manual focus, how on earth do you nail it?

Ah the machine gun method, not learn how to take photos but take 1000's and you bound to get some good ones

lol coming from somone who has an 8fps and a 6.3fps camera! ;)
 
Ah the machine gun method, not learn how to take photos but take 1000's and you bound to get some good ones

"Machine gunning" is a very common safety net technique, it's nothing to be ashamed of and certainly nothing to be looked down upon! Paps have done it for years and years, and wedding togs use it loads.....it should be purely about the end result, not they way you got the end result!!
 
Machine gunning can also save you from camera shake when you absolutely have to shoot at slower shutter speeds, shoot enough frames and you're bound to nail a shot where the shake just changes direction and seems to not be shaking :)
 
Have you tried the Eg-s focussing screen yet Joe? I use one with the 5DII / 50 f1.4 and 135L f2.

I use glasses for reading and distance, so my eyesight is far from perfect. I've found that dioptre adjustment is crucial. The method I use for dioptre adjustment is:

Point the camera at a bright plain subject, the sky would do, but make it out of focus.
Looking at the circle through the viewfinder, turn the dioptre wheel one way until it just goes out of focus. Turn the dioptre wheel the other way until the circle goes out of focus by roughly the same amount. Count the clicks then go back half the amount and I'm in the middle. I use the circle because it is thinner than the focus points and I find it easier to tell when its out of focus.

With the 5DII and Eg-s screen I get 4-5 clicks. With my 40D I get 6-8 clicks.

My manual focus technique is similar with static subjects. Basically I get the subject to go out of focus front and back then put the focus ring in the middle and pray I don't rock back & forth too much when taking the shot.

My hit rate has improved with practice, to the point where I'm confident of nailing the focus most of the time.

Portraits with shallow DOF are a different kettle of fish though. Not only can the photographer move, but the subject can too. Asking them to try and stay still invariably puts to much pressure on them and it shows in their expression. So I tend to burst shoot and move back and forth myself hoping that I can nail at least one focus.
 
Best method I've found for MF is practising using the green dot (Nikon, not sure about Canon?) I've found that playing around by finding where its "sweet spot" is for a particular lens so sometimes it's focusing backwards until the green light appears, sometimes its focusing forwards until it appears. Even found that getting it to appear and then slightly backing off can do it.

Hope that makes sense, basically play around with the green light

I take the point about AF but I've got a couple of manual lens that I like, particularly the Samyang 85mm so I've had to just practice on it until I can get it somewhere near - tis frustrating at times though

Not thought of the burst shooting, shall give that a go
 
Last edited:
Ah the machine gun method, not learn how to take photos but take 1000's and you bound to get some good ones

This is a favourite technique of Joe McNally, are you saying neither he nor I have learnt how to take pictures?

Also if you read what we said, nowhere does it say 1000's of shots - the technique involves taking only a few shots at a time.
 
Joe, why are you persisting with this? Just use AF.

Manual focusing any SLR or DSLR is difficult. Always has been, even when the focusing screen is designed for it, with suitable aids, you have a low f/number lens (which you do) and a decent focusing mech in the lens designed for manual operation. There's no great secret to it - it's just hard, and even then there's a fair amount of guesswork in it, and luck.

And after all that, modern AF beats the pants off anything you can do manually - ten times faster and much more accurate. Always. That's why it was invented, and why everybody uses it.

The only time I ever use manual focus is with macro, and that's a whole different thing. Give yourself a break bud ;)

lol,

Well the only reason I was wanting to know so much was that I was in a situation where I was taking this shot

IMG_0292.jpg


and all the blades of grass were fooling the camera so I had to use manual, but I could only do it in live view at x10 and this was the only shot I got duee to the laborious nature of it - so I wondered how looking through the viewfinder of a normal dslr people would be able to see that eye in focus - to me it looked in focus in the viewfinder but of course as my tests illustrate it actually wasn't - now i know why due to the increased dof in the viewfinder
 
Awww - that's a lovely shot! :thumbs: I can see the difficulties, though. Burst mode might be the best way here, or would it scare the beastie?
 
In that shot, use your centre af point and aim for the high contrast areas of its face (eyes) and auto focus, should nail it pretty accurately.. cameras tend to favour high contrast areas more than the sea of green.

Would I have missed the focus using that method? Probably. But I would still try it :)
 
Manually turning the focus ring till the camera bleeps to tell you the selected af point/sensor is in focus is NOT manually focusing.
It's autofocusing but doing the work of the af motor with your wrist.
Same goes for manually operating the focus ring while watching the electronic rangefinder in the viewfinder, you're still relying on the camera's judgement.

As for the machine gunners, that might be the way you like to perform your photography but I'd rather fill my cf card with considered, well focused good shots than a barrage of slapdash out of focus images.
 
