Street Photography - what's it all about?

With theories, no you don't get agreement with all the scientist.

With Facts, you do get agreement, because it is a scientific fact.

It is a Scientific fact that water is made up of 2 Hydrogen and 1 Oxygen. Anyone is welcome to disagree but he will just look like an idiot.

It is a scientific fact that Gravity exist

It is a scientific fact that what you are typing on, looking at are a creation of science. Try and dispute that.

Well that was a interesting if somewhat bemusingly unnecessary diversion! By the way, a fact in science is only a fact until it is proven otherwise, because all facts are in ... err .. fact just substantiated* theories.

*Substantiated by our current level of knowledge and therefore laible to change as we increase our knowledge
 
Well that was a interesting if somewhat bemusingly unnecessary diversion! By the way, a fact in science is only a fact until it is proven otherwise, because all facts are in ... err .. fact just substantiated* theories.

*Substantiated by our current level of knowledge and therefore laible to change as we increase our knowledge

Facts aren't substantiated theories, theories are interpretations of facts. It's not like a theory will somehow become a fact if enough evidence is obtained: a theory is already solid and, as the US NAS puts it, "so well established that no new evidence is likely to alter them". Facts are facts; theories build upon facts; theories do not become facts.

"A scientific theory is a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world, based on a body of facts that have been repeatedly confirmed through observation and experiment."

(http://www.aaas.org/news/press_room/evolution/qanda.shtml)

The perception of there being some continuum of "theory -> law -> fact" or "theory -> fact -> law", on which each scientific discovery somehow travels as we learn more about it, is pretty misleading.

Edit: wait, how did a discussion about street photography get onto this? XD
 
Indeed Rob. And to put it bluntly, if you had elaborated enough already, do you think I'd have asked again?

That reads quite harsh m8 - Mods are jumping on 'arguments' rather than 'debates' - careful

DD
 
Having read through most of this thread I am going to venture my opinion. I feel that landscape and street photography probably have a lot in common as well as being total opposits. Both are fairly generic descriptions for images of the environment. A landscape could be an epic vista of mountains and lakes, a small area of woodland, a row of houses, something around you but which changes slowly over time or seasons. Street to me is again the environment around you, but more in an urban setting where everything is in a continual flux.

The pictures that result from it are bound to be as varied as the photographers that take them. Some prefer gritty black and whites, some moving, some clean and sharp. Each is surely as valid as the other because it is what we see from our own viewpoint. If everyone shot the same type of image it would get very boring
 
For me, street photography represents the very essense of what photography is about. Capturing a moment in time and preserving it. So many things around us that seem mundane and ordinary take on new meaning when frozen in a picture.
 
Its great this thread came back.
How it was missed in the first place, I dunno, maybe the word street in the title automatically threw it in the "not relevant to most" folder.
With the recent sprouting of contributory street threads, it turns into the topical thread it should have been when DD first baked it.
So I just wanna say well done, to those who started the threads, those who contributed, and those who have found, if not a complete understanding, at least little appreciation for the art of street.

:popcorn:
 
Fact is fact and science is science but both of these need to be presented to the listener .... that IS art. Wether it is a blunt statement or an elaborate story, it IS art. Fact and science depict the instruments we are using for this communication but they are pleasantly transformed into user friendly objects by artistic skill and practicallity at the design stage.

Street Photography is in a similar vein to me. All the ingredients are there, it's just a matter of designing them into a picture that says more than just science and fact.
 
Quick query then...

Today I popped into Leeds to take my wife for a surprise lunch in Harvey Nichols (she works nearby), and for that extra special treat - I took the kids too - lovely

The daughter says 'Daddy I need a new dress' - so off we went to FC and while she was trying one on I took this - it's a shot of a very bored assistant in the ladies changing room

I quite like it - but is it 'Street' - and yes it's technically under the street !!!

Oh - and knowing it wasn't really a camera opportunity, I took only one camera and one lens, my new 10.5mm fisheye

Cheers

DD

Waiting_room.jpg
 
I'd say so...

Its dull, ordinary and bent, but still more street than anything else...:D
I like it too, its a very familiar scene taken from life, except you have time to study it before it changes.
 
