- Messages
- 1,441
- Edit My Images
- Yes
Shame about the brown pine needle. I like the way the beastie is in align with the branch. Not sure it shouts grace at me, but I wish my "grab shots" would come out half as good !
) look pretty graceful to me when they're flying, in fact that was one of the ideas I thought about. Really good detail in there Sarah, not easy with the kit lens, as even at minimum focus you're still a fair way off. The brown needle, isn't a problem for me.
. There's something bugging me (see what I did there
It really doesn't say grace to me but it is an excellent shot. Sharp subject with OOF background. The brown pine needle doesn't bother me either. I was amazed that this was taken with the kit lens. I thought you'd gone out and bought a macro lens.
OK you all caught me out this week.Shame about the brown pine needle. I like the way the beastie is in align with the branch. Not sure it shouts grace at me, but I wish my "grab shots" would come out half as good !
Sarah, it doesn't shout grace to me but with a gentle explanation it works.
You have certainly got a lot out of the kit lens, I like the colour tones in your image. Its a sharp, strong compositional image capturing the detail in the insect.
We (2010 52'ers) are certainly becoming more critical as the weeks go on. I definitely find myself looking more in depth at others and my own images. It was your comment about the brown pine needle in the image that reminded me of this. My view is that it doesn't affect my thoughts on your image, I just took it as thats nature, in it's different colours. How funny that we look at these things differently and with differing critique.
Thats a bit of a ramble sorry, all IMHO of course, feel free to disregard. Iain
Thats a big crowbar your using this week Sarah....haha.
That aside its a nice image and you seem to be getting some cracking quality from the kit lens. Not really into this sort of image myself but they are nicely composed and probably required much more patience than I have.
With a bit of jiggerypokey I reckong you could replace that brown spike with a green one copied from elsewhere.
Dan
Not 100% sure it says Grace but its still a good shot.
Its a really sharp shot and great colours especially considering you were using the kit lens.
The re-crop of the bee is much better
The hover fly doesn't particularly say grace to me but it is a very good capture. The composition and DOF is excellent, and you have done really well to catch it where it shows up so well against the dark background. I really don't think you need worry about the brown needle tip as it fits in well with the overall colour scheme. The OOF brown needles in the background add a lot of interest, I feel - all green would be rather boring by comparison.

I think the fly is gracefully perched on the branch! Lovely shot - nice detail and you avoided the usual mistake of an accurate macro shot with dull composition!
Phil
I'm also gonna say it's not really saying Grace in loud shouts... but Hoverflies and in fact, most flying things (with the possible exception of bees) look pretty graceful to me when they're flying, in fact that was one of the ideas I thought about. Really good detail in there Sarah, not easy with the kit lens, as even at minimum focus you're still a fair way off. The brown needle, isn't a problem for me.
Nice shot Sarah, i think it looks much better on black. considering it was windy you have managed to get it pretty sharp. The composition is neat too, i like the way it looks slick ans streamlined against the branch.
Hi Sarah, just looked through your thread for the 1st time, you have got superb images there, very well done.![]()
nice "grab" shot, the pine needle doesn`t worry me to much its all part of nature,
maybe loose the green in the background to just a plain black?
Ian
'Relaxation' is a nice shot, but come on, you know it doesn't fit the theme![]()
. There's something bugging me (see what I did there
) about the processing too, maybe a little over-sharpened?
I love grace though, the hoverfly looks very elegantly poised on the end, super shot and very fitting
Chris

Hi Sarah, I prefer the latest crop for relaxation. Really nice.
The grace shot does not say grace to me at all but as a shot, I like it. The little fly is really sharp and you have the DOF spot on.
Jenny
Catch-up time for me Sarah.
The new crop works better for relaxation although the flower is too close to the top of the frame. I guess you can't really do much about that. Overall a good shot of a difficult subject and one I haven't come anywhere close to getting.
Grace - At least we know who has the crowbar this weekIt really doesn't say grace to me but it is an excellent shot. Sharp subject with OOF background. The brown pine needle doesn't bother me either. I was amazed that this was taken with the kit lens. I thought you'd gone out and bought a macro lens.
Andy

The noise is perfectly acceptable, imho, and getting anything when life is so manic is a bonus. A big 
Ooo - lots for me to catch up on, here, Sarah.
Week 28 Relaxation (Post #28)
You self-crit says everything I would say, too, and I can hear your frustration that there were elements you couldn't control or change. I guess this is part of the fascination of photography and what keeps us coming back for more and more of the same or similar subjects until you get something you're happy with.
Relaxation (under Week 29 Grace): The composition works well - although it's still a ittle tight at the top - and the detail is excellent. I'm quite sure I couldn't get anything near as good as this with a kit lens!
Week 29 Grace: I like this. I like the way the angle of the hoverfly's thorax is parallel with the pine twig and this is echoed in the background twig. The manky pine needle doesn't bother me at all. I often use
Hacker's brilliant tutorial on eyes (Make those eyes pop) - it works just as well on insects!![]()
http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=43265
Week 30 Reshoot/Relaxation: There's a definite sense of progress in these shots, Sarah - well done. I like the bokeh in this one and the composition works well. You could always paint a few yellow stripes on the bee!!! The noise is perfectly acceptable, imho, and getting anything when life is so manic is a bonus. A bigfrom me! I hope next week is less mental for both of us!
Jean
Thanks for putting all your previous shots at the beginning of this thread so I could catch up quickly. Simply amazing what your imagination is capable of and the quality you're achieving with "just the kit lens" is quite unbelievable at times.
Sarah, as Jean said above, there's a definite sense of progression in your reshoot image so that's got to be a good thing. Life has a way of getting in the way of photography doesn't it? Well done for submitting an image to keep you up to date
. I hope things quieten down for you this week. Iain
Sarah, Once again your pictures never cease to amaze me and it is all done with the minimal amount of effort. I seem to have to put so much in and get so little out :bang:
Love them and Thank you for sharing them with us.![]()
Very well done Sarah, considering you're just using the kit lens, that's good and close. Good sharp detail on the Bee too.![]()
That's definitely a better re shoot the composition is strong. Not bad for a standard kit lens too. I quite like the noise in the bokeh, it gives it a pleasing texture. I have to laugh at your self critique and the antenna, you are just going to have to learn how to become a be whisperer and ask them to pose properly![]()




