Jeremy Clarkson on having his picture taken (again!)

"Cameras dehumanise humanity"

I think he is spot on in some areas though - stood behind a camera filming an incident makes you feel a lot more like your watching it on TV and are unable to help the situation.
 
J.C. Maybe a pain in the arras but on this occasion I am with him 100%

Listen to Don McClean...This is life....sums it all up very well!
 
I dont even think being a pro excuses you for standing taking pics when you could do something to help someone. I just coulnd't do it even if I knew the pictures would make money - I hope I'm in the majority here too.
 
Hes exactly right, now when some people see a crash ect there first response isent to help the person its to take a photo and try and get some money. Personally myself i could never do that i would have to help the person first and once they are ok and out the wreckage and ambulance ect on there way i would then maybe take a photography of the scene but until then my first priority would be making sure everyone involved is ok.
 
Who could film him on the toilet? What a sad man that guy must be.
 
I'm afraid we are now living in a time of bloody-minded ignorance all thanks to modern, mobile technology.

For someone to stand there and film JC having a pee is beyond belief. What was the idiot thinking of?

If someone did that to me I would take that phone/camera and shove it up his Clarkson.
 
I would love to shoot Clarkson, after which I might take his picture.
 
So he does occasionally write a worthwhile column... Who'd have known?

He raises some good points, there is a code of not interfering for pros but it isn't really meant to cover situations like Farage's crash (the pictures of which, by the way, I found quite shockingly explicit).
 
His statement on Nigel Farage is a load of rubbish - UKIP tend to bring along photographers when they're doing publicity stunts.
 
Why is it rubbish? He said it may have been a professional, or it may have been a bank manager, and that in either case the first reaction should be to help, not to snap.

Unless you're suggesting a professional photographer was hired by UKIP to take pictures of Farage's crash...? Perhaps a little extreme, even by UKIP standards.
 
Picture of UKIP was taken by INS photographer Neil Hall (according to a press photographers forum I'm a member of) who probably like the rest of us have been to thousands of events where nothing much happened, but when it mattered he did what was expected of him.

On this occasion Clarkson should get his facts right.
 
Why is it rubbish? He said it may have been a professional, or it may have been a bank manager, and that in either case the first reaction should be to help, not to snap.

Unless you're suggesting a professional photographer was hired by UKIP to take pictures of Farage's crash...? Perhaps a little extreme, even by UKIP standards.

Of course I'm not suggesting that. However, Jeremy Clarkson is assuming that a photographer rushed to the scene after hearing of the incident. How would that be possible? Surely an ambulance would arrive and remove them from the wreckage before it had been made public?

All I'm saying is that the photographer was there anyway - he didn't specifically arrive for the incident.
 
Picture of UKIP was taken by INS photographer Neil Hall (according to a press photographers forum I'm a member of) who probably like the rest of us have been to thousands of events where nothing much happened, but when it mattered he did what was expected of him.

On this occasion Clarkson should get his facts right.

Agreed. By the way, what forum's that? Would like to join!
 
I wouldn't say he is always wrong.

I would class Jeremy as controversial. He speaks his mind, but is ultimately being vocal about things that others think but dare not say!
I like the guy and have plenty time for him. I have read all his books including his personal biography and it makes for interesting reading.

The guy has a way with words and is like marmite - you either love him or hate him.
 
I dont even think being a pro excuses you for standing taking pics when you could do something to help someone. I just coulnd't do it even if I knew the pictures would make money - I hope I'm in the majority here too.

Well you need to be careful what you say here. Some of the greatest moments captured on film, emotional or distressing or whatever, were caught by those who chose to take a shot rather than help. I don't think people who find themselves in that situation would take the shot for money. I know I wouldn't.

They probably find themselves there because they are on assignment working for an agency or a newspaper or even a humanitarian organisation. I'd want to do it to capture a defining moment that other people might otherwise have never seen.
 
A lot of those moments, I should add, have arguably been captured and then gone on to serve a greater good. Its a complex issue, but a good one to discuss.
 
I'm afraid we are now living in a time of bloody-minded ignorance all thanks to modern, mobile technology.
To be fair there has always been bloody-minded ignorance - but now it is augmented with modern, mobile technology.
 
If you have a UK press card and are a full time pro I'll PM you the details. (They have a very strict entry criteria)

I've got my CIoJ card. If you could send me a PM that'd be great. I think I know which one you might be talking about....
 
I've got my CIoJ card. If you could send me a PM that'd be great. I think I know which one you might be talking about....

Ditto for me...I'm interested too. UK Press Card and Fulltime pro, so I pass the first test!
 
good read, some interesting points raised there :)
 
He's got a point.

I was on a lads night out, one of the lads sliped on ice landed on his head his picture of him on his back was on facebook before he'd even got to his feet, a laugh at the time but it's the way the worlds going snap first then think.