To answer the question regarding cutting a cow in half and saying it represents the ‘industrialisation of agriculture’ then if you do that and can defend the work against critics by citing ether artistic precedence or a link to a wider debate , then to you have produced a valid piece of work .

Like with any art form people will either love or loath it , if it stands the test of time and is cited by other artist as inspirational , then the work stands on it’s own merits .

Ok, I get what you are saying with art there... but that is the crunch in both photographic art and pretty much other forms too, there has to be more to something than just the obvious if it is to be "clever" no?

Or have I failed to grasp art totally and really all there was to that unmade bed was actually an unmade bed, no further intent was ever thought of.

What I honestly never have understood is whether the commentary comes from the creator or whether or not we are just left to try and work out what they meant, and at the same time making the assumption they really have to have had a deeper idea than "yeah it really is two people eating at Burger King".

If I did add a comment then would it make it a better photo?

If I called DD's shot "reflection on the rise of American cultural imperialism" woud you think it a cleverer photo?

Please don't think I'm being argumentative, I'm just exploring this by writing what's going round in my head.... no ideas what the answers are!

I have learnt a lot in this discussion so far!
 
If I called DD's shot "reflection on the rise of American cultural imperialism" woud you think it a cleverer photo?

It would depend on who you ask……:)
 
Here's one that's definitely 'Street' - as in... taken on the street :lol:

But this one's rubbish right ??? If right, I'm getting the idea !!!

DD

Should make a poll on which one peeps find more interesting.

In 1# - I like that 1/4 of the fan grill is coming off, a screw fell out, I wonder why the fire extinguisher isn't propping the door open, I like the assistants uncomfortable pose, its the best she can do to look available and ready to serve when inside she wants to go home/fag break/browse HMV or something.
I'm putting colour on that beech type floor, big brother is watching and the handrail looks not entirely suited to being a handrail.
Why....I don't f****** know..:shrug:

2# - burger looks nice, I hope it all falls out on the table....:lol:
I'm reduced to looking in the windows of the reflected building to see if the point of the photo is there, but it isn't.
Some peeps might find it more interesting, I dunno, its quite a subjective thing.
 
Ok, I get what you are saying with art there... but that is the crunch in both photographic art and pretty much other forms too, there has to be more to something than just the obvious if it is to be "clever" no?

Or have I failed to grasp art totally and really all there was to that unmade bed was actually an unmade bed, no further intent was ever thought of.

What I honestly never have understood is whether the commentary comes from the creator or whether or not we are just left to try and work out what they meant, and at the same time making the assumption they really have to have had a deeper idea than "yeah it really is two people eating at Burger King".

That’s the thing about true art though, the initial intent must be in the photographers mind to call it true art ... without initial intent its not actually art, claimed or not. Art is not about being clever or pretty or even understandable....although any of those may be aspects the artist could utilise. ..it is only about wanting or needeing to conveying a point, suggestion or other emotive aspect by constructing something, it should be expressive, good, bad or pointless, but nonetheless its still art.
It is however only the final image that’s subjective not the art itself, which, because of its artists personal initial intent is not open to debate. They either did intend the result, or there lying about it.


Maybe Dave (diddy) can help us answer this too ...

If Dave, your first shot of the girl down the stair? ...maybe you thought something like, "hmm she looks good down that view with this lens, kinda moody and thoughtfull if I frame it right". Then that’s intent, and true art.

The Burger shot on the other hand? .. if you where just pondering whether that was a good street shot because it had some people obviously in the street ... Then no, its not art.

So am I wrong, are they both art, neither or what? :naughty::D
 
I shot, well wasted some slide for Gary's street thing, unfortunately I ran out of time, just got them back today, there was only four anyway.
Lunchtime Friday I nipped out for 5 mins to try and snap something whilst I was in Leeds, saw these guys playing chess in the street, long shadows, half the board black the other in sunlight, black and white pieces, b/w board....I dunno, I just saw loads of b/w contrasts with peeps/board pieces shadows, it looked cool.
Anyway, slides are back and it doesn't do a thing for me, apart from the obvious juxt, its a nothing..:shrug:
Maybe I should have been closer, maybe corner on to the board, maybe into the sun, maybe more connection with the peeps, I swear it looked better than that, I dunno, its not an exact science

30w89xy.jpg
 
That’s the thing about true art though, the initial intent must be in the photographers mind to call it true art ... without initial intent its not actually art, claimed or not.

