Is to much being made of video mode?

Yes.

It's just an idiotic "me too" feature.

IMHO it has no place on a DSLR,especially when so much could be done to improve still image quality.

I admit I'm rather luddite about this, but how this became a "must have" in 2009 is beyond me.
 
Try telling a director of photography that video isn't a form of photography. No one is saying it's easy to make videos, not sure where you're getting that from. Just like it's not easy to take great still images.
Since when did a photograph have a soundtrack? Since when did a photograph have cuts and scene changes? How do you make a print of a video to hang on your wall or include in a book, magazine or newspaper? Is a video the same as a photograph? I'm not sure it is. I did briefly look up "photography" on Google and "video" was not included in the results. You can argue semantics if you like. I was not intending to offend anyone. All I was pointing out is that making good videos/movies requires additional skills above and beyond those required for taking photographs - photography - and videos are not photographs.

A DSLR is a very good tool for taking photographs. Excellent in fact. All you need to add is a lens. However, as a video camera, if all you add is a lens, then I do not think you end up with a tool that is a very good video camera. In fact you have quite a poor video camera, all things considered. The point of all this being that for many people, whether interested in the video features or not, the inclusion of video in a DSLR does not make a lot of sense. For many people - I'm taking Joe Public, not professional film makers - the convenience of a dedicated HD camcorder makes a lot more sense than trying to produce a watchable video from a DSLR - IMHO.

BTW, if "photography" includes making movies/videos then what is "cinematography" and what is a "cinematographer"? How does that differ? Is the sound engineer a photographer too? What about the scriptwriter? Like I say, making movies is not photography. It is a whole lot more.

:coat:
 
I dont care about video mode at all. I buy a camera for photography not filming.
 
Before i had one I'd have said what is the point too. Now I'm exploring the possibilities i'm quite enjoying it. My 5D2 will always be my stills camera but the more I experiment the more it looks like it can be my video camera too.

I watched the link in post #40 above and the conclusion there seemed to be that it was worth the effort - and they had to work with the old firmware with no manual control.

It will never be as easy as a dedicated video camera but the results are better than any video camera i might buy..... and i don't have to take another camera with me.
 
the reason I upgraded to the 7d was because of the video. I film as much as I take photos and was fed up with always carrying two cameras around. I was going to upragde to a 50d until the 7d came out and the cost of a 50d and the HD camcorder I was going to upgrade to came out more expensive. Then I saw the quality of the footage on the 7d and it was a no brainer.

I disagree that you have to buy lots of accessories to make the video decent. The audio quality using the built in mic is as good as the audio I got from my panny HD camcorder and the footage is a world apart.

I'm loving the video function on my camera, it rocks
 
Since when did a photograph have a soundtrack? Since when did a photograph have cuts and scene changes? How do you make a print of a video to hang on your wall or include in a book, magazine or newspaper? Is a video the same as a photograph? I'm not sure it is. I did briefly look up "photography" on Google and "video" was not included in the results. You can argue semantics if you like. I was not intending to offend anyone. All I was pointing out is that making good videos/movies requires additional skills above and beyond those required for taking photographs - photography - and videos are not photographs.

A DSLR is a very good tool for taking photographs. Excellent in fact. All you need to add is a lens. However, as a video camera, if all you add is a lens, then I do not think you end up with a tool that is a very good video camera. In fact you have quite a poor video camera, all things considered. The point of all this being that for many people, whether interested in the video features or not, the inclusion of video in a DSLR does not make a lot of sense. For many people - I'm taking Joe Public, not professional film makers - the convenience of a dedicated HD camcorder makes a lot more sense than trying to produce a watchable video from a DSLR - IMHO.

BTW, if "photography" includes making movies/videos then what is "cinematography" and what is a "cinematographer"? How does that differ? Is the sound engineer a photographer too? What about the scriptwriter? Like I say, making movies is not photography. It is a whole lot more.

:coat:

I'm a joe public and I disagree. There is no convenience in a dedicated HD camcorder when you want to film something and take photos of it. It means carrying around two cameras, which I was fed up with doing. Now I just carry one.

