Street Photography - what's it all about?

Juxtaposition is where its at

For me thats just one style of street photography, it doesn't have to be present to make a good picture. Thats a bit like saying all motorsport shots must have a complete car in them or you can't take a landscape unless it has a hill in it.
 
For you ;)

I happen to think Motion ID is a fantastic street photographer. You won't find much Juxtaposition on his photostream.

Well, IMVHO, you won't find much Street Photography in his photo stream.

Just because a movie is made in Arizona doesn't make it a Western, likewise, just because a photo is taken in the street doesn't make it Street Photogrpahy. When you're talking about a genre there are other elements which tend to dictate whether something ispart of that genre or not.

Motion ID photos can certainly be classed as reportage photography, but although Street is a form of reportage, I certainly would count him as a Street Photographer.
 
Well, IMVHO, you won't find much Street Photography in his photo stream.

Just because a movie is made in Arizona doesn't make it a Western, likewise, just because a photo is taken in the street doesn't make it Street Photogrpahy. When you're talking about a genre there are other elements which tend to dictate whether something ispart of that genre or not.

Motion ID photos can certainly be classed as reportage photography, but although Street is a form of reportage, I certainly would count him as a Street Photographer.

Guess it depends on your definition of Street Photography then. I see him as a street photographer through and through, he captures life, on the street. It maybe more subtle than some other forms, but I still see it.

No one is going to be able to tie a genre as subjective as this down, we will all have our own definitions, and ideas, and we could go round in circles all day long debating what it is and isn't. None of us are right, its why in the challenge thread, I said capture "Your Street".

Gary.
 
Let us turn to that Bible of Fact, Wikipedia.

"Street photography is a type of documentary photography that features subjects in candid situations within public places such as streets, parks, beaches, malls, political conventions, and other settings."

Job done.
 
Guess it depends on your definition of Street Photography then. I see him as a street photographer through and through, he captures life, on the street. It maybe more subtle than some other forms, but I still see it.

No one is going to be able to tie a genre as subjective as this down, we will all have our own definitions, and ideas, and we could go round in circles all day long debating what it is and isn't. None of us are right, its why in the challenge thread, I said capture "Your Street".

Well, if we were to use your definition, I'd only class him/her as an average Street Photographer. I certainly didn't see anything to make me sit up and take notice, and from what I could see they were, even though some were well taken, nothing more than record shots.
 
Well, if we were to use your definition, I'd only class him/her as an average Street Photographer. I certainly didn't see anything to make me sit up and take notice, and from what I could see they were, even though some were well taken, nothing more than record shots.

I don't think street photography is ever going to be your thing is it?

I guess it's a bit like music some people like classical some people like rock and some like everything. Not saying anything is better than anything else it just takes a certain mindset to aprreciate something for example I saw the mona lisa and thought it was just an average portrait while others will tell you it is a masterpiece?!? It takes all sorts, horses for courses and any other lazy palitude we can find.
 
Let us turn to that Bible of Fact, Wikipedia.

"Street photography is a type of documentary photography that features subjects in candid situations within public places such as streets, parks, beaches, malls, political conventions, and other settings."

Job done.

Job done? Only if you want a pointless definition, IMVHO.

What's the point in defining a genre in such vague terms? Look at genre in anyother art form and you'll find that definitions tend to be far more specific than that. By defining Street Photography in such general terms you're not creating a genre you're just describing the environment.

As for limiting it to candid, you're excluding two of the most famous examples of Street Photography ...

06kiss1.span.jpg


and

the_kiss1.jpg
 
I don't think street photography is ever going to be your thing is it?

I'm not sure where you get that idea from, if you read what I've said it's true Street Photography that I'm defending against a tide of average generic shots that happened to be takien in a street.

I guess it's a bit like music some people like classical some people like rock and some like everything. Not saying anything is better than anything else it just takes a certain mindset to aprreciate something for example I saw the mona lisa and thought it was just an average portrait while others will tell you it is a masterpiece?!? It takes all sorts, horses for courses and any other lazy palitude we can find.

I'd say that it was a lot like music. You mention two tpyes of music, rock and classical, and each one has its own genre. Rock includes grunge, NWBHM, thrash, puck etc, Clasical has opera, avant garde, chamber music etc. These genres are often played by the same or simialr instruments, and many may share themes, but they're still separate genres which lie underneath the overall type of music.

