Street Portrait- not a happy person- advice please :)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because its upsetting somebody. So why are you persisting to upset them? Maybe they just don't like the way they look in the image.

Why not just take it out of the public eye and keep it for your self?

Sorry but I'm going with the majority here, and not to delete it until he is completely sure that the request is genuine, especially considering what Luke's main subject is, and how he likes the photo. I can see where you are coming from though.
 
So why not temporarily remove it from your blog/flickr/website whilst you establish that the person that has requested you do so is indeed the man in the photo? If it is him, you have shown moral fortitude and if not, you can easily put it back again. There could be a 101 reasons why a person would suddenly not want their image in the public domain, from involvement in illegal activities themselves, to being involved in cases [witnesses for example] and as already mentioned, being the subject of someone elses sick mind.

Oh and dont forget, google indexes this forum regularly, given that you have used the picture title in the thread, it may easily be found in a search. Nothing wrong in that per se, but depending on the reasons for wanting the removal, it may just add to his distress.

Yeah fair point but I know he doesn't just want it suddenly removed because he said he tried e-mailing me before but it wouldn't work because of his computer, which is why I have no idea why he didn't just ring me. If it was that serious he would have done. And he also hasn't replied to my question of where it was taken which I sent over an hour ago and he replied to my other messages within 3 minutes. So considering its been up 2 months im not removing anything until he replies to my message, I think thats fair because its just too wierd at the moment.
 
I like the processing on a lot of those shots. Care to share? :)

Regarding the thread, yep.. remove.. as hard as it is. I've had similar grief. If it finishes on a good note, maybe he'll recommend you to others.
 
Because its upsetting somebody. So why are you persisting to upset them? Maybe they just don't like the way they look in the image.

Why not just take it out of the public eye and keep it for your self?

Im pretty sure you havn't read thw whole of the thread. Please do especially post 60. Basically there are strong reasons why I belive this is a wind up of some sort. Read the whole thing and you will understand.
 
I like the processing on a lot of those shots. Care to share? :)

Regarding the thread, yep.. remove.. as hard as it is. I've had similar grief. If it finishes on a good note, maybe he'll recommend you to others.

Yep I push alot of sliders :), seriously though spend a week reading my old threads and you'll get it.
 
Yep I push alot of sliders :), seriously though spend a week reading my old threads and you'll get it.

I'm not a baby mate :) You can speak to me in tech speak, I will understand :) *Basically I haven't got a week as good as the info is likely to be)
 
I'm not a baby mate :) You can speak to me in tech speak, I will understand :) *Basically I haven't got a week as good as the info is likely to be)

I thought you were asking sarcastically because of a previous thread sorry. All of the processing is different, lots of contrast, vignette. I literally do play with the sliders sometimes and I stumble across something I like then I save it as a preset, every photo has different processing though because every photo is different. Ok thread back on topic :)
 
I thought you were asking sarcastically because of a previous thread sorry. All of the processing is different, lots of contrast, vignette. I literally do play with the sliders sometimes and I stumble across something I like then I save it as a preset, every photo has different processing though because every photo is different. Ok thread back on topic :)

Not at all! Was a genuine compliment. Always got an eye out for good processing.
 
You caught me I didn't notice it was a three page thread only read the first page! Sorry didn't realise until after.

Don't think I've changed my stance, But I'm just a tourist!

Stuart
 
You caught me I didn't notice it was a three page thread only read the first page! Sorry didn't realise until after.

Don't think I've changed my stance, But I'm just a tourist!

Stuart

Basically if this guy is who he says he is and answers my very fair questions in post #60 ill remove straight away even though I really like the pic. Its just at this moment time I have no reason to belive this is real really, especially as its been nearly two hours since my last message to him.
 
do you mind explaining why you think this.

Not at all.

The person in the photograph would prefer that the photograph isn't on the internet so politely asked that it be removed.

I can't believe there is a three (now four) page thread on an internet forum about whether it should stay or go!

Do the decent thing. Honour the request. Move on.
 
Luke Mate, you have a lot of great pics on your site, do you really need this one ... wind up or no wind maybe better in the long run just to take it down....
 
Not at all.

The person in the photograph would prefer that the photograph isn't on the internet so politely asked that it be removed.

I can't believe there is a three (now four) page thread on an internet forum about whether it should stay or go!

Do the decent thing. Honour the request. Move on.

BUT we dont know know if this is really him. I dont think it is, this is why the thread is so long. Ill say once again, once my questions have been answered it will be removed but not a moment before.
 
Luke Mate, you have a lot of great pics on your site, do you really need this one ... wind up or no wind maybe better in the long run just to take it down....

I dont understand why I would remove the pic if its a windup? surely that means the person winging me up has got what they wanted?
 
1. The person is entitled to their privacy if they want it and leaving their image online after they have asked for it to be removed might not be illegal but is certainly immoral in my opinion

NO, they are not - not if they are in a public place when the picture was taken.

Luke - can we see the pic somewhere?
 
It wasn't even in your mind to question it until someone raised the point on here!

Hey? maybe ive gone crazy but can you please point me to the post where someone doubted it before me? I asked him where it was taken 2 hours and 20 minutes ago.

EDIT: Id also like to add that I posted this for advcie,which is what I have got and needed, so if someone did suggest that it may not be real before I thought of it then thank you to them.
 
He obviously doesn't. As it's a picture of him that is serving no purpose common decency would make it a no brainer, surely?

How do you mean?