I just stuck a lens on mine and found using it for video a synch. It's really not difficult to make a watchable video from a DLSR, in fact it's better. The quality screams. take a look at this for an example

there isn't a chance I'd have been able to get half these shots in low light with my panny HD camcorder I used to have, look particularly at 1.44. Not to mention the awesome bokeh in the first scene in the taxi

[YOUTUBE]<object width="560" height="340"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/y1oO855lQwk&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/y1oO855lQwk&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="560" height="340"></embed></object>[/YOUTUBE]
 
Since when did a photograph have a soundtrack? Since when did a photograph have cuts and scene changes? How do you make a print of a video to hang on your wall or include in a book, magazine or newspaper? Is a video the same as a photograph? I'm not sure it is. I did briefly look up "photography" on Google and "video" was not included in the results. You can argue semantics if you like. I was not intending to offend anyone. All I was pointing out is that making good videos/movies requires additional skills above and beyond those required for taking photographs - photography - and videos are not photographs.

A DSLR is a very good tool for taking photographs. Excellent in fact. All you need to add is a lens. However, as a video camera, if all you add is a lens, then I do not think you end up with a tool that is a very good video camera. In fact you have quite a poor video camera, all things considered. The point of all this being that for many people, whether interested in the video features or not, the inclusion of video in a DSLR does not make a lot of sense. For many people - I'm taking Joe Public, not professional film makers - the convenience of a dedicated HD camcorder makes a lot more sense than trying to produce a watchable video from a DSLR - IMHO.

BTW, if "photography" includes making movies/videos then what is "cinematography" and what is a "cinematographer"? How does that differ? Is the sound engineer a photographer too? What about the scriptwriter? Like I say, making movies is not photography. It is a whole lot more.

:coat:

Ok, let's leave the semantics to the side. But these two videos should show you just how easy it is to make a great video...

The first one, a 5dmk2 and a 15mm fish eye lens. That's all.
http://www.vimeo.com/3155182

Another using available light.
http://www.vimeo.com/2125645

Sure you need to know about composition and what makes a good story, but don't you need those in photography? After all photographs are a method of story telling.
 
My car can do 100... but I'm not a race driver so don't go over 70...

Should I buy a car that can't do 71? Or should I ask the manufacturer not to make cars that can 71?

My oven can go to 280 degrees, but I don't make bricks... should I ask it be maxed to 250?

:shrug:

Some people have use for video.. so it'll be included.

AWP - there have been numerous videos in the wildlife sections :)
 
My car can do 100... but I'm not a race driver so don't go over 70...

Should I buy a car that can't do 71? Or should I ask the manufacturer not to make cars that can 71?

My oven can go to 280 degrees, but I don't make bricks... should I ask it be maxed to 250?

:shrug:

Some people have use for video.. so it'll be included.

AWP - there have been numerous videos in the wildlife sections :)

at a price nae doot!!
 
I'm not sure the accessories argument holds much water, the same could be said for any area of photography. Let's face it the DSLR is capable of close up shots with any kit lens but to do it well and get great macro shots you'll need a specific set of lenses, specialist lighting and a costly tripod head to cope with the small movements required. The same can be said for sports or wildlife, you only get the best results when you attach the long, wide lenses and the right accessories e.g. a gimbol mount. Both have their own set of skills that are unique to that branch of photography. Equally we don't scoff at bridge cameras just because they aren't ever going to match up with the quality of a D3S or a 1Dmkii and a pro lens so why do we scoff at DSLRs just because they have additional functionality :shrug:

I agree that recording moving pictures well will definitely mean learning a whole new set of skills and potentially a whole new set of accessories but I don't see how that means a DSLR shouldn't have the capability of recording moving images. After all it once Live-view got common (remember all those threads questioning the point) it's only a small step to actually take that stream to the memory card; compact cameras have had the ability for years.

Yes it's a marketing tool to allow the camera makers to release a minor improvement as a new model and try to tempt us to upgrade accordingly. Personally I'm pleased they appear to have stopped the Mega Pixel wars and have focused on IQ and ISO along with video.