As for the machine gunners, that might be the way you like to perform your photography but I'd rather fill my cf card with considered, well focused good shots than a barrage of slapdash out of focus images.

So, do you ever bracket exposures? Taking 3 or 4 shots around the focus point is just as valid.
 
For that shot, back button focus, acquire the subject ,thumb off and shoot.
 
So, do you ever bracket exposures? Taking 3 or 4 shots around the focus point is just as valid.

Unless I want to go down the HDR route (which I sometimes use for b&w images, not oversaturated colour images) I very rarely bracket and when I do, I'd say that about 85-95% of the time I end up using the standard metered shot.
With camera raw and the ability to go at least a stop in either direction with negligible effect to image quality there's absolutely no need to be filling my cards with over and under exposed images.
For proper landscape photography bracketing is perhaps more justifiable but that kind of photography is usually a slow, contemplative, considered affair far removed from the 'blast away and hope for the best' machine gun approach. Find me a landscape photographer that ever bought a camera for the fps it could do.
It's a question of subject I suppose for me. Given a moving subject I wouldn't use the machine gun approach (bracketing or not) because even at the 11fps my camera could shoot at I wouldn't want to leave getting perfect composition, timing etc down to pot luck and given a static subject, I'd just take my time and get it right the first time rather than fill up my cards with pointless throwaway poorly focused images.
 
Change the screen for a microprism or split image version.
 
yeah for everyone offering the advice about using autofocus for that shot. the autofocus just wasn't cutting it, the grass was always getting in the way, it was moving around a lot, as was the animal. Manual focus was my only option.

and I already do back button focus
 
Forget it.
 
Last edited:

Try listening and reading instead of shouting your mouth off. You have a top end camera and can`t even focus the goddammed thing.

Either the camera is substandard, which I doubt, or you are,which is more than likely.
 
Try listening and reading instead of shouting your mouth off. You have a top end camera and can`t even focus the goddammed thing.

Either the camera is substandard, which I doubt, or you are,which is more than likely.

:lol: .... :thumbs:
 
Last edited:
*comes in*

*awkward silence*

*goes out again*
 
Try listening and reading instead of shouting your mouth off. You have a top end camera and can`t even focus the goddammed thing.

Either the camera is substandard, which I doubt, or you are,which is more than likely.

i was going to respond to this and then i remembered i'm a better man than that. :thumbs:
 
not sure why the testosterone got decanted, but can we please try and remain civil?

machine gunning..im guilty of that sometimes, 3 or 4 shots at a time on things doing stuff, not point in spending ages teeing it all up and then miss the action. It has its place.
 
Unless I want to go down the HDR route (which I sometimes use for b&w images, not oversaturated colour images) I very rarely bracket and when I do, I'd say that about 85-95% of the time I end up using the standard metered shot.
With camera raw and the ability to go at least a stop in either direction with negligible effect to image quality there's absolutely no need to be filling my cards with over and under exposed images.
For proper landscape photography bracketing is perhaps more justifiable but that kind of photography is usually a slow, contemplative, considered affair far removed from the 'blast away and hope for the best' machine gun approach. Find me a landscape photographer that ever bought a camera for the fps it could do.
It's a question of subject I suppose for me. Given a moving subject I wouldn't use the machine gun approach (bracketing or not) because even at the 11fps my camera could shoot at I wouldn't want to leave getting perfect composition, timing etc down to pot luck and given a static subject, I'd just take my time and get it right the first time rather than fill up my cards with pointless throwaway poorly focused images.

Damn, said I wouldn't get drawn in again.

But in the subject quoted, animal in moving grass, grass fooling AF, unable to get a definitive focus with a wide open lens, you've a couple of options only really to ensure you get the shot. Increase the depth of field or bracket the focus.

Each to their own technique, but I'd be trying both of those to ensure I got the shot.
 
I really don't know sometimes why I even bother offering any advice on this forum. :shrug:

I offer a genuine proven method, basically focus bracketing, and am promptly told I don't know how to take photographs, I can only machine gun. :bang:

Can I just explain - focus bracketing, done either in one shot or multi shot mode, only involves taking three or four shots at a time. The idea is if you're manual focusing and trying to focus on a very small object in the viewfinder, it's near impossible to be able to see it clearly enough and so a few extra shots taken with very slight movements of the focusing ring should be enough to ensure at least one of those shots is focused as you wanted.

