What's the purpose of stacking ? - Eqpt used info added

jgs001

Brian Cox
Messages
12,646
Name
John
Edit My Images
Yes
I've been asked in several threads for the rationale behind stacking (combining) images in Astro photography.

Stacking is used to increase the Signal to Noise ratio in an image. It can also, depending on the combination method remove other objects, like planes that pass through an image. Given the sky conditions with light pollution etc, it's difficult to actually spend longer than 15 to 20 minutes per frame (dependant on settings) before the image becomes over saturated with light, and burns out. Given that we are trying to get images of subjects that are a very long way away, gather as much light from that target as possible, and minimise the impact of local light pollution, it's a balancing act, but that's no different to normal photography anyway.

Here's an example of a single frame from my stack of M42 data

IMG_2240.jpg


As you can see, a plane flew right through the middle of my FOV as I was taking this shot. Also not, the actually image does not contain as much fine detail as the combined stacked shot. By using a sigma clipping algorithm in the stack, the pixels containing the plane, only being in existence in this frame and no others are removed, leaving only the data I was actually after (I did use this frame in the stack). Here's another example with a satellite passing through the frame

IMG_1817.jpg



Here is the resulting image

m42-14-22-feb-final.jpg


With my current setup, I cannot take a shot for 144 minutes, the stars would be all sorts of odd shapes, if you could see them through the light pollution, which I doubt, as I suspect the result would be blank white. The shot would also be spoiled, by the plane and a satellite that passed through. You can also see, if you look at the result and individual sub frames, that the fine detail that the stack has pulled out is not readily visible.

What I also did was to take a sequence of dark frames, exactly the same exposures, but with the scope capped, which is used to remove camera sensor noise and hot and cold pixels from each frame. The camera can do this with in camera noise reduction, but that would mean each 2 minute exposure would take 4 minutes, whereas, I can take twice as many light frames (image data), then take maybe 10 or 15 dark frames and combine them into an averaged version to subtract from all the light frames. It's important that the camera is at the same temperature as the image frames. I also used flat frames, which remove vignetting, and any dirt from the imaging train when these are subtracted (in much the same way as darks), and flat darks, same as for the image darks, but to remove sensor noise from the flat frames.

So the image might have been some 80 frames of actual data, but there were a further 45 frames of noise and other adjustments frames taken for this.

I hope this helps explain the rationale behind it and gives an example of the benefits for those that have been asking.
 
Excellent explanation (and cool photos)
 
Thank you.

Ruth, the purple wavy stuff is Nebula. This region is a massive star forming region, thus the very bright core region (there's a lot of new hot stars in there). The Nebula is made up of dust and gas, the blue stuff it reflecting light from stars, the red stuff (and this my unmodded camera doesn't collect very well, as the fitted filter blocks the infrared light. It won't be modded though, but I am going to bye me another at some point with the express idea of removing that filter) is gas that is emitting light in the infra red region of the spectrum.
 
Really helpful, I've been wanting to do photos like this for a while now, and will be next time I'm in Scotland where there will be little light pollution.

Could anyone point me in the direction of the programme used to stack these images?
 
John, these are really great shots and the stacking explanation is useful. I think some thing that would be of interest to me certainly, is detail of your setup to get these kind of shots. I would love to do these, but know that just with my camera and lens it's not possible.

So, what do you need? In all its gory detail please!!
 
Thanks for the write up- must try this some time when I get some astrophotgraphy gear together again. We used to use a very similar frame registration technique in the days of astrophotography with 'real' film. Litterally stacking the cut slide film frames one on top of the other- being ultra careful to keep all the stars aligned through the stack. The stacked slides were then re-photographed to get the final image. The effect was to reduce the 'noise' caused by the grain of the film and enhance any fine detail.

A single frame of comet Hale Bopp (Ektachrome 400 slide film) the colour looks a bit washy and the film grain is apparent.
HALE_BOPP_SINGLE.jpg


Stack two or three slides together and you loose some the film grain, light pollution is lessened plus the comet's tails stand out more.
HALE_BOPP_STACK.jpg


Good to see that image 'stacking' is still used- but is it still a pain to get the stars in register?
 
John thats a brilliant tutorial
( I will admit to not understanding it all though)
and the final image is superb :thumbs:

Lazer Jock
Thats also pretty damned good :thumbs:
 
what software do u use to achieve this?

I can't believe you got some kind of stellar mass / galaxy in there, its absolutely amazing!!!
 
Thanks all.

