Wedding photography and the recent requests for freebies...

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is interesting though to note that some (not all) who have posted on this thread have no real interest in the subject and couldn't careless. Suggesting we are wingeing, insecure or over protective is really uncalled for.


I think that its all about having confidence in your self as well as the ability
to provide that ( any) service.

It just seems to me that a lot of these arguments start, and are perpetuated, by insecurity. ( where is that tin hat emoticon?)

Guilty as charged and if you read post #62 you will see
my reasoning behind it


It's our job to keep our socks pulled up :)
If your truly happy with what you do, if your truly satisfied with what you can achieve, then whatever the technology, you should really have nothing to fear..
Very true ( my point exactly :thumbs:)

My concerns are whether it's a threat to this forum. I remain undecided.

I just dont think thats something I want to see associated and seemingly encouraged with TP ... regardless of my own personal feelings towards wedding photography.

About a quarter of the way through this thread I would have disagreed with you on that,
but the way this has morphed into an almost us and them (I'm on the fence as always :D)
argument I can see more negatives than positives in allowing this
"freebie section and the potential harm that it could do to TP as a
forum.

I think that on balance, someone suggested allowing potential
brides to advertise in the wanted section may be the best solution.
That way they can put in a request but it is no way endorsed by TP.
By allowing a separate section for "bride wants a freebie"
( erm, well you know what I mean :D)

It does somewhat ( would ) appear to me and probably "outsiders"
that it was in fact endorsed by TP and the adminnies.

 
Could you have a list [on a sticky] of all the togs interested in doing a free or cheaper weddings.

People could add their name or delete it, as and when they please.

They could say what they would be prepared to do and what area.

Then all communication could be through a PM.

I would encourage anyone to broaden their horizons, but maybe if it was done through the PM they would not feel they are being 'watched' and 'criticised' by others.
 
I think I've said all I want to, unless someone wants to throw something else into the hat...

I think there's a benefit to it as long as it's policed properly...if this 'facility' is advertised on the various Bride2B sites, then there has to be the Mother-Of-All-Stickies attached to it, laying out in 'words of one syllable' that 'we' will try and steer potential customers towards any professional Wedding Photographer members in the first instance as that is where they'll get the best value.

It should be made clear that if the customer does decide to go ahead with a non-Wedding-Pro for 'free' then they have absolutely no comebacks if it goes awry.

It needs to also be made abundantly clear that this 'facility' is merely a portal to enable people to get in touch and is not 'sponsored' or 'endorsed' by TP in any way.
 
i don't think it should be advertised elsewhere tbh, if they want a free photographer then they'll find their own way here and if not then if someone is wanting to do wedding photography and offer free weddings then they should be marketing that off their own back, part of getting into weddings as people have rightly pointed out is actually doing some work.

i guess my standpoint at the moment (seeing as it's something i'm looking to move into) is that it's a subject that should be catered for but not pampered to.

it's like the screaming toddler that's getting way more attention than the well behaved ones...not really fair at the end of the day.
 
is it possible a professional does a wedding free
is that a possibility...
i think i saw it done once
 
thanks for all the opinions and comments, further discussions will be done in the staff room...
 
Unlikely - think: if Wedding Pro's are getting twitchy about the possibility of toggers on here offering to do weddings for free, what chance do you really have of getting one of them to actually train someone who'll be in direct competition with him on his own patch?

All this talk of courses, networking etc is just BS - it screams to me of insecure photographers who've cornered themselves into a niche market, terrified that their rice-bowl is about to taken away from them by hordes of lower-priced (or free) competition...

Diversify or die... and as I've said on other threads many, many times - if your images are good enough, you will survive...

i totally agree , very well put
 
thanks for all the opinions and comments, further discussions will be done in the staff room...

Does that mean its time for a :lock: :lock: :lock:then ?


 
...not yet...need to let those getting in from work and overseas members in different time zones a chance to put in first...
 
