jgs001
Brian Cox
- Messages
- 12,646
- Name
- John
- Edit My Images
- Yes
I've been asked in several threads for the rationale behind stacking (combining) images in Astro photography.
Stacking is used to increase the Signal to Noise ratio in an image. It can also, depending on the combination method remove other objects, like planes that pass through an image. Given the sky conditions with light pollution etc, it's difficult to actually spend longer than 15 to 20 minutes per frame (dependant on settings) before the image becomes over saturated with light, and burns out. Given that we are trying to get images of subjects that are a very long way away, gather as much light from that target as possible, and minimise the impact of local light pollution, it's a balancing act, but that's no different to normal photography anyway.
Here's an example of a single frame from my stack of M42 data
As you can see, a plane flew right through the middle of my FOV as I was taking this shot. Also not, the actually image does not contain as much fine detail as the combined stacked shot. By using a sigma clipping algorithm in the stack, the pixels containing the plane, only being in existence in this frame and no others are removed, leaving only the data I was actually after (I did use this frame in the stack). Here's another example with a satellite passing through the frame
Here is the resulting image
With my current setup, I cannot take a shot for 144 minutes, the stars would be all sorts of odd shapes, if you could see them through the light pollution, which I doubt, as I suspect the result would be blank white. The shot would also be spoiled, by the plane and a satellite that passed through. You can also see, if you look at the result and individual sub frames, that the fine detail that the stack has pulled out is not readily visible.
What I also did was to take a sequence of dark frames, exactly the same exposures, but with the scope capped, which is used to remove camera sensor noise and hot and cold pixels from each frame. The camera can do this with in camera noise reduction, but that would mean each 2 minute exposure would take 4 minutes, whereas, I can take twice as many light frames (image data), then take maybe 10 or 15 dark frames and combine them into an averaged version to subtract from all the light frames. It's important that the camera is at the same temperature as the image frames. I also used flat frames, which remove vignetting, and any dirt from the imaging train when these are subtracted (in much the same way as darks), and flat darks, same as for the image darks, but to remove sensor noise from the flat frames.
So the image might have been some 80 frames of actual data, but there were a further 45 frames of noise and other adjustments frames taken for this.
I hope this helps explain the rationale behind it and gives an example of the benefits for those that have been asking.
Stacking is used to increase the Signal to Noise ratio in an image. It can also, depending on the combination method remove other objects, like planes that pass through an image. Given the sky conditions with light pollution etc, it's difficult to actually spend longer than 15 to 20 minutes per frame (dependant on settings) before the image becomes over saturated with light, and burns out. Given that we are trying to get images of subjects that are a very long way away, gather as much light from that target as possible, and minimise the impact of local light pollution, it's a balancing act, but that's no different to normal photography anyway.
Here's an example of a single frame from my stack of M42 data
As you can see, a plane flew right through the middle of my FOV as I was taking this shot. Also not, the actually image does not contain as much fine detail as the combined stacked shot. By using a sigma clipping algorithm in the stack, the pixels containing the plane, only being in existence in this frame and no others are removed, leaving only the data I was actually after (I did use this frame in the stack). Here's another example with a satellite passing through the frame
Here is the resulting image
With my current setup, I cannot take a shot for 144 minutes, the stars would be all sorts of odd shapes, if you could see them through the light pollution, which I doubt, as I suspect the result would be blank white. The shot would also be spoiled, by the plane and a satellite that passed through. You can also see, if you look at the result and individual sub frames, that the fine detail that the stack has pulled out is not readily visible.
What I also did was to take a sequence of dark frames, exactly the same exposures, but with the scope capped, which is used to remove camera sensor noise and hot and cold pixels from each frame. The camera can do this with in camera noise reduction, but that would mean each 2 minute exposure would take 4 minutes, whereas, I can take twice as many light frames (image data), then take maybe 10 or 15 dark frames and combine them into an averaged version to subtract from all the light frames. It's important that the camera is at the same temperature as the image frames. I also used flat frames, which remove vignetting, and any dirt from the imaging train when these are subtracted (in much the same way as darks), and flat darks, same as for the image darks, but to remove sensor noise from the flat frames.
So the image might have been some 80 frames of actual data, but there were a further 45 frames of noise and other adjustments frames taken for this.
I hope this helps explain the rationale behind it and gives an example of the benefits for those that have been asking.