That's hardly a truism, and besides: how do you know what the artist's true intent was? They rarely discuss the meaning of their work, generally.

Art is about interpretation, about how you feel when viewing it. The feelings of the artist have very little relevance, really.
 
Haven't most of todays kids been brought up to be kings of the burgers?

I'd try and isolate the child and the sign a little more :shrug:
 
They either did intend the result, or there lying about it.

The Burger shot on the other hand? .. if you where just pondering whether that was a good street shot because it had some people obviously in the street ... Then no, its not art.

So am I wrong, are they both art, neither or what? :naughty::D


You'll never know unless you speak to the photographer.
It's not something you should consider, its like photoshop cloning and alterations, if you can't tell by looking at it that it was altered, then it wasn't altered, only the tog will know that so there's no point in doubting its authenticity, same as doubting artistic intention authenticity, only the tog will know (and have to live with it) so it isn't up for debate.
By his own skill and judgement, the tog was there to capture the moment, whether carefully crafted over hours of observation, or just giving him/herself the best opportunity to capture something by accident.
Landscapes hang about for years never changing, street changes every fraction of a second, so not every shot can be said to be carefully considered.
I count giving oneself the best opportunity to capture something by accident, intent.
 
That's hardly a truism, and besides: how do you know what the artist's true intent was? They rarely discuss the meaning of their work, generally.

Art is about interpretation, about how you feel when viewing it. The feelings of the artist have very little relevance, really.


No, no its not Rob ...it is about intent of the artist as I said. Whether the artist is successful or not is not actually open for question, that’s a side effect ...and whether its art or not is defiantly not down to the viewers interpretation of the work. Its success in various ways ,may come down to the viewers art interpretation though....that’s the capitalist world we live in right.
Its a common misinterpretation of what art is, to assume we the viewer have the right to say what is and is not art ...we don't only the artist can say what he wanted to say. We have the right to accept that choice, enjoy the work, or not.
And as for artists not telling us, well that’s just tough I guess, part of the reason they produced the art in the first place rather than just telling us how they felt. ...actually most of them do tell us, whether we see the vision and appreciate it, or not, is another matter.
 
You'll never know unless you speak to the photographer.
It's not something you should consider, its like photoshop cloning and alterations, if you can't tell by looking at it that it was altered, then it wasn't altered, only the tog will know that so there's no point in doubting its authenticity, same as doubting artistic intention authenticity, only the tog will know (and have to live with it) so it isn't up for debate.
By his own skill and judgement, the tog was there to capture the moment, whether carefully crafted over hours of observation, or just giving him/herself the best opportunity to capture something by accident.
Landscapes hang about for years never changing, street changes every fraction of a second, so not every shot can be said to be carefully considered.
I count giving oneself the best opportunity to capture something by accident, intent.

Yeah, I agree on all points.... I'm only actually interested in the final image myself, that’s all that counts.... all methods and ways of getting to that point are all equally valid as artistic methods, and inevitably all still created for the original intent, so as you say, all irrelevant.
 
Maybe Dave (diddy) can help us answer this too ...

If Dave, your first shot of the girl down the stair? ...maybe you thought something like, "hmm she looks good down that view with this lens, kinda moody and thoughtfull if I frame it right". Then that’s intent, and true art.

The Burger shot on the other hand? .. if you where just pondering whether that was a good street shot because it had some people obviously in the street ... Then no, its not art.

