


(as above but then layers- adjustment layer- gradient map, then layers-adjustment layer -levels, then layers- flatten )

But we digress :lol:
 
Shorly the whole point of miproving, is when you can crit, your own photos. And see what you could have done better. Anyone can find fault in others work.

Finding fault in ones own work is the hard part.
 
Back
Top