For me to say that Motion ID is an average Street photographer under Gary's wide ranging definition isn't a comment on his/her photogrpahy per se, but a comment based on the context of putting it within the genre. A shot of his/hers may be a superb fashion shot, a great urban landscape, or a fine portrait, and yet still be an poor/average example of Street Photography.
 
Well, if we were to use your definition, I'd only class him/her as an average Street Photographer. I certainly didn't see anything to make me sit up and take notice, and from what I could see they were, even though some were well taken, nothing more than record shots.

For real? :D He has a loyal following, and an outstanding reputation as one of "the best" at what he does. For some reason, he deleted his flickr account a fortnight ago, but his comments usually entered the hundreds, and the guy practically lived on Explore. I understand that there is no "scientific" way of measuring how good he is, however, if flickr held a top40 chart, I reckon he would be a top performer, consitently :D

Gary.
 
For real? :D He has a loyal following, and an outstanding reputation as one of "the best" at what he does. For some reason, he deleted his flickr account a fortnight ago, but his comments usually entered the hundreds, and the guy practically lived on Explore. I understand that there is no "scientific" way of measuring how good he is, however, if flickr held a top40 chart, I reckon he would be a top performer, consitently :D.

If the demographic decided quality, baked beans would be classed haute cuisine.

You were probably writing this as I posted my post above, but I rated him as a Street Photographer not as a photographer in general.
 
Look at genre in anyother art form and you'll find that definitions tend to be far more specific than that.

Not at the top level. For example 'chamber music' would include any piece of music written for a small 'classical' ensemble by any composer from Haydn to Adams. You have to go to the next level down to get more detailed - baroque, minimalist etc.

I think this is where my problem is. "Street photography" to me is the top level and it's from there that you begin to get more restrictive - so for me it does include 'record snaps' but also juxtaposition images and the like -- no 'type' being better than any other but obviously within the very broad genre there will be good and bad photographs.

(In short: "street" would be an equivalent of "landscape" etc.)

The two images you put up I would include but they'd also have a little category of their own called 'staged street photography' or posed or somesuch.

I only put the wikipedia definition up as an Aunt Sally. Sorry about that.;)
 
I'm not sure where you get that idea from, if you read what I've said it's true Street Photography that I'm defending against a tide of average generic shots that happened to be takien in a street.

Maybe I should have said street photography with a general definition rather than you more specific one?

I think we've reached a point where nobody is going to agree and everyone is probably correct in some peoples opinions and wrong in others. I shall end by saying art is subjective and beauty is in the eye of the beholder.
 
Hmm, he has 369 on there now so he must have put them all back, or a technical glitch maybe? :shrug:

Not likely, he had a statement on his profile that said "Born to be f****d over by others", and literally, no photos :D

The cake one, he put up first, then the others followed.

Maybe he had a breakdown :)

Gary.
 
Maybe I should have said street photography with a general definition rather than you more specific one?

I think we've reached a point where nobody is going to agree and everyone is probably correct in some peoples opinions and wrong in others. I shall end by saying art is subjective and beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Agreed, there is no right. There is no "true" street photography either. Silly debate, I guess its allright to be different. As long as everyone accepts Nikon wipes the floor with Canon, we can all remain friends.

Gary.
 
I think this is where my problem is. "Street photography" to me is the top level and it's from there that you begin to get more restrictive - so for me it does include 'record snaps' but also juxtaposition images and the like -- no 'type' being better than any other but obviously within the very broad genre there will be good and bad photographs.

(In short: "street" would be an equivalent of "landscape" etc.)

Well this is where we diverge then, I really can't see how "Street" would be on the top level. I'd put "Documentary" on the same level as "Landscape", "Reportage" under "Documentary" and "Street" would sit below "Reportage".
 
Agreed, there is no right. There is no "true" street photography either. Silly debate, I guess its allright to be different.

Well not really, the debate is far from silly. I think having a clear understanding of genre helps photographers have an idea of what they want to achieve, either by following the genre, or reacting against it. At the very least we might be spared the awful examples of girls walking down a high street ith abgs of shopping or talking on their phones because that's what people think is classed as 'Street'. I also think that there can be a 'true' definiton, in as much as you can have them in other art forms.

As long as everyone accepts Nikon wipes the floor with Canon, we can all remain friends.

I thought that was a given?
 