So am I wrong, are they both art, neither or what? :naughty::D


This is an easy one - yep I saw this bored looking lass in a scene of light colours, with lines from the corridor, steps & bannisters all leading the eye to her. Raising the 10.5mm it all just framed well and funnily enough no other lens could have done it - I also took about 8 shots in total as she moved about a (small) bit and I tried to make the doorway both symmetrical and level - for me then this is 'art'

The other shot was taken walking along with the camera held mid chest height and I simply pressed the shutter a few times to see what I got. I actually took a couple of such cafe shots not for 'me' but because I'd seen others' work looking just like that's what they had done - so I was testing for total 'chance' over 'seen/planned' - so for me it's a snapshot only and not 'art'

DD
 
This is an easy one - yep I saw this bored looking lass in a scene of light colours, with lines from the corridor, steps & bannisters all leading the eye to her. Raising the 10.5mm it all just framed well and funnily enough no other lens could have done it - I also took about 8 shots in total as she moved about a (small) bit and I tried to make the doorway both symmetrical and level - for me then this is 'art'

The other shot was taken walking along with the camera held mid chest height and I simply pressed the shutter a few times to see what I got. I actually took a couple of such cafe shots not for 'me' but because I'd seen others' work looking just like that's what they had done - so I was testing for total 'chance' over 'seen/planned' - so for me it's a snapshot only and not 'art'

DD

I would agree with this, whilst I am not saying its wrong, shooting from the hip feels a little "hit and miss"...

Gary.
 
I would agree with this, whilst I am not saying its wrong, shooting from the hip feels a little "hit and miss"...

Gary.

Morning EG !!!

And yes, very much hit & miss - but then so much photography is like that isn't it?

If you wandered around snapping from the hip (a decent viewing angle in many cases too) at the end of the day, with judicious editing, you may well have a 'corker' or two - would that be 'wrong' though if the result is a defining image?

As opposed to someone shooting very little and with true thought/planning who may end up with the same quality of image?

Sounds like one for a TP meet - one limited to 50 shots thought out, one who MUST take 1,000+ and decide if any are worth keeping later :shrug:

DD
 
Morning EG !!!

And yes, very much hit & miss - but then so much photography is like that isn't it?

If you wandered around snapping from the hip (a decent viewing angle in many cases too) at the end of the day, with judicious editing, you may well have a 'corker' or two - would that be 'wrong' though if the result is a defining image?

As opposed to someone shooting very little and with true thought/planning who may end up with the same quality of image?

Sounds like one for a TP meet - one limited to 50 shots thought out, one who MUST take 1,000+ and decide if any are worth keeping later :shrug:

DD

I think what is best, in my opinion (and shootting thousands when out will help you learn this if you don't know what to look for), what is best is to try and kid yourself into thinking you can spot those magical scenes. Each time you think you see such a scene, shoot it. Eventually, you will see them, and you will slow down with the shots you take, and ultimately I guess you will then get a much higher hit rate.

I think my eye has developed hugely since starting this a week ago, as I was concious at the end of the week that I was "looking" for something extra in the shots. Still failing more or less, but I am glad for example in the judging thread that my "Picture of Health" was picked up on. I saw it and shot it for the very reason that I thought it worked. Girl, babies, fag, kebab shop. I did not pick up on the fact she was overweight, otherwise I saw those elements before firing. I don't think a week ago I would have done.

Gary.
 
I think what is best, in my opinion (and shootting thousands when out will help you learn this if you don't know what to look for), what is best is to try and kid yourself into thinking you can spot those magical scenes. Each time you think you see such a scene, shoot it. Eventually, you will see them, and you will slow down with the shots you take, and ultimately I guess you will then get a much higher hit rate.

I think my eye has developed hugely since starting this a week ago, as I was concious at the end of the week that I was "looking" for something extra in the shots. Still failing more or less, but I am glad for example in the judging thread that my "Picture of Health" was picked up on. I saw it and shot it for the very reason that I thought it worked. Girl, babies, fag, kebab shop. I did not pick up on the fact she was overweight, otherwise I saw those elements before firing. I don't think a week ago I would have done.

Gary.