In response to the OP I'd expect a review to cover all the features on the camera and as video gives different results I'd want to read how it performs in that area. I'd imagine most of us are intelligent enough to ignore the ratings at the end and focus on the things that are important to what we want. So if video isn't important we can ignore that Camera A has a score of 79 whilst Camera B has a score of 82 because it does video better and realise that camera A is better for us because it does what we want better, or am I giving fellow TPers too much credit ;)
 
I'll check the wild life sections.

I watched the Dublin video above - sorry not impressed - doesn't really tell a story - continuous panning and zooming - music (probably unlicenced) doesn't fit - no attempt to edit picture to music - picture quality was the last thing I noticed! Who cares if the quality is great if it's not worth watching.

Probably means a lot more at a personal level to the shooter - and that's great - and no more than I'm expecting from the vast majority of people who have video capability. Certainly for now.
 
I think VIDEO is a great idea. I haven't a clue how to use or process it, but that should not mean not liking it. The wedding shot on 5DMKII's posted here a while back (RaymondLin posted the link)...the wedding video was absolutely epic. These guys were clearly well trained in its use, and I think they had 7 MKII's going too.

I love the idea of having a studio slideshow playing, with maybe 90% images, but a few "moments" where everything just pops to life. I really think VIDEO *SHOULD* be a deciding factor when making a purchase now. Not that it matters, I presume all top end DSLR's are going to have it now?

Gary.
 
Sorry I meant videos posted and taken by TP members - quite a few of them have cameras with video capability.


A quick search on vimeo will show thousands of people using their DSLRs for video. I personally have always been a big fan of video and was chuffed to bits when I got my 500d. I've been shooting so much video the last proper photo I took was actually well over a month ago. At the moment I'm just dabbling in 3D tracking software, so here is my example video just testing that out, it doesn't show off what DSLRs can do but gives you an idea what kind of doors video mode can open:

http://www.vimeo.com/9129105

I also shoot stock video now on my 500d and find it often keeps up with the pros and their cameras. Here's just 2 examples, one with my 250mm and one with the raynox 250 added for macro videography:

Blackbird: http://www.fotolia.com/id/19755592

Match: http://www.fotolia.com/id/19445878


I thought video was just a gimmick too until I actually played around with it and now I wouldn't ever buy a DSLR without it (unless I got a proper video camera that is).

Who cares if the quality is great if it's not worth watching.

But that's not the point. The point is, in the right hands, this is a cheap and easy way of getting into high quality videography.
 
in the middle eighties - early nineties I worked with video along side stills - shooting on Betacam SP. It took at least 2 days planning and 1 day editing for every day with the camera. Videos that are shot off the cuff (like holiday videos) are just snaps on wheels and are rarely worth watching. Combining little edited video clips with stills might be the way to go rather than attempting full size videos - which do require a different skill set to shooting stills.

The fast video distribution available now (YouTube and others) means that people will be more tempted by the fast off the cuff shoots and we will all be drowned in video junk. :(
 
I watched the Dublin video above - sorry not impressed - doesn't really tell a story - continuous panning and zooming - music (probably unlicenced) doesn't fit - no attempt to edit picture to music - picture quality was the last thing I noticed! Who cares if the quality is great if it's not worth watching.
There is also the wobbly/shakey effect, focus sometimes being missed, verticals clearly not being vertical and some quite odd effects on faster pans and motion, including the bus passing through the frame. I only dipped in and out of the sound but I expect that if we had the opportunity to hear the ambient sound we might have heard handling noise from the camera and also the effects of autolevelling, plus the rather lacklustre and thin mono soundtrack.

All in all I thought the video supported my own views quite well. Whether a decent camcorder - something like this : http://www.panasonic.co.uk/html/en_...corders/HDC-TM300/Overview/1973727/index.html - would have improved results I honestly don't know, but if those are the results that "Joe Public" is destined to achieve with a video DSLR I don't think it will raise the bar as far as mass consumer video quality goes. In the hands of a video professional or enthusiast, that's another matter, but in the hands of "Joe Public"....... same ol' sh!t, but more awkward to use. It's not much of a marketing tagline, is it?