I know it's the nature of the internet sometimes, but why on earth do people have to resort to thinly veiled insults in threads like this? Someone asks a simple enough question, people offer their advice and then you get two dozen more people arguing and insulting each other. It's bizzare, useless and downright pathetic.:thumbsdown:
 
I know it's the nature of the internet sometimes, but why on earth do people have to resort to thinly veiled insults in threads like this? Someone asks a simple enough question, people offer their advice and then you get two dozen more people arguing and insulting each other. It's bizzare, useless and downright pathetic.:thumbsdown:

:clap:
 
I know it's the nature of the internet sometimes, but why on earth do people have to resort to thinly veiled insults in threads like this? Someone asks a simple enough question, people offer their advice and then you get two dozen more people arguing and insulting each other. It's bizzare, useless and downright pathetic.:thumbsdown:

I know exactly what you mean Ste, theres been three people in this thread that are basically so far up their own arses you can't see their neck.

Anyone who reverts to personal insults lacks inteliigence in my opinion. I appreciate your advice and I WILL be trying the focus bracketing method in the future so thanks for letting me know about it, as for the others -meh, just ignore them :thumbs:
 
Last edited:
I know exactly what you mean Ste, theres been three people in this thread that are basically so far up their own arses you can't see their neck.

Anyone who reverts to personal insults lacks inteliigence in my opinion. I appreciate your advice and I WILL be trying the machine gun method in the future so thanks for letting me know about it, as for the others -meh, just ignore them :thumbs:

Don't fuel their arguments! It's not the machine gun method we are talking about :lol:

I'm quite happy for debate on opinions and advice given, but it's the way some people come on here and chose to word their views that gets me wound up. If I read some comment on here that was clearly wrong, I wouldn't feel the need to correct the poster in an insulting and frankly childish manner, I might say 'no, you're wrong because...' and state my own case but only if I was absolutely sure and had some evidence to back my opinion up, and I certainly wouldn't do it in a condesending patronising and insulting way.
 
Don't fuel their arguments! It's not the machine gun method we are talking about :lol:

I'm quite happy for debate on opinions and advice given, but it's the way some people come on here and chose to word their views that gets me wound up. If I read some comment on here that was clearly wrong, I wouldn't feel the need to correct the poster in an insulting and frankly childish manner, I might say 'no, you're wrong because...' and state my own case but only if I was absolutely sure and had some evidence to back my opinion up, and I certainly wouldn't do it in a condesending patronising and insulting way.

lol, oops my bad. I corrected my post! typed it too quickly!
 
theres been three people in this thread that are basically so far up their own arses you can't see their neck.


Anyone who reverts to personal insults lacks inteliigence in my opinion.

:shrug:

I made a suggestion which you ignored but then there was so much ping-pong going on it was probably engulfed! lol
 
lol, nah I know but what I was meaning is that your two comments as quoted meant you were calling yourself silly ;) Was just being light hearted tongue and cheek. :)

Not important to be honest and back on topic did you ever try the newspaper (or similar) test? It's a great way to show pretty much were the problem may lie.

Cheers
G
 
Bromide tea anyone? :suspect:

Now then fellas - I understand that everyone has an opinion, a way of doing things, etc etc, none are necessarily wrong and most are very valid, tried and tested methods to get the end result that you need. So, this thread has one more chance to get back to the topic in hand in a civil and polite manner, or it gets filed under 'C'
 
Not important to be honest and back on topic did you ever try the newspaper (or similar) test? It's a great way to show pretty much were the problem may lie.

Cheers
G

I didn't try the newspapare test. Instead when I read the article posted that the viewfinder has a much larger dof than the sensor and the final image it all made sense. Thats why the image looked in focus in the viewfinder both when it actually was in focus and when it was just out.

This makes sense to me and so I now know the limits of doing manual focus with a standard viewfinder without some of the special prism additions others have talked about.
 
I didn't mean to attack or insult anyone (presuming it was my comments that caused offence), I just don't consider machine gunning a very good technique and the way I read some of the comments it seemed that they were suggesting a blast away and hope for the best approach should be taken at all times.
I can however appreciate that it has it's place and in the shot with the grass it would have been hard to see the focus in the viewfinder to manually focus and the subject would have been fooling the af system so a best attempt plus some focus bracketing would have been the best route to go.
I still stand by my opinion that manually turning the focus ring till the camera tells you the selected af point is in focus is not manual focusing though.
 
I still stand by my opinion that manually turning the focus ring till the camera tells you the selected af point is in focus is not manual focusing though.

My very first SLR - a NIKON F - only had manual focussing - there was no alternative - but you could tell when the image was in focus from the screen - i.e. the camera told you - it was manual focus!!
 
Bromide tea anyone? :suspect:

Now then fellas - I understand that everyone has an opinion, a way of doing things, etc etc, none are necessarily wrong and most are very valid, tried and tested methods to get the end result that you need. So, this thread has one more chance to get back to the topic in hand in a civil and polite manner, or it gets filed under 'C'

I was hoping we could have an open, frank discussion as I find that it helps me as a learning process.
Instead, I've backed away from this thread and for the first time gone looking for the ignore function. It's a shame that a forum that promotes itself as friendly sometimes has moments like this.
 
Back
Top