At least Jeremy Clarkson accepts that for a pro tog the lines are blurred.
 
Well you need to be careful what you say here. Some of the greatest moments captured on film, emotional or distressing or whatever, were caught by those who chose to take a shot rather than help. I don't think people who find themselves in that situation would take the shot for money. I know I wouldn't.

They probably find themselves there because they are on assignment working for an agency or a newspaper or even a humanitarian organisation. I'd want to do it to capture a defining moment that other people might otherwise have never seen.

Sorry I still dont think it's acceptable. There is no reason not to help a fellow human being if you are in a position to do so. If it means sacrificing a photograph that defines a moment then so be it. Nothing is worth more than preventing sufferring.
 
A lot of those moments, I should add, have arguably been captured and then gone on to serve a greater good. Its a complex issue, but a good one to discuss.

Nick Ut's picture of the girl running away from he napalm attack, allegedly helped change the americans attitude to the vietnam war. (he also went on to help save the girls life)
 
But in that case he was able to do both photograph and help. Would he have made the same decision to take the photograph it it might have meant she was injured by the delay?
 
I generally hate JC (being 1/2 french, veggie and a cyclist that's only normal :)), however his point re the news being all about what has been captured on video other than what is relevant is spot on. The amount of american 'news' stories nowadays is ridiculous.
 
But in that case he was able to do both photograph and help. Would he have made the same decision to take the photograph it it might have meant she was injured by the delay?

It's a fine line but generally I'd say if you can help potentially save a life, you do. If something uncomfortable if in front of you that might shock most of us, that's when a pro tog comes to the fore.

I think you'll never know if a picture will get published let alone the effect of it, so help first, shoot if no help required. :thumbs:
 
I think you'll never know if a picture will get published let alone the effect of it, so help first, shoot if no help required. :thumbs:

Spot on. If there's enough people helping you will be in the way. Photograph to record the scene. It may help prevent similar things occurring again.
If you are the first on scene you have a moral responsibility to help until such time as you are no longer required.
The best way to think of it is :- if it was your son or daughter hurt or in trouble and a tog was first on site and did nothing to assist, just photographed the scene, what would you think of the tog ? We are all members of the human race first and togs second.
 
Reminds me of the photographers who stood by photographing Princess Diana when she was dying in a car.
 
Tough one - a photographer is good at photographing. A trained first aider is good at first aid.

Nowadays, if you try to help someone and make their condition worse (which can easily happen) you're looking at a lawsuit.
 
Reminds me of the photographers who stood by photographing Princess Diana when she was dying in a car.

I think there is a HUGE difference between documentary photographers and those paps at the crash scene. If I was covering a famine who do I choose to help knowing that despite my efforts people are going to die?

I tend to agree that if you know you can hep then do so. But I still think the primary role of a documentary photographer is documetary.
 
however his point re the news being all about what has been captured on video other than what is relevant is spot on. The amount of american 'news' stories nowadays is ridiculous.

Agree with this. But we also get a load of American news stories in the print media as well - far higher than we do from mainland Europe for example despite those stories by dint of us being in the EU together (whether one likes that or not) having far greater impact on the UK.
 
Picture of UKIP was taken by INS photographer Neil Hall (according to a press photographers forum I'm a member of) who probably like the rest of us have been to thousands of events where nothing much happened, but when it mattered he did what was expected of him.

On this occasion Clarkson should get his facts right.


From the Times article:

Neil Hall, a photographer who was asked by Mr Farage, an MEP for South East of England, to capture the publicity stunt on camera, said he had feared that both men had been killed. “His plane was about 10m off the ground when the banner became tangled in the rear tail rudder, and it nose-dived quickly into the ground,” said Mr Hall, 30, of the INS News Agency.

“One minute it was in the air, the next it was a cloud of dust. It simply nose-dived without any warning.”

Mr Hall drove across to the crash site with Duncan Barkes, Mr Farage’s spokesman, and said that he expected to find two dead bodies. “It looked like the front of the plane had completely flattened. I could see Nigel’s leg sticking out and feared he was dead. Then I heard him moaning saying, ‘Get me out, Get me out’. Blood was pouring from his mouth. I think he had cut his lip with his tooth. He was dazed and confused. He was conscious, but utterly scared.

“When he got out he just kept asking for his phone. He said ‘I’ve lost my phone’. I said ‘Nigel you’re in shock’ and he just said ‘I’m scared, I’m scared, I’m scared’. He had a cigarette and then felt a bit better.

“He did not know what to do with himself. It was complete shock. One minute he was in his plane thinking about his campaign or something and the next minute he was trapped in a crashed plane. I’m surprised he didn’t break his neck.”
 
Back
Top