...not yet...need to let those getting in from work and overseas members in different time zones a chance to put in first...

Fair as always :thumbs:

(BTW it was a question not a request )
 
thanks for all the opinions and comments, further discussions will be done in the staff room...



got to say it but your attitude as a mod beggars belife sometimes you really seem to have a bee in your bonnet about wedding photography dont you. This as far as i am aware is a forum about all things photography hence the name talkphotography maybe you should rename it talkeverythingexceptweddingphotography if you dont like it.

Love it or hate it wedding photography (on this forum) creates discussion/agreement.disagreement.pleasure.disatisfaction and many other good and bad points regarding the subject, to me as long as people are coming to your website to discuss the said matters that should be enough.

To talk of banning it and closing threads at your discression when you've had enough of the subject really gets my back up

sorry if you dont like what ive said but i have to say it

Dave:thumbs:
 
Does that mean its time for a :lock: :lock: :lock:then ?


Ideally, threads should never be locked. Only if they have got out of hand and require that sort of extreme action. Otherwise leave things alone. That has been the thrust of what I have been saying all along, and others I think.

If a thread has run its course and nobody has anything to add, it will quickly fall down the page and effectively close itself.
 
yeah another thing maybe instead of talking of closing threads and sometimes actually closing them maybe the mods could spend some more time......................agghhhhhhhhh forget it its not worth it
 
Fascinating and well debated topic.

My only contribution is to quote words of wisdom from an experienced printer that I worked with many years ago. We were often approached by churches and other charities to print a few event tickets, or draw tickets whatever, but always with the promise that paid work would follow.

This printer would always say:

"The only thing you get if you do a job for nothing, is more jobs to do for nothing"

I cant remember just how many times this has proven true and I cant help but think its true in this case, applying not only to individuals but forum members as a whole.

After careful consideration I have just come to the view that such posts should be removed by the Mods. Anyone who want wedding photography experience should gain that as a second to an experienced photographer, rather than devaluing the whole profession (not just the wedding part, what next, anyone want to do a free family portrait, or school photo etc?)

Thats my view no doubt many will disagree - feel free!!!
 
After careful consideration I have just come to the view that such posts should be removed by the Mods. Anyone who want wedding photography experience should gain that as a second to an experienced photographer, rather than devaluing the whole profession (not just the wedding part, what next, anyone want to do a free family portrait, or school photo etc?)

Thats my view no doubt many will disagree - feel free!!!

Many of us would love the opportunity to assist and learn from a pro - but these opportunities arent that easy to come by - believe me I have looked (and still am).

Doing my own shoots is the next best thing.
 
Studio16, you have a problem with moderating decisions, please use the correct channels. Don't use this thread to have a dig at someone who spend his time looking after this place.

Maybe if you spent all your time pandering to all the whingers and immature children and **** stirrers (I can name names but wont) who can't help but post juvenile tit for tat **** all the time, then you might understand why we have to close threads.

To come into a thread and respond to a perfectly innocent comment from matty explaining that we are continuing to discuss this amongst staff, just to have a dig is bloody rude. You have a problem? use the correct channels. Don't know what the correct channels are? Read the rules.

Now, enough OT...

Back on topic please.
 
I personally will vote to veto this from happening, it's not what we were set up to provide and it's not something I'd like to be associated with.

It devalues a photographers worth
It risks the reputation of this forum
It's too much hassle to police, don't forget it's the site staff who end up fighting the fires.
 
I personally will vote to veto this from happening, it's not what we were set up to provide and it's not something I'd like to be associated with.

It devalues a photographers worth
It risks the reputation of this forum
It's too much hassle to police, don't forget it's the site staff who end up fighting the fires.

This is the proposed solution to the fact that certain forum members hounded posters off the wedding forum. Posters who were asking for services that many members on here were willing to provide.

This forums reputation (and probably the profession) has already been damaged by these incidents.
 
Not reading all the pages, too many :D

My idea.

There is a forum linking to here as a directory of "cheap photographers". I think this is an EXTREMELY bad development.