And it's very satisfaying when you find a new way of using PS. 




Well done on catching up, Sarah. If you're working full-time I really don't know how you fit everything in - and come up with great images week after week.
I've been doing something like 50 hour weeks for the last couple of monthsI'm also trustee for a charity and the AGM was last week - trying to review accounts for them has been digging into my free time too. So yes, finding time for photography has been a real struggle lately. I'm glad that you haven't noticed a massive decline in my shots, even if I haven't been entirely happy with them
Endings: It fits the theme and I had to laugh at your comment about dead insects being easier than living ones.
As an image, though, I can't quite make up my mind. There's something amiss, (for me!) but I'm not sure what. Possibly there needs to be a bit more light on the fly's body, it looks a bit 'lost' in the frame - but that can add to the sense of a lonely ending, and I don't know quite where to focus. None of this is in any way detracting from your skill with the close up filter - a dof that narrow at f11 is drastic and you've controlled it well. Nor is it detracting from your ability to produce 'insect blood'.I'll come back to it later and try to be more constructive. Sorry.
I didn't think that this would be for everyone, but if you come up with anything more definite about what doesn't work I'd really appreciate your thoughts. The lighting on the body was difficult - so much black that it was hard to get any detail, so I think you might have something there
Electric: Now that's what I call using the weather to your advantage - dull weather = time using PS.And it's very satisfaying when you find a new way of using PS.
It's been a bit of a novelty to have the time to do it this weekend, but it was definitely fun and better than weeding the front garden which is what I'd have been doing if it was dry.
Of the 2 shots, I prefer #1 for its simplicity. It's bang on theme, clean, bright and does what it says on the tin perfectly.
#2 is eye-catching and I spent some time examining the intricate background - and very nice it is too, but I think it might work better in a more subdued colour so that it's not competing with the subject. Just my thoughts.
Thanks Jean. I'm with you on No.1, but I found the tutorial for the b/g in No.2 and couldn't resist trying it
Let's hope for a 'good' theme this week - and the time to enjoy it.
Jean
Endings:
Nice composition, and you've done a good job getting everything in focus! If you think it's tricky going for us 'regular macro' folks, spare a thought for those that use the MPE-65 super ultra extreme macro thingywhasit! And I wholeheartedly agree that dead beasties are much easier to shoot
Electric:
I actually really like these! And I think I prefer number one, with the plain background, but I'm a bit of a sucker for simplicity, so perhaps that's just me. Only criticism I can really make is that on the plain black background you can see the edge of the 'electricity' bit, above the left wire and below the right, there's a straight line which I guess marks the edge of the 'electricty' you drew, and the original shot.
The contrast on my monitor is all over the place at the moment, so chances are a lot of other people can't see it anyway though! And it's completely invisible on the second due to the busier background anyway
Chris
Hi Sarah, neat idea for endings, i especially like the touch of extra gore, just to go a bit further a blob of custard would have really made it as there is always some yellow goo to be seen when squishing flies.
I love electricity, great idea, nice job on the pp. I agree with Chris on this i think the simpler shot is the better one. I understand though as it easy to get carried away with photoshop and create something mad. How did you get this effect?

nice endings shot, for me i would like a little more depth of field to show more wood grain, but overall a nice shot.
Ian

#1 gets my vote for its simplicity (in comparison to background in #2).
Very creative in your PP skills as usual Sarah. I like #2 also, the background draws one's eye into the image, reminds me of the Matrix films or (showing my age here) the start of Doctor Who when the tardis is flying through space. Both images certainly say electric to me, well done again on your dull day PS creativity. Iain
Endings made me laugh. What kind of sick man am I?I think the whole thing works a treat.
Electric - the first gets my vote for its simplicity. The second is just a little too busy and contrived for my liking.
Well done for catching up.
)Electric - like both of these. The first is - as others have mentioned - nice and simple. The second reminds me of the Matrix for some reason.
Endings - that is a stupidly narrow DOF but you have controlled it really well. The effort to fake the blood has paid off as without it the shot wouldn't have had any impact. I think this is great and bang on theme.
Electric - another that is right on theme. Like the others I prefer number 1 for it's simplicity. Number two is good in it's own way but is very busy. I can't work out how you did the electricity though.
I know what you mean about work getting in the way. I finished today so will have to get my electric shot done tomorrow now. I might submit one on time at some point
Andy