Just to be clear, I have no problem with DSLRs being able to do video. I also have no problem with pros and enthusiasts maximising the results that can be obtained from such devices. What I do have a concern about (not a problem, just a concern) is whether the inclusion of video in a DSLR is something that "Joe Public" should give a stuff about. For many people, as an alternative to a camcorder, it simply won't deliver the goods as it will be too difficult to use well.
 
Yes.

It's just an idiotic "me too" feature.

IMHO it has no place on a DSLR,especially when so much could be done to improve still image quality.

I admit I'm rather luddite about this, but how this became a "must have" in 2009 is beyond me.

I utterly agree:thumbs:
 
I'll check the wild life sections.

I watched the Dublin video above - sorry not impressed - doesn't really tell a story - continuous panning and zooming - music (probably unlicenced) doesn't fit - no attempt to edit picture to music - picture quality was the last thing I noticed! Who cares if the quality is great if it's not worth watching.

Probably means a lot more at a personal level to the shooter - and that's great - and no more than I'm expecting from the vast majority of people who have video capability. Certainly for now.

Errr, I think you completely missed the point.

I wasn't posting it to ask for your crit on the video, I was showing you what a joe public can get out of shooting my video with that instead of a camcorder. The shots and the editing would have all been exactly the same had I used my camcorder except I wouldn't have been able to even get half the shots because of the low light.

I wasn't claiming that the storytelling, panning and zooming (of which there wasn't actually any zooming -since it was all shot with a 50mm prime) and music editing is better because I used a DSLR. I was using it as an example of how the shots couldn't even have been got with an HD camcorder and if they had of been they would be noisy as hell.

The video is some holiday footage - it's not a documentary, holy cow.
 
There is also the wobbly/shakey effect, focus sometimes being missed, verticals clearly not being vertical and some quite odd effects on faster pans and motion, including the bus passing through the frame. I only dipped in and out of the sound but I expect that if we had the opportunity to hear the ambient sound we might have heard handling noise from the camera and also the effects of autolevelling, plus the rather lacklustre and thin mono soundtrack.

All in all I thought the video supported my own views quite well. Whether a decent camcorder - something like this : http://www.panasonic.co.uk/html/en_...corders/HDC-TM300/Overview/1973727/index.html - would have improved results I honestly don't know, but if those are the results that "Joe Public" is destined to achieve with a video DSLR I don't think it will raise the bar as far as mass consumer video quality goes. In the hands of a video professional or enthusiast, that's another matter, but in the hands of "Joe Public"....... same ol' sh!t, but more awkward to use. It's not much of a marketing tagline, is it?

Just to be clear, I have no problem with DSLRs being able to do video. I also have no problem with pros and enthusiasts maximising the results that can be obtained from such devices. What I do have a concern about (not a problem, just a concern) is whether the inclusion of video in a DSLR is something that "Joe Public" should give a stuff about. For many people, as an alternative to a camcorder, it simply won't deliver the goods as it will be too difficult to use well.

You've missed the point as well. That camcorder you linked to is a similar model to what I used to have, I had the HS-300 which is almost identical to that. The video shot with it was nowhere near as good quality as that sample I put up.

It doesn't matter if my editing is crap, my handheld stuff is shaky - all of that would have been the same had I used my camcorder - but the quality of the video would have been worse and the shots would have either been impossible due to the low light or noisy as hell.

as for the audio, here's some footage with audio straight out of the camera and it's not mono at all. The audio is every bit as good as with my camcorder - i should know I've been the one using it.

Now when you look at this, don't talk about the storytelling, panning etc - you'll be missing the point again. The fact is the exact same footage shot with a camcorder by ME would have been worse. The editing, shot choices, and everything else would have been the same BUT the quality of the footage is nowhere near as good. Not to mention the point that if my dSLR didn't have video I'd have never ever captured a single frame because I wouldn't have carried my camcorder with me.

