manual focus, how on earth do you nail it?

I don't. view finder too small and its not split. easy on a MF camera though

I know some people on here manually focus their subjects.

Now in live view with a still subject at 10x magnification, I can do this!

But how would you manually focus say 50mm at 1.4 a portrait through the viewfinder and know that you have got the eyeball sharp and not the eyelash instead?
 
Perhaps a good way of testing would be to get a broadsheet newspaper laid flat, then point your camera at an angle, say 45 degrees and try autofocus and then manual focus on the same word in the middle of the sheet.

This way you'll be able to see in which direction you are out by (front or back) and we can also eliminate camera shake because if there isn't any then there must be a line of text somewhere on the paper in focus!!
 
ok i have tried this on a tripod now with mirror lockup and i get the exact same thing.

I think it is the increased depth of field on my viewfinder like you say. If I go to live view and I x10 the object and put it in absolute focus and then turn live view off it looks perfectly in focus in the viewfinder, but also if i go back to live view and take it slightly out it still looks in focus in the viewfinder -

and this brings me full circle - how the hell can anyone see an object is in focus this small by using the viewfinder?
 
I was worried about the metering and I have not noticed any difference since fitting mine, regardless of the metering types (did look just after I fitted it),

I think that is one of the reasons katzeye are so expensive it matches the old screen very very, I read about people cutting and fitting old 35mm film prisms the only cost a few pounds and suffering from metering problems.

But fitting it isn’t fun, I’m not looking forward to doing it to my new D300!

Stuart
 
Re split screens. I looked into them and to be honest, didn't fancy the fitting procedures, but more worrying was the affect some of them have on metering.

The KatzEye at least only have an effect on spot metering when central point is used and the deviation appears to increase with the focal length. However I don't consider it such a drawback - spet metering can be done at any point so to use it it's just a matter of moving away from the central point really.
 
ok i have tried this on a tripod now with mirror lockup and i get the exact same thing.

I think it is the increased depth of field on my viewfinder like you say. If I go to live view and I x10 the object and put it in absolute focus and then turn live view off it looks perfectly in focus in the viewfinder, but also if i go back to live view and take it slightly out it still looks in focus in the viewfinder -

and this brings me full circle - how the hell can anyone see an object is in focus this small by using the viewfinder?

:bang: focus indicator and range finder!

Stuart, who for the first time feels himself going horse just from typing!:D
 
I do wear glasses yes. But f the dioptic is accurate this won't affect it will it?

Nope, but how do you know it's accurate? It appears from your shots that the camera is focussing fine but your view using your eyes isn't/

I started wearing glasses last year and had to adjust mine as I wasn't finding things looked right, but I kinda went through the same microfocus procedure. I stuck it on a tripod, did the autofocus (checked with liveview zoom) then adjusted the dioptic until it looked in focus through the viewfinder.
 
Nope, but how do you know it's accurate? It appears from your shots that the camera is focussing fine but your view using your eyes isn't/

I started wearing glasses last year and had to adjust mine as I wasn't finding things looked right, but I kinda went through the same microfocus procedure. I stuck it on a tripod, did the autofocus (checked with liveview zoom) then adjusted the dioptic until it looked in focus through the viewfinder.

but i put the camera on a tripod, set the focsu using x10 live mode, it's spot on. I look down the viewfinder and it is also spot on - so nothing wrong with my eyes.

at 1.4 a very small turn of the focus ring in live view and the battery is out. Look back through the viewfinder - still looks good. To me that is just the limit of the focus screen having more dof than is actually there - would you agree or are my eyes defo broken?
 
but i put the camera on a tripod, set the focsu using x10 live mode, it's spot on. I look down the viewfinder and it is also spot on - so nothing wrong with my eyes.

at 1.4 a very small turn of the focus ring in live view and the battery is out. Look back through the viewfinder - still looks good. To me that is just the limit of the focus screen having more dof than is actually there - would you agree or are my eyes defo broken?


No, No, No, No.......like I said earlier if you can see the tip of the battery is in or out of focus through the view finder when doing minimal adjustments then you have the eyes of an owl.
 
I may have wasted my 5000th post on a repeated view..............good grief.

I wanted to use it to congratulate some fantastic looking shot too, never mind.
 
Who wrote that.................lol

Pardon? :D

Post 89 is empty in my eyes maybe we are just reading what we want to read! :D

Ooo Ooo Congratulate my photo! I took one yesterday and I'm quite proud of it! :D

(as you may have guest my brain has flipped to silly weekend mode 33 mins early!)