If it were me, I would use the technology available to DETECT those incoming hits from said forum, and redirect to a page which explains in full detail, just how difficult a job wedding photography is, and how much work goes into it. It should cover the cost of equipment, insurance, travel costs and transport requirements, the computers and web sites needing paid for, the marketing, the whole lot. Each and every visitor from that forum should be made to accept that they have read said document (some won't), and at least they can't claim to be surprised when their request for free professional photographers is laughed at. The words are bold for a reason.

Gary.
 
Studio16, you have a problem with moderating decisions, please use the correct channels. Don't use this thread to have a dig at someone who spend his time looking after this place.

Maybe if you spent all your time pandering to all the whingers and immature children and **** stirrers (I can name names but wont) who can't help but post juvenile tit for tat **** all the time, then you might understand why we have to close threads.

To come into a thread and respond to a perfectly innocent comment from matty explaining that we are continuing to discuss this amongst staff, just to have a dig is bloody rude. You have a problem? use the correct channels. Don't know what the correct channels are? Read the rules.

Now, enough OT...

Back on topic please.

WHATS UP ARE WE NOT ALLOWED TO COMMENT ON MODS COMMENTS :shrug:

Its not rude and i didnt use it just to have a dig at someone its a fair enough comment as far as i am concerned. That "perfectly innocent comment" you say has been a line that i seem to have come acroos a lot latley from matty and all i was doing was expressing my opinions that its a forum about photography weather its wedding/portrait/horses or nude its photography and if some areas of photography create more heated discussions than others then i would of thought it was your (the sites) best interest to deal with it and not keep harping on about banning it and how fed up you are with it, its been said and suggested many times what to do with the subject so i suggest you read those suggestions.

Dave :thumbs:
 
Fascinating and well debated topic...

...After careful consideration I have just come to the view that such posts should be removed by the Mods. Anyone who want wedding photography experience should gain that as a second to an experienced photographer, rather than devaluing the whole profession (not just the wedding part, what next, anyone want to do a free family portrait, or school photo etc?)

Thats my view no doubt many will disagree - feel free!!!

Okay, I disagree!

Mods should only intervene in extreme circumstances. This debate hasn't got anywhere near that on any score.

I do free family portraits all the time. I enjoy it. So do the families. I'm doing one this weekend. Or should I be prevented?
 
I've got my friends wedding next year and will be looking for a second person to help out. A forum here where I could post would be good however a place for non-forum people could come in and ask for free stuff is not a great idea. If someone advertises they want to do one for free fair enough I think.
 
Not reading all the pages, too many :D

My idea.

There is a forum linking to here as a directory of "cheap photographers". I think this is an EXTREMELY bad development.

If it were me, I would use the technology available to DETECT those incoming hits from said forum, and redirect to a page which explains in full detail, just how difficult a job wedding photography is, and how much work goes into it. It should cover the cost of equipment, insurance, travel costs and transport requirements, the computers and web sites needing paid for, the marketing, the whole lot. Each and every visitor from that forum should be made to accept that they have read said document (some won't), and at least they can't claim to be surprised when their request for free professional photographers is laughed at. The words are bold for a reason.

Gary.

If I was about to embark on a professional photographic career, I might be inclined to agree with you ;)

But, like almost everybody else on here, I'm not. So I don't.
 
I think there's a benefit to it as long as it's policed properly...if this 'facility' is advertised on the various Bride2B sites, then there has to be the Mother-Of-All-Stickies attached to it, laying out in 'words of one syllable' that 'we' will try and steer potential customers towards any professional Wedding Photographer members in the first instance as that is where they'll get the best value.