I have some footage of my daughter swimming I shot with an HD camcorder and my 7d that I can put up to show the difference in the exact same envrionment. I'll do so later

[YOUTUBE]<object width="560" height="340"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/tg5cy7rkyso&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/tg5cy7rkyso&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="560" height="340"></embed></object>[/YOUTUBE]
 
Joe, I don't think I did miss your point, and I was not meaning to be rude about your video either. Apart from the skills and talents required to make an interesting video there are, I think, some real fundamental basics that should not be ignored, no matter which sort of video device you use. One of the most important, I would think, is to keep the bloody camera steady. Waving a DSLR or camcorder out in front of your face is probably not the best way to achieve that. At least with a camcorder you can press the eyepiece up to your eye and hold your arms comfortably into your body to create a relatively stable platform - just the way you would shoot stills with a DSLR. Hopefully IS/OS will take care of the rest. With these video DSLRs, unless you are using a tripod or a proper shoulder mount or steadicam, you are forced by their design to wave the thing about in front of you. The results will not be good. If you use a shortish lens perhaps you can get away with it. If you use IS then maybe that will do enough, but there will be problems for the soundtrack with the whirring of the IS mechanism. So, you can either limit yourself to shooting short/wide, use a tripod, or start rigging up with the accessories I was talking about, in order to do the job properly. Then you still need to get that mic where it needs to be in order to pick up clear sound, so that's an external mic to be added to the kit list too.

The sensor IQ is all well and good, but if everyone feels seasick I don't see how it helps.
 
This member of the 'public' is interested in the video side because it means one less camera and better video quality. The video I'll be shooting is the same stuff that anyone with a camcorder will be doing - personal memories not major productions.

I'm reading up on what the people trying to make professional looking stuff are doing but have no intention of going that far.

Sound does seem to be as issue. Most of the 5D2 video is with a replaced sound track. My next step is to try a simple external mic to see if it reduces camera mechanical noises enough. All my previous camcorders have picked up internal mechanical noise - even the most recent with a hard drive instead of tape picks up switch and zoom sounds. Reducing it is all I'm looking for not perfection.

I'm comparing camcorder home video with DSLR home video nothing more. Once I get the sound sorted there is only one winner.
 
At least with a camcorder you can press the eyepiece up to your eye and hold your arms comfortably into your body to create a relatively stable platform - just the way you would shoot stills with a DSLR.

My camcorder and a lot of current models has no viewfinder. You flip out the screen from the side and look at that while shooting. hence my comparison to dslr shows no advantage to the camcorder on handling.
 
Joe, I don't think I did miss your point, and I was not meaning to be rude about your video either. Apart from the skills and talents required to make an interesting video there are, I think, some real fundamental basics that should not be ignored, no matter which sort of video device you use. One of the most important, I would think, is to keep the bloody camera steady. Waving a DSLR or camcorder out in front of your face is probably not the best way to achieve that. At least with a camcorder you can press the eyepiece up to your eye and hold your arms comfortably into your body to create a relatively stable platform - just the way you would shoot stills with a DSLR. Hopefully IS/OS will take care of the rest. With these video DSLRs, unless you are using a tripod or a proper shoulder mount or steadicam, you are forced by their design to wave the thing about in front of you. The results will not be good. If you use a shortish lens perhaps you can get away with it. If you use IS then maybe that will do enough, but there will be problems for the soundtrack with the whirring of the IS mechanism. So, you can either limit yourself to shooting short/wide, use a tripod, or start rigging up with the accessories I was talking about, in order to do the job properly. Then you still need to get that mic where it needs to be in order to pick up clear sound, so that's an external mic to be added to the kit list too.

The sensor IQ is all well and good, but if everyone feels seasick I don't see how it helps.

Don't worry about being rude or not, I don't take offense, it's all good.

I used a camcorder for 5 years and I never once looked through the viewfinder, nor does the "Joe public" you are referring to. The shakiness of any shot is exactly the same whether I were using a camcorder or a dSLR.