Stuart
 
Last edited:
No, No, No, No.......like I said earlier if you can see the tip of the battery is in or out of focus through the view finder when doing minimal adjustments then you have the eyes of an owl.

well thats pretty much what i mean, just a different way of saying it, i'm not looking at the tip i'm looking at the numbers. What you are saying is that it's not possible to manually focus that battery at that distance accurately - which is the same as what I'm saying.
 
The downside to a splitscreen though is that metering tends to go off. So although I initially bought one, I put the normal one back in for better metering. It's not too hard to tell if something is in focus though even with today's screens, the beep on my Pentax K-7 helps as do the autofocus aids in modern DSLRs. I tend to look at texture rather than object. If the texture is in focus (harder than object) then you're ok. I also have a 2* magnifier.

12 of my 15 lenses are manual, they cost me £300 or so in total so I now have nice fast sharp primes for everything from 28mm to 300mm. The Pentax mount didn't change when we went digital so anything Pentax still works. Pentax uses in-body shake reduction so you get the benefit of that too. If you're on a budget you'd be crazy to consider any other brand because of this incredible backwards compatibility :).
 
So was I. When you manual focus it still shows you when you've hit the focus point. I'm not sure if it still works on lenses that are full-time manual focus but if it does then it would allow you to pick up some cracking manual focus only lenses at hardly any cost compared to modern auto-focus lenses.

With certain Nikon bodies you can get metering as well with full manual lenses and you still get the focus confirmation.
:)
My fave manual lens is 50mm f1:1.2 wide open it produces some great shots with beautiful bokeh on DX or FX cameras.
 
Last edited:
With certain Nikon bodies you can get metering as well with full manual lenses and you still get the focus confirmation.
:)
My fave manual lens is 50mm f1:1.2 wide open it produces some great shots with beautiful bokeh on DX or FX cameras.

I'm guessing it cost a fraction of the auto-focus equiv? :)
 
No, No, No, No.......like I said earlier if you can see the tip of the battery is in or out of focus through the view finder when doing minimal adjustments then you have the eyes of an owl.

also this is pretty much my point, the battery is no smaller than an eyeball at that distance so how do people see if the eyeball is in focus as well - they must have the eyes of an owl too then?
 
Back in the day when MF was the norm, focus screens were brighter and often had focussing aids like split and/or multiprisms. KatsEye can supply similar screens for many DSLRs but for the time being, I'm happy with the accuracy of the AF in both my bodies so will let it do the hard work (and blame it for any failures!) Oh, and MF lenses have a greater arc of travel on the focus ring for a set distance of focus change, far less sensitive than a modern AF lens, so easier to do very slight adjustments.
The viewfinder-lens also used to magnify more. I know for Nikons you can buy replacement eye-pieces with higher magnifcation. There might be something similar for Canon.

I was worried about the metering and I have not noticed any difference since fitting mine, regardless of the metering types (did look just after I fitted it),
I didn't have a problem either.

But fitting it isn’t fun, I’m not looking forward to doing it to my new D300!
It wasn't that bad, but laminar flow cabinets and lab equipment come in handy. :D
 
also this is pretty much my point, the battery is no smaller than an eyeball at that distance so how do people see if the eyeball is in focus as well - they must have the eyes of an owl too then?

I still think it is down to you moving while pressing the shutter, you need to post examples with the tripod and be honest about it.

As I pointed out in and earlier post, you were not focusing on the same/same part of the subject.
 
I still think it is down to you moving while pressing the shutter, you need to post examples with the tripod and be honest about it.

As I pointed out in and earlier post, you were not focusing on the same/same part of the subject.

I already did the tripod test. It's the same results. nothing to do with the camera moving whilst pressing the shutter, you are wrong about that I'm afraid. I even put the mirror lockup and put it on 2 second shutter release.

At 1.4 at that distance with an object that size the viewfinder looks in focus when the object is and isn't in focus.
 
I already did the tripod test. It's the same results. nothing to do with the camera moving whilst pressing the shutter, you are wrong about that I'm afraid. I even put the mirror lockup and put it on 2 second shutter release.

At 1.4 at that distance with an object that size the viewfinder looks in focus when the object is and isn't in focus.

can you post the results please?
 
Modern DSLR viewfinders do not show depth of field accurately, and certainly do not show what the scene looks like at wide apertures.

I remember reading ages ago (KR and elsewhere) that modern focusing screens don't show precise focus with lenses wider then f/2.8; this article, Live view versus the cheating DSLR viewfinder goes into a lot more detail and includes several images to illustrate the problem.

Also see what KR says about alternative screens for the 5D.
 
