Daft video. He's well out on a limb there and has simply glossed over the fact that Canon has switched to touch-screen centric control - which invalidates the whole basis of his button-centric criticisms. It's a big change, but we're all smartphone users and most buyers will be very happy with it.
Vloggers - crap for clicks
Well he sucked me in.
I did think that he may have gotten wrong the multi step way to change modes. I do think that left eye shooter may have a problem with controlling the AF via the touch screen, and is something they should try out first if possible just in case.
The touchscreen approach may work well for a some people, but one of the reasons a lot of people like the higher end DSLR's is for the quick access to functions via buttons. Yes, some don't like the size and weight, but the quick access to important, often changed settings, can only be a good thing, and if you offer that via dedicated or programmable buttonsdials/switches, and a touch screen, then you cater for more people feeling comfortable using the camera whichever way they choose.
And btw, speak for yourself when you say "we're all smartphone users". I'm not.
His brain hasn't worked out that the Control Ring can be programmed for ISO (working the same for both EF and RF lenses) and the quick selection dial for Exposure Compensation.
Surely the control ring option for EF/EFS lenses is only with the adapter with the control ring!
Not everyone is going to have that.
I totally disagree with him about the On/Off switch - I find it the easiest I have ever experienced to date on any camera.
Not being an EOS R user, having to use the left hand to turn the camera on and off seems a poor bit of design to me. That switch seems an area of the camera that could have done something else, maybe even kept it as a mode dial and used the right hand wheel for something else.
For me, being a mainly Nikon user, I think the on/off button integrated around the shutter button is the best design. You can pick the camera up and turn it on with one hand. I think Sony do something similar, if not the same, though on the Nikon's it sometimes also has an extra spring loaded position that also wakes up the camera and activates the rear screen. And on the cameras that have the option, illuminate the rear buttons too. If we all liked the same things there would be one layout of buttons, or not,
on a different contoured body (or not contoured eh Sony users
).
It will be interesting when Canon do a higher end model, how much stays the same, but then even whether they use the same body which may slightly evolved like Sony, or as Nikon have done, at least with their first two models, used the same body. That is obviously a way to maximise research/design/production costs, as is having fewer buttons/dials.