The point is if all the mistakes I or any other Joe public make are the same whether they use a camcorder or a dSLR then your point isn't valid, they are going to make those same mistakes no matter what tool they are using. BUT if the result is that the quality of video is better and you don't have to take more than 1 camera around meaning you are more likely to get memorable footage then it's a good thing!

also I get less camera noise from my dSLR than I did with my camcorder, camcorders are actually incredibly noisy things, if you are using IS on a lens for sure you'll here it but I don't have many lenses with IS so don't use it.
 
ok - I take your point Joe. There are some fantastic still pictures published on this forum - I'd love to see some fantastic video to justify it being available - indeed sought after by many people - in DSLRs. I guess I'll have to be patient! Enjoy your filming! :)
 
It is a still photography forum :)

Maybe we'll have a video sharing section one day.
 
ok - I take your point Joe. There are some fantastic still pictures published on this forum - I'd love to see some fantastic video to justify it being available - indeed sought after by many people - in DSLRs. I guess I'll have to be patient! Enjoy your filming! :)

If you were interested in seeing good video shot with a dslr, take a look at cinema5d forum. There are amazing videos shown on there, but those guys are mostly professionals, so the video isn't home video quality stuff like what I was putting up.
 
My camcorder and a lot of current models has no viewfinder. You flip out the screen from the side and look at that while shooting.

I used a camcorder for 5 years and I never once looked through the viewfinder, nor does the "Joe public" you are referring to. The shakiness of any shot is exactly the same whether I were using a camcorder or a dSLR.
Fair enough. I thought I was a "Joe Public" myself, but I guess that if the above is representative of the real "Joe Public" then I am not him after all.

I just thought that those using a DSLR for their photography would have slightly loftier aspirations for their video too. My mistake.
 
Thing is you aspire to quality when quality is possible. You don't have the motivation with the average camcorder as the quality is good enough for memories but not much else.
Video on the DSLR has given me some motivation to see what I can do. Stills is still my main interest but I'm going to give video a bit more effort now.
 
Fair enough. I thought I was a "Joe Public" myself, but I guess that if the above is representative of the real "Joe Public" then I am not him after all.

I just thought that those using a DSLR for their photography would have slightly loftier aspirations for their video too. My mistake.

I think there has been a massive change in who buy's dSLRs over the last 10 years. Everyone I know has a dSLR pretty much, mostly just own them with the kit lens and use the on camera flash. Reductions in price have meant that joe public owns a lot more dSLRs and they rarely do anything with them but point and shoot in auto mode, maybe a crop in iPhoto after taking it, but when I look at 100 friends on facebook I have maybe 3 that look like they do any form of PP or own extra lenses

It's the same with video, most people who own camcorders point and shoot and then watch their footage, rarely doing anything with it - maybe burn it to dvd.

Thats the majority of the consumers. I would consider myself at the top end of one of these consumers because I do own extra accessories and edit my video. But I still pretty much film just everyday events and life and the stuff I make is just for my own and my family's consumption. All those people who are now buying dSLRs and camcorders have the option of buying just one for what works out at less than owning 2 - great, it's a huge appeal. All the mistakes they might make are going to be the same and their footage is going to be at least as good, mostly better once they get the hang of manual focus. SO if thats the case then it makes sense to have the one device for cost and convenience.

The big thing is that going back to the original post, joe public doesn't buy photography magazines and vote in them so the results of that poll are mostly from still photography fanatics and as a result the 28% vote has got to be expected
 
Well I suppose that is where I am puzzled. Is "Joe Public", with his entry level DSLR, going to be wanting to faff about with manual focus and manual zooming only, or a DOF shallow enough to potentially cause problems, or intrusive handling noises that would be comparatively subdued on a decent camcorder with solid state media? What about when using a longer lens, such as a 55-250 or something like that? With a camcorder and its 10X, 12X or 20X optical zoom, the handling is still not a huge problem, but with a DSLR and equivalent lens I can imagine it being a ruddy huge problem - for Joe Public.

Hopefully I'm just being thick and can't see the logic, but I still think most people would be served far better by a nice camcorder than battling with the challenges presented by a video DSLR. You could hand a camcorder to Aunty Maud and say "Can you video us please?", but can you imagine handing over a DSLR and expecting usable results? How about videoing the kids playing football - fairly easy with a camcorder, I should imagine, but would that really be doable, easily, with a hand held DSLR and 70-300 zoom?

p.s. at least camcorders are designed with handholding at a distance in mind, plus they are quite light and easily held too. To do the same thing with a DSLR and largeish lens, which needs focusing manually, does not seem such a good strategy. At the end of the day, what is the point in worrying about sensor IQ if you can't hold the camera steady or keep your subject in focus, in frame and vertical?
 
