Street Portrait- not a happy person- advice please :)

Status
Not open for further replies.

lukewoodford

FYI, I am Luke Woodford.....by Luke Woodford
Messages
3,320
Name
Luke Woodford
Edit My Images
No
I have just had a message from someone via windows live. Do you all remember the "removed name of image" image. I wont post it because that would take the **** a bit but its on my blog and on a thread somewhere. Anyway he's messaged me saying "Please would you remove the picture of me from your website called 'about to be punched' and also would you remove it compleately. Thanks! (Sorry for any inconvenience!)"

What do I do? Do I remove it out of politeness? Or do I keep it as I like it and its a street portrait? What would you do?

Cheers :)

]For everyone who's coming to the thread now please read it all before posting because quite alot has happened i.e. there is a strong possibility this is a wind up.

UPDATE: Declared a wind up.....for various reasons but persons e-mail is notification-1f8dcdf78fdce957b1@live.com (ive changed a couple numbers for to cover myself but I don't think anyone normal would have an e-mail like that.
 
I would remove it, things could get out of hand if not. As he did not consent to having his picure taken?
 
i just found this:

3.1 What should you bear in mind when photographing people?

There is no general legal requirement to obtain someone’s authorization to take his or her photograph. However, there are situations where photography can infringe on important social interests such as national security, protection of children, right of privacy, etc. Most of these situations are strictly controlled by national laws and regulations. Irrespective of the legalities, there are also some things a photographer should not photograph for ethical reasons. Certain photographs of people may amount to exploiting the persons concerned or misrepresenting the truth. If you, as a photographer, know the law and one’s legal rights, you will also be in a better position to find solutions that minimize your legal risks.

Often, you may be free to take a photograph of a person, but the way the image is used may give the person shown in the photograph a right to take legal action.

with the title "About to be punched" it could misrepresent the person so may be worth a simple polite email back enquiring why he wishes it to be removed.
 
I would delete it out of common courtesy. He seems to have asked nicely without any threats. Perhaps it was initial reaction was out of character and left him with a reputation!

But it's your decision really.

Graham
 
Im not saying im not going to but im not breaking any laws am I?

Where were you when the pic was taken Luke...? If you were in a public place and not on private property then you were not breaking the law.

I would remove it, things could get out of hand if not. As he did not consent to having his picure taken?
he did not have to consent to having his picture taken. Do you consent to having your picture taken every day when you're out and about on your daily business... cos if you do not consent, then you'd best contact the council/police/security company of many shops et al as they film you regularly without your consent.

It's not against the law Josh.
 
I would remove it - immediately - for various reasons.

1. The person is entitled to their privacy if they want it and leaving their image online after they have asked for it to be removed might not be illegal but is certainly immoral in my opinion

2. You want to earn your living at photography - just think of the bad publicity this person could give you

3. The heading is not exactly flattering to them

4. I really hate having my photo taken let alone displayed - maybe they are the same, especially at one time I had serious problems with an internet stalker who did not know what I look like - be nice to keep it that way.
 
I would say that as you are suggesting this man was about to punch you you should probably remove it. He could take it as an accusation. I dont know if this would constitute defamation of character. Playing devils advocate.
 
No you are not breaking the law Luke, you don't have to consent to have your picture taken and so long as you are not using it commercially there is nothing to answer.

However.

By calling it "About to be punched" you are slightly more than suggesting that a threat of physical violence did or could have been made. I'd say it's as much about the title as the pic.

If it's not crucial to a project then I'd consider either removing it (if it does not show the person in a very good light, and I don't mean photographically speaking :)) or at least rename it?

Just my take on it.
 
Where were you when the pic was taken Luke...? If you were in a public place and not on private property then you were not breaking the law.


he did not have to consent to having his picture taken. Do you consent to having your picture taken every day when you're out and about on your daily business... cos if you do not consent, then you'd best contact the council/police/security company of many shops et al as they film you regularly without your consent.

It's not against the law Josh.

I didnt say it was against the law, but as said in a post before some people do not like pictures being taken and used online. its not so much consent for the picture its consent for how the picture is going to be used.
 
Yeah im deleting it, he said he likes the photo but its personal reasons. From where it was taken I can kind of understand that. With regards to the title though if you read it on my blog you will see the caption, he wasn't bothered about that.
 
Im not saying im not going to but im not breaking any laws am I?

You're not breaking any laws by leaving it on.