I mean do as the man has asked you politely to do, I fear that your camera may be placed firmly up your ring otherwise, you will not be difficult to find and if you want to succeed in business you need to take some knocks, leaving that picture on your blog will only bring you negative publicity.

I don't know how old you are but do seem to come across as very immature, take the hit.
 
I mean do as the man has asked you politely to do, I fear that your camera may be placed firmly up your ring otherwise, you will not be difficult to find and if you want to succeed in business you need to take some knocks, leaving that picture on your blog will only bring you negative publicity.

I don't know how old you are but do seem to come across as very immature, take the hit.

Have you read the whole thread?
 
I've read this thread from the off and its baffled me as to why it really exists

some people for whatever reason dont want there faces on the internet , I'd save yourself a lot of potential hassle and just remove it
 
I'd take it down, (but not remove it from my HD,) not give it a second thought, and move on with the more important things in life tbh. :)

Luke, you have obvious talent as a photographer, with lots of very good work to your name, and imho, this isn't worth the time you're devoting to it. Even if it's a wind up - (really, how sad is that?) do you really care if the person behind it "feels they've won?".

I'd have gone for that ride along the seafront. :thumbs:

(All said in a good-natured tone btw, just in case the internet decides to project my comments with a negative vibe this evening.) ;)
 
I mean do as the man has asked you politely to do, I fear that your camera may be placed firmly up your ring otherwise, you will not be difficult to find and if you want to succeed in business you need to take some knocks, leaving that picture on your blog will only bring you negative publicity.

I don't know how old you are but do seem to come across as very immature, take the hit.

Luke isn't being immature. He doesn't want to delete the image for many reasons, and to be honest, he knows more about what's happening and he has a better understanding of what's going on than you probably do. :nono:
 
From the first word.

But I don't get it? I was having a very good conversation with the guy, even though a little strange. Then I ask him to politely to confirm where it was taken and no reply. The I messaged him very politely again, still no reply. If this is real I have said ill take it down but I dont get why i would possibly remove a photo when I have no reason to believe this is real? The photo is one I like, hence why its on my blog. Please explain this to me.
 
I've read this thread from the off and its baffled me as to why it really exists

some people for whatever reason dont want there faces on the internet , I'd save yourself a lot of potential hassle and just remove it

All the perosn has to do is send me one message, that is all, its not rocket science and ill remove it.
 
If that is so, why the hell is he asking on here ?

He has learnt more and found out more about the guy (even if it is him) and he is now asking a much broader question as to what he thinks he should do. Obviously, you have your views and I'm sure he will take them into consideration when he decides what to do - as it is, however, he is waiting for a response, and in my first post I said that he should wait until he has more information, anyway.

Nice picture, btw! :thumbs:
 
But I don't get it? I was having a very good conversation with the guy, even though a little strange. Then I ask him to politely to confirm where it was taken and no reply. The I messaged him very politely again, still no reply. If this is real I have said ill take it down but I dont get why i would possibly remove a photo when I have no reason to believe this is real? The photo is one I like, hence why its on my blog. Please explain this to me.

His boos walked in to the room, his dinner was ready, his Cafe time was up, he ran out of credit - who knows, I know that I would have had it down in a flash until I had got to the bottom of it, common decency in my eyes and that is one thing that this country is lacking - I know I wouldn't be asking you twice.
 
I'm with Luke on this one. Luke has said he will remove the photo if the guy who is sending him messages can prove he is the guy in the photo. Luke has given him a chance to prove this but has heard nothing since......

I think you are doing the right thing Luke and are going about it in the right way.
 
i am amazed that we are up to about 110 posts or so as to whether a picture should or should not remain in the public domain.

Personally, wind up or not, i'd remove it from the blog. If its not a wind up - maybe he's gone to the pub for a beer, and it seemed to me to be a polite reasonable request I don't see the issue - as a portrait, it's ok, but nothing "special" - sorry - the ones of the homeless guy with the cigarette are much much better......... artistically speaking - hope you bought him a cup of tea or a sandwich for being your model.

If I was the guy in question, and stumbled upon this thread, given he knows your name, and a bit of googling will soon bring you here, then i'd be a bit pi55ed at such a debate, over something so trivial.

therefore - ditch it - no big deal.

Lynton
 
His boos walked in to the room, his dinner was ready, his Cafe time was up, he ran out of credit - who knows, I know that I would have had it down in a flash until I had got to the bottom of it, common decency in my eyes and that is one thing that this country is lacking - I know I wouldn't be asking you twice.

I do see where your coming from with that however as you will have previously read I gave him my name and wesbiste and told him to contact me. I hear nothing for two months even though he had my phone number and now this? By the way he was talking in the messages, even though he wants the photos removed so badly he can wait until he gets his message. He was very polite to me and said thank you for being so considerate twice so I dont think im lacking common decency and please stop with the insults.
 
i am amazed that we are up to about 110 posts or so as to whether a picture should or should not remain in the public domain.

Personally, wind up or not, i'd remove it from the blog. If its not a wind up - maybe he's gone to the pub for a beer, and it seemed to me to be a polite reasonable request I don't see the issue - as a portrait, it's ok, but nothing "special" - sorry - the ones of the homeless guy with the cigarette are much much better......... artistically speaking - hope you bought him a cup of tea or a sandwich for being your model.

If I was the guy in question, and stumbled upon this thread, given he knows your name, and a bit of googling will soon bring you here, then i'd be a bit pi55ed at such a debate, over something so trivial.

therefore - ditch it - no big deal.

Lynton

I always buy the homeless cups of coffee, even when I let them have a day off ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top