It's definitely easier to film with the handheld camcorder but for every thing you say as a negative I can come back with a positive. What about when Joe public wants to film and take photos, he doesn't have to carry two and that will be an appeal, what about when Joe public is fed up with looking at crappy noisy HD footage that doesn't even look HD when viewed on his 50 inch plasma.

If he's filming a football match Joe public is going to be using an aperture with a high f number like f/13 because he won't own any ND filters and he'll be filming in daylight and so focussing will be a lot less of a problem.

Don't get me wrong, dSLRs with video aren't going to replace camcorders, not even close and for the majority the points you mention are going to be true.

But there is enough of an audience of joe publics like me who want more from their video and all the conviences and quality it brings when getting than video out of the dSLR instead. For this reason there is a big market for video in a dSLR
 
, but I still think most people would be served far better by a nice camcorder than battling with the challenges presented by a video DSLR.

Can't argue with that. However when I'm somewhere with a camera it is the DSLR. Even if the camcorder is in the camera bag it rarely comes out. Having a secondary function to my main camera means I will actually shoot some video - and more so because the picture quality will be so superior.
 
The single biggest issue for me is that people are realising how important good sound is with video. And that's not easy to do well.
 
The single biggest issue for me is that people are realising how important good sound is with video. And that's not easy to do well.

but like I said before, the sound quality from the internal mic on my 7d is just as good as from the mic on my HS300 so this realisation comes with both mediums.

I have an external rode mic which I could attach to both my camcorder and 7d. How many times have I used it on either? probably less than the number of fingers I have because I can't be bothered with carrying it. The sound quality is good enough as it is for my home video needs and that will be the same for the majority
 
Ok so here is the swimming example I talked about. The first 40 seconds are shot with my old HS300 panasonic which is considered one of the best consumer HD camcorders on the market and weighs in at around £800. After that it is shot with my 7d and a 70-300mm lens.

Any errors in the actual filming are present throughout both samples, the focus on the 7d is harder to nail first time so I've left parts in where I was searching for focus to make a fair comparison.

To me the 7d footage is hugely better than the HS300 camcorder footage. Even after I have re-rendered it a few times so you aren't really getting the full HD quality out of the video.

The other big thing was the first time I went with my camcorder I only got video. The 2nd time I went with my 7d I got pics and video - so not only is the video at least as good (better in my opinion) but I got photos of the event as well.

I wasn't going for huge DOF in this footage, just capturing a personal moment of my daughter swimming. The end result was that on my 2nd trip I was able to get much better quality footage and also capture photographs as well.

[YOUTUBE]<object width="560" height="340"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/hcWtxyiJ7xE&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/hcWtxyiJ7xE&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="560" height="340"></embed></object>[/YOUTUBE]
 
Good demo. The first part does look very rough (IQ) compared to the later portion.
 
yeah and the hs300 is supposed to be good in poor lighting, it really isn't I've never seen a consumer HD camera produce HD quality footage in anything other than perfect lighting, at least none that I have owned or tried, and it was always something that really disappointed me because you rarely do have perfect lighting unless you are always filming outside on sunny days. I filmed a lot indoors and found the IQ to be very poor.
 
Taking into account the price rises due to the poor exchange rate, have prices been significantly higher than pre-video models at release? :shrug:

if cameras follow the trend of usa marketed musical instruments...especially guitars..especially basses

we get ripped off all the time..R.O.B.!!

we are a poor country...no wonder:|
 
Like many of you - when I chose to upgrade my D80 to the 300s the video function was not one of the selling points that made me buy it.

But - I take a lot of photographs of a local band, so one night thought I would try and video one of their songs.

The picture quality was fine, but the audio was about 7/10. It is one of the bands quieter songs and I used a stereo mic set up I had from my bootlegging days (using a mini disc recorder).

I uploaded the link on Youtube here

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bgivn5N6-kE

So you can see for yourself. Now even though the band are happy with my stills for their website etc....the fans like the video!! So I have just sent off for a better quality mic to use in future. I will let you know how I get on!!

Finally, apart from the above - I also found it great to video my Granddaughter at Christmas!!
 
Back
Top