Who is Ann Hillsgrove and why did she steal from Syl Arena??

Messages
3,696
Name
Frank
Edit My Images
Yes
A copy of a post from PotN by Troubleshot -

http://speedliting.com/

Some people have no class, no scruples at all. Still, it's all good publicity - I ended up buying a copy of the book as I'd been looking for a good guide to Canon Speedlites.
 
Last edited:
I think it came of as a massive cry baby whine. Yes it's theft but the rant was far from elegant, had flawed reasoning (100 free downloads is not 100 lost sales) and outing the person into the lime light as a thief perhaps overly harsh.

In this day it should be expected that your work will be pirated, in some way. The only way to prevent this is to not release a digitised version and even then someone with a scanner will often make one.
 
I read that as well and ended up buying the book. Turned up from Amazon today so that's tonight's reading sorted. The new AP will have to wait.
 
I think it came of as a massive cry baby whine. Yes it's theft but the rant was far from elegant, had flawed reasoning (100 free downloads is not 100 lost sales) and outing the person into the lime light as a thief perhaps overly harsh.

In this day it should be expected that your work will be pirated, in some way. The only way to prevent this is to not release a digitised version and even then someone with a scanner will often make one.

If someone breaks into your house and nicks all your camera gear, I guess by your reasoning it's your fault for leaving it in your house for someone to steal. You've got a pretty weak argument. You're basically excusing people for stealing just because they can. What happened to common decency?
 
wonder if i can get in touch with Ann .... see if shes still got a copy.... :)
 
It's a very good book I bought off Amazon and finished just a day or two ago but hes probably started a double edged sword. On the one hand it'll stir up publicity and get people buying it that would but on the other it advertises the fact you can get it for free, I spent all of 30 seconds before I found it for download.
 
Yeah, but like Chris said - thieving scumbags who've never created anything worthwhile in their lives will always find a way to avoid any contribution to society.
 
Last edited:
djinn said:
wonder if i can get in touch with Ann .... see if shes still got a copy.... :)

By all accounts, the downloadable PDF is floating round on the Internet, obviously passed on by one (or many) of the subscribers to the website that AH uploaded to. Probably didn't take long....

As for the 100 downloads = 100 lost sales, who says that can't be true? This is stealing, plain and simple, but its masked by some Robin Hood-esque ideal that surounds the Internet that if it can be made free then it should be free.

I actually have this on my amazon wishlist but just never got round to it because of other purchases. Might just buy it, even if it is for Canon shooters......
 
I have a canon flash but ended up buying Hot Shoe Diaries. Have not read it yet. Do you think the book you guys are talking about would still be of value? I struggle with getting flash to do what I want. I can balance flash ok'ish.. but I'm not great at it.
 
I have both books dubcat, the "Hot shoe diaries" are ok but as it says more of a diary of shots and roughly how they where taken, Syl's book goes through, custom functions, modifiers, gels, stands, direction of light, balancing ambient vs flash etc etc then has a section on how some shots were taken along with diagrams & settings. It's well worth it :)
 
Calzor Suzay said:
I have both books dubcat, the "Hot shoe diaries" are ok but as it says more of a diary of shots and roughly how they where taken, Syl's book goes through, custom functions, modifiers, gels, stands, direction of light, balancing ambient vs flash etc etc then has a section on how some shots were taken along with diagrams & settings. It's well worth it :)

Sounds good - suppose it'll be quite easy to see through the Canon talk and see the theory that can be applied to any system.

TBH, hotshot diaries is okay but it's a bit loose, a bit too anecdotal for it to be a proper learning tool IMO. It's great as a motivational read but it wasn't as good as I thought it would be. Probably Joe's infectious enthusiasm makes it into a better read than if it were written by someone else.
 
Calzor Suzay said:
I have both books dubcat, the "Hot shoe diaries" are ok but as it says more of a diary of shots and roughly how they where taken, Syl's book goes through, custom functions, modifiers, gels, stands, direction of light, balancing ambient vs flash etc etc then has a section on how some shots were taken along with diagrams & settings. It's well worth it :)

Thanks :) I think I will buy it.
 