Ok tripod mounted
200 shutter
1.4 aperture
50mm
iso 100

1st shot went to live view, x10 focussed perfectly
changed to viewfinder,looked through the viewfinder, looks perfect in there too
IMG_3614-1.jpg


2nd shot, switched back to live view, x10 focus, turned the focus a tiny amount so it went out, switched back to viewfinder looked through -still looks perfect
IMG_3615-1.jpg



the fact is, a tiny movement front or back renders the battery out of focus, but in the viewfinder it always looks in focus - so how would i ever know if i just looked through the viewfinder?
 
Modern DSLR viewfinders do not show depth of field accurately, and certainly do not show what the scene looks like at wide apertures.

this is the conclusion I have come to but tiler seems adamant I must be wrong?
 
What about the view finder being slightly out? Isn't there a wee dial on the outside that can adjust it, such as for people who wear different strengths of glasses etc (or has someone already mentioned this?)
 
Why has the focus distance changed from 1290mm in the live view version to 1170mm in the view finder version, like I say you have moved the camera.

Either that or you have a front focussing camera.
 
Last edited:
What about the view finder being slightly out? Isn't there a wee dial on the outside that can adjust it, such as for people who wear different strengths of glasses etc (or has someone already mentioned this?)

this would only be relevant if when the object was in perfect focus through live view, when looking through the viewfinder it looked out - this doesn't happen, when it is perfectly focused in live view at x10, looking throuhg the viewfinder reveals perfectly in focus too

Tracer, thank you, thank you for posting that article, the results of what the viewinder shows to what is really happening is EXACTLY what I am trying to explain. When people keep telling you it must be this, it must be shutter and camera shake, etc you start to believe you must be going mad. then this proves my point exactly and makes me realise i am not insane!

for those of you who don't have time to read that article, it basically says the DOF in the viewfinder is much more than in real life and these two images illustrate what I see perfectly

real dof
http://www.dphotoexpert.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/true1point2web.jpg

viewfinder dof
http://www.dphotoexpert.com/wp-content/uploads/2007/09/shotthroughfinderweb.jpg
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why has the focus distance changed from 1290mm in the live view version to 1170mm in the view finder version, like I say you have moved the camera.

I didn't move the camera at all!!!!!!

I explained it in the first post, i deliberately pulled the subject slightly out of focus in live view by moving the focus ring to show you that when i look through the viewfinder it STILL looks perfectly in focus.

what i am saying is, both these shots through the viewfinder look in focus. But only one actually is. Now I know why after reading the article tracer posted. the DOF through the viewfinder is higher than in real life.

to quote


You fit a lens which is f/1.2, f/2.8, or f/2. You view the scene, and it looks like so much is in focus. But your screen, the lens and the viewfinder optics are combining to create an aperture which equals f/4.5, f/5.6 or most commonly f/6.3
 
Isn't that why we have a depth of field preview button???????
 
and it makes no difference at 1.6 anyway. Even with the DOF button pressed the battery looks in focus through the viewfinder BOTH when it is in focus and when just out of focus.
 
ok i have tried this on a tripod now with mirror lockup and i get the exact same thing.

I think it is the increased depth of field on my viewfinder like you say. If I go to live view and I x10 the object and put it in absolute focus and then turn live view off it looks perfectly in focus in the viewfinder, but also if i go back to live view and take it slightly out it still looks in focus in the viewfinder -

and this brings me full circle - how the hell can anyone see an object is in focus this small by using the viewfinder?

Joe, why are you persisting with this? Just use AF.

Manual focusing any SLR or DSLR is difficult. Always has been, even when the focusing screen is designed for it, with suitable aids, you have a low f/number lens (which you do) and a decent focusing mech in the lens designed for manual operation. There's no great secret to it - it's just hard, and even then there's a fair amount of guesswork in it, and luck.

And after all that, modern AF beats the pants off anything you can do manually - ten times faster and much more accurate. Always. That's why it was invented, and why everybody uses it.

The only time I ever use manual focus is with macro, and that's a whole different thing. Give yourself a break bud ;)
 
and it makes no difference at 1.6 anyway. Even with the DOF button pressed the battery looks in focus through the viewfinder BOTH when it is in focus and when just out of focus.

I think he's trolling you.

I knew exactly what you meant from the first post but I only just now found this thread.
On a dslr it is pretty much hit or miss with manual focus without a specialist focussing screen.
On old film cameras you would have a visual cue to tell you if it is in focus rather than judging sharpness.

I think you can let this subject die now..
 
Joe, a little trick Ste Manns showed me is to set your camera to high speed shooting mode and kinda turn the focus ring slightly both ways whilst shooting a burst. One of them will probably hit the exact spot you need.

Ah the machine gun method, not learn how to take photos but take 1000's and you bound to get some good ones
 
Back
Top