Xeno and Ricky, http://deepskystacker.free.fr/english/index.html was used to stack these, it's also free :D. Ricky, that's not a galaxy, it's actually within the Milky Way, From memory about 1200 light years away. I went out on Saturday night, missed the target I wanted, but got a couple of others, they are some 40 million light years away (the light left the galaxies 40 million years ago), it's not a good image as I didn't get anywhere near enough exposure time, the clouds moved in. Ricky, under suitably dark skies, it's possible to see M42 without any equipment, a pair of 10x50 binoculars will shot it nicely, it won't look anything like this or any image you see of it though, just a faint grey whispyness.

Laser_jock, that's superb, the technique appears to be identical. Registering and stacking is much easier, load the frames into the software and click go.... Some time later, depending on the machine in use, the stack will complete. The trick is in using the appropriate settings for the stack, and post processing after stacking.

Sara, Here's a pic of my new rig which was used to collect the data for this M42 image.
PICT0197.jpg


It's a bit grainy, shot with the Z2, as the 450d is attached to the scope. What we have here, from the bottom up..

a Skywatcher HEQ5 Syntrek mount, this is a combination of 1.5" steel tube legs and the head. The head contains the tracking motors and is operated by a hand controller that's not attached in this shot. It can be controlled from a laptop also, and that's something I plan on doing. On the lower end is a 5Kg counter weight to ensure that the tubes are balanced out properly which aids in tracking, by relieving motor strain.

a Celestron C80ED, an 80mm aperture, 600mm focal length, APO telescope, with a focal ratio of f7.5. This is the imaging scope and has the 450d attached via T thread.

a Konus Vista 80s (my original scope, and was used for last years imaging, it's not a well corrected scope, and suffers a log from CA). It's an 80mm aperture, 400mm focal length, f5 scope. This will be used as my guide scope, with a secondary camera attached. This will mean, that the mount, with a computer control attached can accurately track the night sky, enabling single images of well over 20 minutes (assuming light pollution doesn't spoil each frame long before then of course :D).

The most important part of the rig for imaging is the mount, of course, this is no different for any form of photography where longer exposures are being taken, you can't afford to have wobbles. Even if you spent a larger fortune on decent optics, without a heavy duty mount underneath, you won't get decent images. The next most important thing is decent quality optics, you can spend silly money, but it's not necessary. With this setup, when I get everything right, I've been able to get nearly 4 minute exposures without trailing, when it's not setup exactly right, I can still get 2.5 minutes.
 
That's absolutely fascinating John and an excellent explanation too.:clap::clap:
 
Thanks Karin, glad it was clear.
 
Thanks for that John. Can I ask a really cheeky question regards price for this set up? Also, I'm not quite sure about the bit on the top. The camera is connected to the scope right? So is that onto of the scope part of it or another device?

John, have re read and stuff - Understand now what it is!! A guide scope that is piggy backing the camera scope? So you need to use this one to get to where you want then take the pics using the other one. Am I on the right track?
 
John many thanks for taking the time to explain your set up and techniques

Absolutely stunning stuff! :)
 
Thanks for that John. Can I ask a really cheeky question regards price for this set up? Also, I'm not quite sure about the bit on the top. The camera is connected to the scope right? So is that onto of the scope part of it or another device?

John, have re read and stuff - Understand now what it is!! A guide scope that is piggy backing the camera scope? So you need to use this one to get to where you want then take the pics using the other one. Am I on the right track?

Sara, you got it, nearly. The guidescope is used to keep the imaging scope precisely aligned on target and thus will adjust to remove any errors from the mechanics of the drives. You can indeed ask. The guide scope I got for £60 (on sale from Park Cameras) it was my primary scope till just before xmas, the imaging scope, is currently on a special price (I think they are in the process of selling off old stock ready to replace with a new version for double the price) £214, the mount... that's the expensive bit. I got that just before the prices rose by 30% and paid £500. I've still got some bits to work out with it, and that will probably involve me having to spend more :bang:. Cabling, power, guide camera... It would be nice to get a cooled Astro CCD camera, instead of using the 450d, but you're talking £1500+ for one of those.


You're welcome Andy.

John many thanks for taking the time to explain your set up and techniques

Absolutely stunning stuff! :)

You're welcome John.
 
With the tracking on the mount - Is that a type of 'goTo' system or putely for tracking once you have found what you are looking for? I ask because I have got a scope that once aligned, I can tell it where to look. So can you do tihs with the mount? If so, is it easy to align? Mine is a bloody nightmare and takes lots of the fun out of it for me.
 
Sara, that's a non goto mount, the drives are just for tracking. I can upgrade it to goto for about £200, by replacing the handset. Or, and this is something I'm working on, I can hook it up to a lappy for about £20, and use free software to make it fully goto, and use the same components for the guiding. I've just gotta make a cable, and make sure I get it right, or risk blowing the controllers on the mount... :(
 
Back
Top