Painting my photo to sell - allowed?

Or I could say the fee be in damages and the contract prohibit further use?

There is no way I will license this image out. Anyway - I have an agency and they have always said they can get involved with things if needed.

There's your solution in one.

Decide whether you want a one off fee and a declaration of desist from the artist, or a fee and a follow on percentage, and if he fails to agree to those terms hand it over to the agency who will pursue the matter (as long as it's making them money of course). It certainly wouldn't harm your position if you informed the guy of your intentions when you present him with the chosen option.
 
fixedimage said:
I'd definitely get your agency involved.
They will likely have an entire department of people who know this type of law inside out and they will have the time/money to take it to court on your behalf.

Problem is I'd have to license the image to the agency too. I guess I could do this, but would rather keep this particular one to just myself.
 
it sounds fine, but i would let the agency look at it anyway, to be honest

i think fixed image is trying to say everyone in an issue like this sees it as identical, whereas im assuming there is no bias and just talking business and law
 
It can be as obvious as you like but I'd imagine that until you have a way to legally prove the painting is a copy of your image and not just a painting of a scene that bears an uncanny likeness then there will be lawyers out there who would be happy to take a young adult like yourself to court and tear you to shreds.

Would you care to explain how the artist would be able to take Will to court under English law?
 
Would you care to explain how the artist would be able to take Will to court under English law?

Not a clue.
I'm not a lawyer.
I'd imagine though that it could well be as simple as the painter saying "I painted this image before your photograph was taken and I put it to you (Will) that you have photographed a stuffed squirrel which you have placed in a location that you have engineered to look exactly like my painting."
The painter and his lawyer could know that was complete BS, Will could know it was complete BS, the judge could know it was complete BS but in a court of law it'd come down to proof.
 
Not a clue.
I'm not a lawyer.
I'd imagine though that it could well be as simple as the painter saying "I painted this image before your photograph was taken and I put it to you (Will) that you have photographed a stuffed squirrel which you have placed in a location that you have engineered to look exactly like my painting."
The painter and his lawyer could know that was complete BS, Will could know it was complete BS, the judge could know it was complete BS but in a court of law it'd come down to proof.

I think that you've missed the rather salient point in all that guff; Will is sixteen.
 
the onus for proof is on the prosecutor, actually

so no

plus, there would be lighting, and the fact hed have to prove the date of his own painting, whereas will won an award with it, so thats presumably documented

//edit

said actually twice *face palm* my bad
 
Last edited:
I think that you've missed the rather salient point in all that guff; Will is sixteen.

Not sure I see your "salient point".
Over the age of majority? Yes.
Has already stated he can sign contracts himself? Yes.
Something about being sixteen that makes it impossible for you to obtain stuffed squirrels? Not really sure there is.
 
Yes the image won 2009 Young British Wildlife Photographer of the Year and was shortlisted when I was 14 in photography monthly's Nikon UK top 50 photographers. So it has several documented occurrences.

fixedimage said:
Something about being sixteen that makes it impossible for you to obtain stuffed squirrels? Not really sure there is.

That made me laugh a lot!
 
Not sure I see your "salient point".
Over the age of majority? Yes.
Has already stated he can sign contracts himself? Yes.
Something about being sixteen that makes it impossible for you to obtain stuffed squirrels? Not really sure there is.

The legal age of responsibility is 18 not 16.
 
yeah, it got changed quite a while ago

though the legal process often protects those that are younger, but you can be arrested/sentanced at much younger than sixteen - doesent mean you -will- be
 
fixedimage said:
Really? Wikipedia and www.inbrief.co.uk are under the impression that in England and Wales the age of criminal responsibility is 10.
According to both those sources up until 2010 it was 8 in scotland but that has now been raised to 12.

Unfortunately the majority of google says 18.

HOWEVER - if I sign along with a parent, then it is enforced and is valid - is this the case?
 
you have to get a guardians signature because you dont neccecerily count as having full powers of consent, but its more relaxed than when your under sixteen - cant help you with the specifics on that one though
 
Ershin said:
you have to get a guardians signature because you dont neccecerily count as having full powers of consent, but its more relaxed than when your under sixteen - cant help you with the specifics on that one though

Well that is fine and completely possible as both parents are fully behind it.

Funny, my agency signed a contract with me knowing I was 16, but hey ho.
 
Really? Wikipedia and www.inbrief.co.uk are under the impression that in England and Wales the age of criminal responsibility is 10.
According to both those sources up until 2010 it was 8 in scotland but that has now been raised to 12.

Yes really; go and look it up on a decent website if you have to. The age of criminal responsibility had absolutely nothing to do with the age of legal responsibility.

I'll give you a hint:

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/
 
yeah, it got changed quite a while ago

though the legal process often protects those that are younger, but you can be arrested/sentanced at much younger than sixteen - doesent mean you -will- be

No it didn't. The Family Reform Act 1969 is still extant.
 
i was under the impression that civil suits ended up on the parents shoulders if the minor was only criminally responsible
 
Yes really; go and look it up on a decent website if you have to. The age of criminal responsibility had absolutely nothing to do with the age of legal responsibility.

I'll give you a hint:

http://www.legislation.gov.uk/

TLDR.
I'll take your word for it.
Copyright theft is a crime though so I'd have thought age of criminal responsibilty had everything to do with it.
 
No it didn't. The Family Reform Act 1969 is still extant.

im starting to get quite out of my area of knowledge here, so il defer

i have to admit i hadent realised that the legal age was seperated between criminal and legal liability, just that with certain things you had a hell of a lot of slack
 
TLDR.
I'll take your word for it.
Copyright theft is a crime though so I'd have thought age of criminal responsibilty had everything to do with it.