That's all about developing the 'eye' for things

I often get asked why I take so few shots on club trips, and my usual answer is 'Cos there's no point' - meaning, something's not 'right' at that moment and as I'll only delete them later - why bother. I guess that takes time to achieve; I can do that in landscapes, portraits and I'm getting better at Weddings - but with Street stuff I'd need to waste a load too to zone in on what works for me

The quicker you learn the better, but my Street problem was (note past tense) that I didn't get it at all - now I think I'm getting 'it' - so thanks for reviving this thread m8 - it's helped a lot

:thumbs:

DD
 
That's all about developing the 'eye' for things

I often get asked why I take so few shots on club trips, and my usual answer is 'Cos there's no point' - meaning, something's not 'right' at that moment and as I'll only delete them later - why bother. I guess that takes time to achieve; I can do that in landscapes, portraits and I'm getting better at Weddings - but with Street stuff I'd need to waste a load too to zone in on what works for me

The quicker you learn the better, but my Street problem was (note past tense) that I didn't get it at all - now I think I'm getting 'it' - so thanks for reviving this thread m8 - it's helped a lot

:thumbs:

DD

Awesome, next time we have a street challenge, your entries are going to "Rawk This Joint"
rocker.gif


Gary.
 
Who was it that shot the "Blacks" photo. It was a photo of the Shop "Blacks", with a black man (PC?) standing alone in the scene. It was very cool. May have been Shutterman...can't remember.

Gary.


That was me on my first Street attempt Gary !!! :D

That was my idea of watching for backgrounds, then waiting for something to happen in the foreground to make the story/humour

As for 'rawking' the joint - well not sure about that, but if my next attempt doesn't rank as ****** I'll call that a success :lol:

DD

These 3 were my favs of that stroll around...

#1
TP121.jpg


#2
TP11.jpg


#3
TP10.jpg
 
That was me on my first Street attempt Gary !!! :D

That was my idea of watching for backgrounds, then waiting for something to happen in the foreground to make the story/humour

As for 'rawking' the joint - well not sure about that, but if my next attempt doesn't rank as ****** I'll call that a success :lol:

DD

Well there you go. Dunno why I thought of that shot, but for me, 100% street :D

Do you think you could dig out that thread? Tried to find it. Would love to put it back in the context of all the recent discussions.

Gary.
EDIT: Too quick :)
 
Dave, seriously. 1 is a corker. 2 is an absolute blinder. I remember the set well, that "shoot him" image is flawless IMO and is perfect street. 3 is still very good, just the other 2 smoke it. Looks like you "have understood street" for ages :)

Gary.
 
Dave, seriously. 1 is a corker. 2 is an absolute blinder. I remember the set well, that "shoot him" image is flawless IMO and is perfect street. 3 is still very good, just the other 2 smoke it. Looks like you "have understood street" for ages :)

Gary.



Awww you big sweetie - where's that hugs & kisses smiley now :lol:

I was processing so many images, and edits, I ran out of TP space - so had every image deleted to start again

I was a bit concerned others may find #1 a bit too non-pc, but that wasn't the case then and hopefully won't be now either

Cheers

Off to wrap presents now before a meet up & mini-shoot with Alib !!!

:wave:

DD
 
And yes, very much hit & miss - but then so much photography is like that isn't it?

If you wandered around snapping from the hip (a decent viewing angle in many cases too) at the end of the day, with judicious editing, you may well have a 'corker' or two - would that be 'wrong' though if the result is a defining image?

As opposed to someone shooting very little and with true thought/planning who may end up with the same quality of image?

Thing is though as Joxby said.... "I count, giving oneself the best opportunity to capture something by accident, as intent."

Which I totally agree with, so shooting from the hip can also be art. :nuts::D
 
By his own skill and judgement, the tog was there to capture the moment, whether carefully crafted over hours of observation, or just giving him/herself the best opportunity to capture something by accident.
Landscapes hang about for years never changing, street changes every fraction of a second, so not every shot can be said to be carefully considered.
I count giving oneself the best opportunity to capture something by accident, intent.

I'll own up to this one being a happy accident :

img_4547.jpg


Not exactly shooting from the hip, but the camera was on my lap and I framed the shot using Live View - another new tool in the street photographers bag.

For me it was an experiment to test how close I could be and still shoot something. Did I see the hand reaching for his nose and the headline ?, no I didn't, but I was very happy to see them in the image afterwards :)
 
Back
Top