If you want to trake it off or not is a different matter - personally I'd leave it but I dislike people telling me what to do :D
 
Where were you when the pic was taken Luke...? If you were in a public place and not on private property then you were not breaking the law.


he did not have to consent to having his picture taken. Do you consent to having your picture taken every day when you're out and about on your daily business... cos if you do not consent, then you'd best contact the council/police/security company of many shops et al as they film you regularly without your consent.

It's not against the law Josh.

Yeah lets not go into the law because we know its not illegal. I was in town, he knows its not against the law, he's been polite so I understand even though im a bit gutted. If he had been an arse I would have just kept it out of spite lol
 
No you are not breaking the law Luke, you don't have to consent to have your picture taken and so long as you are not using it commercially there is nothing to answer.

However.

By calling it "About to be punched" you are slightly more than suggesting that a threat of physical violence did or could have been made. I'd say it's as much about the title as the pic.

If it's not crucial to a project then I'd consider either removing it (if it does not show the person in a very good light, and I don't mean photographically speaking :)) or at least rename it?

Just my take on it.


Just to clarify he's cool with the title, I wouldn't put a title like that and not explain it like I did on my blog, but yeah good advice and its coming off.
 
I'd remove it too but I'm just interested how you know that the person in the shot is the same person who sent the email/message?

Bob
 
I'd remove it too but I'm just interested how you know that the person in the shot is the same person who sent the email/message?

Bob

I told him my name when I took the shot and told him to e-mail me and ill show him etc, im a nice guy you see. I asked him why he didn't contact me sooner and he said he couldn't e-mail me from that computer. Just to confirm its actually him im going to ask where it was taken, I think thats a good idea.
 
maybe he wasn't supposed to be where you took a photo of him, or with someone he was not supposed to be with, or maybe he just doesn't like the fact that someone had a photo of him. WHy not see if he wants to do a shoot with you as an apology for you postin it, with the agreement that you canpost some that are taken.

you might be able to get more out of him face to face, and then he may let you use the origional.
 
If he's being polite I don't see any reason why not to remove it.

Just because it's not illegal to post the photo doesn't mean you have to post it to make a point
 
maybe he wasn't supposed to be where you took a photo of him, or with someone he was not supposed to be with, or maybe he just doesn't like the fact that someone had a photo of him. WHy not see if he wants to do a shoot with you as an apology for you postin it, with the agreement that you canpost some that are taken.

you might be able to get more out of him face to face, and then he may let you use the origional.

Yeah I dont think he will want a shoot, I wont go into detail but im not getting that impression, he's being polite although it all seems quite strange. He wasn't with anyone or anything, I just wish I knew the reason but I wont pressure him.
 
maybe he just thinks it is not his best side!!
 
Just ask!

Say, "I'm totally happy to delete all evidence of the photograph as you have asked. Is there any particular reason you want the photograph deleted though? Just so I know for future portraits."

Or something like that.
 
Im not saying im not going to but im not breaking any laws am I?

If you're a considerate person you'd remove the image personally. They've asked nicely to have their 'image' removed from your website. Unless you want to be a complete arse to them about it I'd suggest removing it our of courtesy.
 
Just ask!

Say, "I'm totally happy to delete all evidence of the photograph as you have asked. Is there any particular reason you want the photograph deleted though? Just so I know for future portraits."

Or something like that.

I have, he said it was personal, I havnt got a clue why it is but he really doesnt want it. shame.
 
He obviously doesn't. As it's a picture of him that is serving no purpose common decency would make it a no brainer, surely?


not sure it is - I'm not saying Luke should or shouldn't remove it. Thats his decision, but if somebody asked me to completely remove one of my photos then, for me, I'd have to think long and hard. I can see off a website at a push, but out of a personal portfolio as well?

Hugh
 
He obviously doesn't. As it's a picture of him that is serving no purpose common decency would make it a no brainer, surely?

Ummmmm I am deleteing it but understand its an image that I really like and I have future plans for all my street stuff but thats another thread. Its fustrating because I dont have a reason.
 
not sure it is - I'm not saying Luke should or shouldn't remove it. Thats his decision, but if somebody asked me to completely remove one of my photos then, for me, I'd have to think long and hard. I can see off a website at a push, but out of a personal portfolio as well?

Hugh

Yeah thats whats getting me, I cant even have it as my desktop lol
 
Ummmmm I am deleteing it but understand its an image that I really like and I have future plans for all my street stuff but thats another thread. Its fustrating because I dont have a reason.

I don't see what the fuss is about. You like the image. He's asking you to remove it from the website, not delete it for ever , right?

You'll still have it on your hard drive.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top