If someone breaks into your house and nicks all your camera gear, I guess by your reasoning it's your fault for leaving it in your house for someone to steal. You've got a pretty weak argument. You're basically excusing people for stealing just because they can. What happened to common decency?

Not really the same thing. Would more be like I left my camera gear out on the lawn and was surprised to find that it was gone. If it was locked up it wouldn't have been in the open to the casual thief.

I'm not excusing just saying it's inevitable. I have also had software pirated (admittedly not to the same value) but I understand that the simple fact I made it available means that some one somewhere isn't going to pay for it (even though it was £1 and now 50p so hardly expensive).

edit:

Now if I was a cynical person I'd say this rant has earned more sales than the $200 that was "lost".
 
Last edited:
I think it came of as a massive cry baby whine. Yes it's theft but the rant was far from elegant, had flawed reasoning (100 free downloads is not 100 lost sales) and outing the person into the lime light as a thief perhaps overly harsh.

In this day it should be expected that your work will be pirated, in some way. The only way to prevent this is to not release a digitised version and even then someone with a scanner will often make one.

Your so right, Chris. Your work will be pirated at some point or other. That's the way it is now. What people need to realise is that, like you said, if you offer it over the internet, then someone somewhere will offer it somewhere else for free. If it’s any good or course! If your pirated then take heed in the fact that someone out there thinks you’re pretty good.

I think people need to grow up a little. Through the internet the world is forever changing. What was called a crime 10 years ago for downloading, say an album, book, film, is now quite widely accepted as the norm. And if anyone tells me you've never watched, or purchased some form of pirated material id be aghast. Yes you have the internet police which are about as much use as a community police officer and that is because they really don't give a crap, they have better things to do like catching real criminals!

Take say, Scott kelby for instance. Have a look on pirate bay and see how many people are downloading his books or tutorials. Do you think he's having sleepless nights about it or do you think he’s thinking, the more people that download my stuff is imperative to my book sales. After all we'd all like a hard copy in our hands and maybe the guy who couldn’t afford it just might come into a little cash and actually buy my book. If not so be it. If it aids in the next David Bailey that’s got to be good, right? And let’s not forget his fame and marketability is making him a chunk of money.

I'm not sure how many members are on TP but, I'll swear to GOD, that a whole chunk has a copy of some form of software. PS is the award winner for photo editing pirating along with LR and Elements and others. The bubble is well and truly burst. It seems to me through the amount of people on TP who have CS5 are so cash rich that the recession never happened. Last year businesses where going bust and all of sudden, on this site, most have CS5!! WTF!

Don't lose any sleep over it if you’re the honest one either. One day you may just have to except that the only way to promote yourself is using all avenues that are available to you.

I live in Vietnam as a very few may know. You can't buy much original stuff over here. Do you know they have businesses over hear that are fully staffed with shop logo t-shirts and barcodes etc. that are dedicated to selling pirate copies of whatever. An honest job selling hooky gear. You can't buy an original. But here's the thing....

It's a lively hood for so many people. It goes to the point of life changing for them. It puts food on the table and a TV on the wall and music throughout the house. Not heroin on the table or guns in infant’s hands. It also has a growing creativity through kids inspired by such things as western films, music, books……
But getting back on track, Phew! Yeah the case of this pdf will only add to this persons popularity for sure. Sales will be made. Illegal copies will be downloaded. The Authors popularity and credibility 'WILL' escalate. Who wouldn’t want that?

:)
 
@Vantage, I agree with most of your points, except this one...

I think people need to grow up a little.

Is it childish to protect your intellectual property?
 
Thanks KayJay and I take your point on board. And as correct as you are, I wouldn't want to detract from my feelings on the matter. Sound point though!:thumbs:
 
It's not childish to protect your property, intellectual or other wise. What is childish is having a massive rant on the internet in which you barely stop short of saying "persecute this person".
 
100 free downloads is not 100 lost sales.

Never a truer word spoken and only applies more so to image (mis)use.

Your so right, Chris. Your work will be pirated at some point or other. That's the way it is now. What people need to realise is that, like you said, if you offer it over the internet, then someone somewhere will offer it somewhere else for free. If it’s any good or course! If your pirated then take heed in the fact that someone out there thinks you’re pretty good.

