Street Portrait- not a happy person- advice please :)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ummmmm I am deleteing it but understand its an image that I really like and I have future plans for all my street stuff but thats another thread. Its fustrating because I dont have a reason.
Good for you and your future plans, but that doesn't detract from the fact that it's common decency to do as politely asked by the subject matter.

In fact, I'm amazed you felt the need to start a thread about it (although, on reflection, perhaps I'm not).
 
Don't remove it from the hard drive. Take it off the internet. That's as far as I'd go. For him to ask you to delete it permanently is going a bit far considering he's probably on CCTV at the same time and place when the shot was taken.
 
Good for you and your future plans, but that doesn't detract from the fact that it's common decency to do as politely asked by the subject matter.

In fact, I'm amazed you felt the need to start a thread about it (although, on reflection, perhaps I'm not).

The photo is one of 20 street portraits that I got printed for my portfolio. If he had messaged me saing sorry mate but I want you to remove the photo for "insert reason" it would have been easier. And I wouldn't have put it on my blog if I didn't really like them amge.
 
Don't remove it from the hard drive. Take it off the internet. That's as far as I'd go. For him to ask you to delete it permanently is going a bit far considering he's probably on CCTV at the same time and place when the shot was taken.

Thats a very good point mate thanks.
 
The photo is one of 20 street portraits that I got printed for my portfolio. If he had messaged me saing sorry mate but I want you to remove the photo for "insert reason" it would have been easier. And I wouldn't have put it on my blog if I didn't really like them amge.
That says far more about you than it does him IMO.
 
I don't get this either :shrug:

Luke seems to be being quite reasonable here.

I just want to clarify

I took this photo two months ago, as soon as it was taken I introduced myself and explained what I was doing and even shook his hand. I told him my name and told him to go on my site and gte in contact to see the pic and if it was cool.

Two months later I get a random message from this guy "if its even him" asking me to remove it with no detailed reason and even asking me to delete it from my harddrive. He has been on my website ages ago but couldn't e-mail me? my site has my phone number on so if it was this important why didn't he call? Or go to an internet cafe and e-mail me? Actually thats another question I shall ask if he replies to my first question.

EDIT: If it was that much of a problem having his photo taken (and he has made out it really is) then why did he not say when I took the photo and told him id put it on my site?
 
I just want to clarify

I took this photo two months ago, as soon as it was taken I introduced myself and explained what I was doing and even shook his hand. I told him my name and told him to go on my site and gte in contact to see the pic and if it was cool.

Two months later I get a random message from this guy "if its even him" asking me to remove it with no detailed reason and even asking me to delete it from my harddrive. He has been on my website ages ago but couldn't e-mail me? my site has my phone number on so if it was this important why didn't he call? Or go to an internet cafe and e-mail me? Actually thats another question I shall ask if he replies to my first question.

The plot thickens.... I would wait for a reply before you delete.
 
I just want to clarify

I took this photo two months ago, as soon as it was taken I introduced myself and explained what I was doing and even shook his hand. I told him my name and told him to go on my site and gte in contact to see the pic and if it was cool.

Two months later I get a random message from this guy "if its even him" asking me to remove it with no detailed reason and even asking me to delete it from my harddrive. He has been on my website ages ago but couldn't e-mail me? my site has my phone number on so if it was this important why didn't he call? Or go to an internet cafe and e-mail me? Actually thats another question I shall ask if he replies to my first question.

It definitely seems odd - leave it on until:

A. You're satisfied that it's him.

B. He's given you a good enough reason.

C. Don't delete it completely, because he has no right to make you do that.

But that's my opinion. :thumbs:
 
It definitely seems odd - leave it on until:

A. You're satisfied that it's him.

B. He's given you a good enough reason.

C. Don't delete it completely, because he has no right to make you do that.

But that's my opinion. :thumbs:

This is exactly how I feel. I just want to know if its him and why didnt he ring me or say something in the first place? Because I dont know the reason he wants it removed I think those are fair questions.
 
I was going to post earlier....

You cannot be absolutely sure this is him.

How on earth can the 'person' demand that all evidence is removed, impossible to satisfy this requirement IMHO.

Remove from the website (for now) and see what happens.
 
Tell him to send you £100,when it arrives,you`ll delete it........:naughty:
 
Im not removing anything for now, sorry this is just strange. Still no reply and I sent him this e-mail

This is very strange and I might be I reading too much into this but every message you sent you replied to within 3 minutes but its been half an hour since your last reply. Theres just a couple more things I want to know.

1, You said you couldn't e-mail me but my phone number is on my site next to the e-mail so why didn't you phone or use an internet cafe?

2, If a photo of you is so serious why didn't you say when I took the photo, shook your hand and told you about my site etc?

Sorry for the questions but there are people out there who just play games with other peoples sites.

Kind Regards,

Luke
 
Well it could be a 'mate' who he has shown off to. Getting it deleted would be a lark :lol:

An interesting discussion. Can't wait to see what happens next!

Graham
 
Well it could be a 'mate' who he has shown off to. Getting it deleted would be a lark :lol:

An interesting discussion. Can't wait to see what happens next!