Copyright infringement is a civil offence and not a criminal one, unless it's committed under very very specific circumstances, usually at a corporate level.

There's no such thing as copyright theft.
 
Copyright infringement is a civil offence and not a criminal one, unless it's committed under very very specific circumstances, usually at a corporate level.

There's no such thing as copyright theft.

^ /agree
 
Fair enough.
So had Will, at age 14, decided to photograph a stuffed squirrel - that he had asked an older boy (older than 16) to get for him - so that it looked like this painting, he would not be responsible as it was a civil offence.
Would that mean that no offence had been committed or just that 14 year old Will wasn't responsible? Would responsibility pass to parents etc?
 
Hardly the point though is it?

The guy is trying to ask a serious question and getting an awful lot of duff info.
 
oh to surmise then everything previous to the counter sue discussion is as it was, but you have potentially an added layer of security

oh, and fixedimage, im guessing you arent from the uk, being as you specified uk in your online searching and reporting on that

im gonna go ahead and guess the states, as way as liability ages being different, copywrite law itself here is a different kettle of fish as well
 
oh, mark, i had a quick look at your site, you have an image there of some sort of park with reptillian statues in - out of curiosity, where is that? looks like an awesome place
 
unfortunatly im in the west midlands, but il try and keep it mentally bookmarked for when im around

thank you for sharing :)
 
Will, you are in a very strong position. From what you have said, your photo has been copied and so much is obvious to anyone. The painting could not have been created without reference to your image. If you took it to court, they would have no alternative but to find in your favour and award costs. It would cost you nothing; it would cost him a lot just to lose.

At the very least, a court would order all copies to be withdrawn from sale and destroyed, whatever else they might award in terms of compensation is another matter, especially as you appear to have lost nothing and it would be hard to prove any future loss. However, courts take a pretty dim view of of blatant flouting of the law by someone who clearly ought to know better and are duty bound to ensure that the law breakers do not benefit and are indeed punished, albeit sometimes modestly.

Cut and dried cases like this very rarely go to court and are settled outside through solicitors. It saves money and hassle for everyone as the outcome is already a foregone conclusion. What you should go for depends entirely on what you're likely to get, which will in turn depend on what the artist has done with his painting/s. If it's just a one-off in a local gallery for a few quid, then that's one thing. But is he has had a limited edition of a hundred screen prints made or something, ready framed for sale through a wildlife magazine ad, then that's entirely another. He will not want to lose that, so do your research as best you can to establish your bargaining position.

Being realistic, it's not a big deal and something of a compliment. At the end of the day, if you get a signed copy of an original painting plus a small sum for your troubles, and he agrees not to do it again, that might not be a bad result.

Edit: or you could go for a share of future sales, like they did in this case http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-12720159
 
Last edited:
Sorry I don't have anything useful to say other than I hope you get the issue resolved to your satisfaction, but.....

Fair enough.
So had Will, at age 14, decided to photograph a stuffed squirrel - that he had asked an older boy (older than 16) to get for him - so that it looked like this painting, he would not be responsible as it was a civil offence.
Would that mean that no offence had been committed or just that 14 year old Will wasn't responsible? Would responsibility pass to parents etc?

:cuckoo:
 
Will, you are in a very strong position. From what you have said, your photo has been copied and so much is obvious to anyone. The painting could not have been created without reference to your image. If you took it to court, they would have no alternative but to find in your favour and award costs. It would cost you nothing; it would cost him a lot just to lose.

At the very least, a court would order all copies to be withdrawn from sale and destroyed, whatever else they might award in terms of compensation is another matter, especially as you appear to have lost nothing and it would be hard to prove any future loss. However, courts take a pretty dim view of of blatant flouting of the law by someone who clearly ought to know better and are duty bound to ensure that the law breakers do not benefit and are indeed punished, albeit sometimes modestly.

Cut and dried cases like this very rarely go to court and are settled outside through solicitors. It saves money and hassle for everyone as the outcome is already a foregone conclusion. What you should go for depends entirely on what you're likely to get, which will in turn depend on what the artist has done with his painting/s. If it's just a one-off in a local gallery for a few quid, then that's one thing. But is he has had a limited edition of a hundred screen prints made or something, ready framed for sale through a wildlife magazine ad, then that's entirely another. He will not want to lose that, so do your research as best you can to establish your bargaining position.

Being realistic, it's not a big deal and something of a compliment. At the end of the day, if you get a signed copy of an original painting plus a small sum for your troubles, and he agrees not to do it again, that might not be a bad result.

Edit: or you could go for a share of future sales, like they did in this case http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-12720159

hes already explicitly stated he doesent want to liscense the image
 
Will
I don't know about any of the legal stuff, but I had a look at your website and you have some cracking wildlife shots there. Don't suppose the squirrel in question has an intriguing look to it has it?

If its the one I'm thinking it is, then I too would be rather upset, its a great capture.

Oh, and well done for all your stuff, at 16 you are doing fine, keep up the good work.
 
It is indeed a very distinctive photograph which has been well captured (I love the ears :cool:) I'd like to ask the OP if this is just sour grapes because the painting is making money, I ask because it seems like a half hearted attitude given that you don't want to license the image and possibly make money from it?

I hope you sort things out.
 
Good luck! There was a thread a while ago with a member who had the same issue with a shot of waves breaking over the sea....can't seem to find it though.
 
Back
Top