I think people need to grow up a little. Through the internet the world is forever changing. What was called a crime 10 years ago for downloading, say an album, book, film, is now quite widely accepted as the norm. And if anyone tells me you've never watched, or purchased some form of pirated material id be aghast. Yes you have the internet police which are about as much use as a community police officer and that is because they really don't give a crap, they have better things to do like catching real criminals!

Take say, Scott kelby for instance. Have a look on pirate bay and see how many people are downloading his books or tutorials. Do you think he's having sleepless nights about it or do you think he’s thinking, the more people that download my stuff is imperative to my book sales. After all we'd all like a hard copy in our hands and maybe the guy who couldn’t afford it just might come into a little cash and actually buy my book. If not so be it. If it aids in the next David Bailey that’s got to be good, right? And let’s not forget his fame and marketability is making him a chunk of money.

I'm not sure how many members are on TP but, I'll swear to GOD, that a whole chunk has a copy of some form of software. PS is the award winner for photo editing pirating along with LR and Elements and others. The bubble is well and truly burst. It seems to me through the amount of people on TP who have CS5 are so cash rich that the recession never happened. Last year businesses where going bust and all of sudden, on this site, most have CS5!! WTF!

Don't lose any sleep over it if you’re the honest one either. One day you may just have to except that the only way to promote yourself is using all avenues that are available to you.

I live in Vietnam as a very few may know. You can't buy much original stuff over here. Do you know they have businesses over hear that are fully staffed with shop logo t-shirts and barcodes etc. that are dedicated to selling pirate copies of whatever. An honest job selling hooky gear. You can't buy an original. But here's the thing....

It's a lively hood for so many people. It goes to the point of life changing for them. It puts food on the table and a TV on the wall and music throughout the house. Not heroin on the table or guns in infant’s hands. It also has a growing creativity through kids inspired by such things as western films, music, books……
But getting back on track, Phew! Yeah the case of this pdf will only add to this persons popularity for sure. Sales will be made. Illegal copies will be downloaded. The Authors popularity and credibility 'WILL' escalate. Who wouldn’t want that?

:)

It's well known that Adobe not only allow their software to be pirated but actually have a hand in it themselves.
Were it not so easy to get your hands on a pirated copy of Photoshop, it wouldn't have become THE image editing package that everyone knows how to use and Adobe wouldn't be so free to name their price for the professional buyers that need the software that everyone knows how to use.
 
By all accounts, the downloadable PDF is floating round on the Internet, obviously passed on by one (or many) of the subscribers to the website that AH uploaded to. Probably didn't take long....


Yep it is still out there didn't take very long to find it either, a pirated pdf is not for me though I prefer to have a hard copy in my hands that I can take time over reading and going back to at a later date.

The people that will download it will never buy it anyway so I don't agree with 100 sales lost do you count it as lost sales if I am one of a hundred people that get a copy from a library? If I buy the book from someone second hand is that a lost sale?

I do feel sorry for him though it must be hard to see something you’ve put so much time energy and money into reduced to a 2 minute download must be soul destroying, although I hadn’t even heard of this book beforehand I will be keeping an eye out for it and may even get it at some point so people are right a good marketing ploy...
 
Having read through the original article and the 'apology' I would not be so surprised to discover that this particular Ann Hillsgrove is a fictional character!

Good marketing I guess............or am I just too cynical :thinking:
 
Having read through the original article and the 'apology' I would not be so surprised to discover that this particular Ann Hillsgrove is a fictional character!

Good marketing I guess............or am I just too cynical :thinking:

One of the links had a letter.email from Ann Hillsgrove that mentioned facebook, there is an Ann Hillsgrove on FB but only one and most of her info is hidden to non friends. Anyone want to add her n ask if she is the culprit?
 
One of the links had a letter.email from Ann Hillsgrove that mentioned facebook, there is an Ann Hillsgrove on FB but only one and most of her info is hidden to non friends. Anyone want to add her n ask if she is the culprit?

She ain't the culprit, it was someone else using her name and hijacked Facebook account.

Syl Arena now says so and has apologised to her.

http://speedliting.com/how-to/ann-hillsgrove-replies/

Possibly a good thing she's not gone legal on his ass... :suspect:
 
Last edited:
Back
Top