Graham

Tell me about it, I was going to go for a nice evening ride along the seafront until this happened!
 
I have had a look and the first thing I noticed was the contradiction of the text: "He was actually a really nice guy, a bit bewildered by me but I think thats understandable". And the title: "About to be Punched".

Legally you can leave it there but I think morally, because you state he is a nice guy, the title is defamatory and you should remove it.

If he really was a nasty piece of work and was about to punch you, I would suggest keeping it but that's not the case here.

There is a lot of good stuff on your blog and I don't think the loss of this image would detract from the overall content and quality of your collection of images.


Steve.
 
I have had a look and the first thing I noticed was the contradiction of the text "He was actually a really nice guy, a bit bewildered by me but I think thats understandable". And the title "About to be Punched".

Legally you can leave it there but I think morally, because you state he is a nice guy, the title is defamatory and you should remove it.

If he really was a nasty piece of work and was about to punch you, I would suggest keeping it but that's not the case here.

There is a lot of good stuff on your blog and I don't think the loss of this image would detract from the overall conten and quality of your collection of images.


Steve.

Thanks for the comment but he's not bothered about the title, he hasn't even mentioned it. In the future I may be a bit more careful about titles but I don't really see the point in changing it when it's not the issue. Oh and the title in contradictory but I called it that because I struggle with names and thats what he looks like he's going to do. I did also say that it was the closest ive felt to being punched.


Also still no reply, nearly an hour.
 
Good for you and your future plans, but that doesn't detract from the fact that it's common decency to do as politely asked by the subject matter.

do you mind explaining why you think this. If we're going to talk about common decency then not putting yourself in a position where you can be the subject of a photo entiltled 'About to be punched' is far better than asking for it to be deleted afterwards. He's given AFAIK no reason for wanting it deleting.

Theres photos of me I'd love deleting, mainly cause they remind me of how little hair I have :D, but none of me that you could give that title too.

For me, I may delete it from my blog, but I'd not delete from my portfolio.

Hugh
 
Why do you feel that common curiosity has to be legislated? There are regular complains here about Photographers coming up against the law. but why make an excuse for a law to be generated?

Somebody doesn't want there picture taken. Just resect that and move on to the next person!

Stuart
 
I Certainly would not have used that title even though he says he is fine with it.
He has asked for it to be removed from the public view and i totally respect that and would do but i would not remove it all together especially if you like it.
I had banned a India lady from the market stall i worked on she then came back the next day with about 60 family members to do me over but i was off.
The next time i was on i was told they were on there way so grabbed my camera that i had taken ready and as soon as the leader approached i took a clear head on shot in case i had to get the police involved i still have the shot somewhere.
I kept it incase anything came about later even though i had cleared things up with the family as she had swore at me and assaulted me hence why i had banned her.
Sorry for the rant but i hope it serves a purpose despite the fact you like the shot there could be other reasons to keep hold of it besides that.
 
Why do you feel that common curiosity has to be legislated? There are regular complains here about Photographers coming up against the law. but why make an excuse for a law to be generated?

Somebody doesn't want there picture taken. Just resect that and move on to the next person!

Stuart

WTF? Why am I going to delete a photo when at this present moment in time I have more reason to belive that this person is fake than real.
 
So why not temporarily remove it from your blog/flickr/website whilst you establish that the person that has requested you do so is indeed the man in the photo? If it is him, you have shown moral fortitude and if not, you can easily put it back again. There could be a 101 reasons why a person would suddenly not want their image in the public domain, from involvement in illegal activities themselves, to being involved in cases [witnesses for example] and as already mentioned, being the subject of someone elses sick mind.

Oh and dont forget, google indexes this forum regularly, given that you have used the picture title in the thread, it may easily be found in a search. Nothing wrong in that per se, but depending on the reasons for wanting the removal, it may just add to his distress.
 
Because its upsetting somebody. So why are you persisting to upset them? Maybe they just don't like the way they look in the image.

Why not just take it out of the public eye and keep it for your self?
 
I was asked to remove a portrait from the internet once.
The reason for the request was that the subject felt uncomfortable.
That was good enough a reason for me, I removed it and never gave it a second thought.
Ordinary peeps are ordinary peeps, if somebody isn't happy for you to use their likeness regardless of the legalities, and if we aren't to be viewed as tin pot pappz who don't give a ***** who they upset, I think its courteous to remove it.
This is if it isn't a wind up ofcourse..
 
Oh and dont forget, google indexes this forum regularly, given that you have used the picture title in the thread, it may easily be found in a search. Nothing wrong in that per se, but depending on the reasons for wanting the removal, it may just add to his distress.

Yeah ive noticed TP comes up in searches often.
 
Because its upsetting somebody. So why are you persisting to upset them? Maybe they just don't like the way they look in the image.

In itself I don't think thats a reason to delete a photograph, there are hundreds of images published every day that doubtless upset somebody - for heaps of reasons. That it causes upset, and there is no real reason to think thats the case here, is not by itself a good reason

Hugh
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top