I really like that one too, the first one is also a nice photo but not amazing.

It doesn't make you a bad person it just makes POAH appear contreversial as usual. See all the comments made in this thread for examples.


its my photo, so its up to me if I think its **** or not lol
 
Maybe I should have said street photography with a general definition rather than you more specific one?

Well yes, it's never going to be my cup of tea because its doesn't say anything, and the reason it doesn't say anything is because it doesn't know what it is trying to say.

I think we've reached a point where nobody is going to agree and everyone is probably correct in some peoples opinions and wrong in others. I shall end by saying art is subjective and beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Well the appreciation of art is subjective, but that doesn't preclude other aspects from being objectively studied, particularly style and gene. You don't get total agreement in science so you'll never find it in art, but that doesn't mean that every on can be right just because it is art.
 
*must resist commenting about agreement in science*

It doesn't say anything?! It can say just as much or just as little as any portrait, landscape etc photo out there. If you choose not to see it, fair enough. If it's not your cup of tea, fair enough, that is your opinion. But saying it doesn't know what to say is just, well, a little short sighted and obtuse tbh.
 
The story of any photo, regardless of genre depends on the depth delved by the viewer, Canon users obviously delve deeper :p (joking !!) lighten up if you don't get it don't view it :D



"tis the season to be jolly!............."
Merry Christmas humbugs :D
 
It doesn't say anything?! It can say just as much or just as little as any portrait, landscape etc photo out there. If you choose not to see it, fair enough. If it's not your cup of tea, fair enough, that is your opinion. But saying it doesn't know what to say is just, well, a little short sighted and obtuse tbh.

I think that you've missed the point and he context of my argument there.
 
to most 99% of the population its a funny picture of a man with a starbucks sign for a head turned B&W to make it more interesting

POAH,

No disrespect, but can you really speak for 99% for the population when making the above statement. I have heard that 50% of statistics are made up!!!

To get back to the debate, street photography links to art in as much as both mediums should be asking the viewer to consider ideas and concepts that have not previously been explored.

For example I recently visited the TATE gallery in Liverpool and saw a piece by Damien Hurst, named ‘Butterflies’ initially I was attracted to the large canvas because it was decorated with butterflies.

As I was viewing the picture I became aware that the butterflies were real and had been killed just to produce the picture, at that moment I became repelled.

This feeling of both attraction and repulsion stayed with me, I read later that this was the idea of the piece, to make the viewer attracted and repelled at the same time.

Street photography also know as social commentary does ask a lot of the viewer more so than any other form of photography because it is not just a technical reproduction, it is a two way process between photographer and viewer.

Like all art there is good and bad photography, I have seen some images that I just do not understand and cannot enter the photographer’s frame of reference.

To answer the question regarding cutting a cow in half and saying it represents the ‘industrialisation of agriculture’ then if you do that and can defend the work against critics by citing ether artistic precedence or a link to a wider debate , then to you have produced a valid piece of work .

Like with any art form people will either love or loath it , if it stands the test of time and is cited by other artist as inspirational , then the work stands on it’s own merits .
 
Dare I enter my own opinion on this topic? To me street photography can mean anything you want it to, and many people do just that. However for me personally I think street photography is more than just street portraiture. It's about capturing people in situations making use of various technical aspects of photography, such as context, juxtaposition, contrast and other things like humour, shock, surprise, sadness. I don't think there is any right or wrong when it comes to something like this and is basically entirely subjective.
 
Dare I enter my own opinion on this topic? To me street photography can mean anything you want it to, and many people do just that. However for me personally I think street photography is more than just street portraiture. It's about capturing people in situations making use of various technical aspects of photography, such as context, juxtaposition, contrast and other things like humour, shock, surprise, sadness. I don't think there is any right or wrong when it comes to something like this and is basically entirely subjective.

Pretty good nutshell there! :thumbs:
 
You don't get total agreement in science so you'll never find it in art, but that doesn't mean that every on can be right just because it is art.

With theories, no you don't get agreement with all the scientist.

With Facts, you do get agreement, because it is a scientific fact.

It is a Scientific fact that water is made up of 2 Hydrogen and 1 Oxygen. Anyone is welcome to disagree but he will just look like an idiot.

It is a scientific fact that Gravity exist

It is a scientific fact that what you are typing on, looking at are a creation of science. Try and dispute that.
 
Back
Top