Hi Rob,

I'm in two minds about the potential benefits but the idea of advertising on the Bride2be sites is wrong. I'm not worried/paranoid whatever reasons people may give against free togs, but I along with a fair few other members pay to advertise on those Bride2B sites and the idea of TP advertising itself as a source of free togs rankles for this reason. Mostly we don't advertise against TP (there is the odd exception) but it would be nice if it mainted the same back

Advertising the service doesn't seem to sit either with what Matty et al are trying to achieve here

Finally, its a photography forum, and helping the members is good, is not a bridal services forum

Cheers
Hugh
 
For what it's worth, I'm beginning to agree its not a good idea....
 
There do exist sites based around photogrpahers looking for work - someone should surreptitiously mention THOSE on the wedding forums instead. Thus diverting all attention in opposite direction. Then we can run away and hide behind a tree.

L
 
Finally, its a photography forum, and helping the members is good, is not a bridal services forum

Cheers
Hugh

I'm with Hugh .... and yes I'm biased - and no I haven't read all the other pages - but how many of you doing other jobs would allow someone to offer to do the same work for free in its own section ... then you would become a bit insecure no doubt...

But apparently Wedding Pros' don't get afforded the same respect ...
 
Well, we are in portraiture. If people want to seek a freebie, they were never going to pay to come to us so they can crack on and do what they want. If they want to offer a freebie, they probably aren't set up in business quite yet, I don't begrudge them trying.

And, when we are training staff, trying new techniques etc we shoot families for free and provide high res images as a thank you.

L
 
I've got my friends wedding next year and will be looking for a second person to help out. A forum here where I could post would be good however a place for non-forum people could come in and ask for free stuff is not a great idea. If someone advertises they want to do one for free fair enough I think.

Perhaps this is the way to go. This may be the middle ground that is lacking. If it can be made easier for amateurs and pros to hook up for their mutal benefit - perhaps freebie wedding shoots will become less attractive to the inexperienced.
 
I'm with Hugh .... and yes I'm biased - and no I haven't read all the other pages - but how many of you doing other jobs would allow someone to offer to do the same work for free in its own section ... then you would become a bit insecure no doubt...

But apparently Wedding Pros' don't get afforded the same respect ...

People like me arent offering the same service that you are - but for free. I couldnt hope to offer what you do as part of your wedding package and my photography certainly isnt up to the required standard yet.

But if people really dont want to pay for a photographer (or cant afford one) - wouldnt I be silly not to offer in order to gain some experience. I have learnt so much just doing two weddings and I think it shows in the quality of pictures I have obtained between the first and second weddings.
 
There is a forum linking to here as a directory of "cheap photographers". I think this is an EXTREMELY bad development.

If it were me, I would use the technology available to DETECT those incoming hits from said forum, and redirect to a page which explains in full detail, just how difficult a job wedding photography is, and how much work goes into it. It should cover the cost of equipment, insurance, travel costs and transport requirements, the computers and web sites needing paid for, the marketing, the whole lot. Each and every visitor from that forum should be made to accept that they have read said document (some won't), and at least they can't claim to be surprised when their request for free professional photographers is laughed at. The words are bold for a reason.

Gary.

You don't do it very often Gary :p :D but every now and again
you come up with a good idea :thumbs:

One other ( I won't say last :D) thing
this is ( will be possibly maybe, be) 1 forum out of the other 30 odd, plus, sub forums
on TP.
Never before in the field of human conflict
during a "shall we create a new forum?" discussion

has it lasted so long or got so heated
and thats in the embryonic stage **** knows what will happen should it be allowed
to go beyond that.



 
as i've said before let them post in the wanted section with a mahoosive sticky of doom that warns them of impending death at the hands of the pros :D (i'd be tempted to stick a 10/20 post requirement to post on this section)

ideally an interrupt that displays a page when the words wedding and free are submitted with a disclaimer/readme and a [] tick here to continue box :)

i do think the idea of people being able to grab the odd test off this forum to help themselves into the market is great but there must be alternatives for those wanting to get further into wedding photography (like myself) that aren't going to be so destructive to the peace and tranquility of lake tp :)

at the end of the day the people you want using the forums are people that are going to give something back rather than just using and abusing...
 
I can't believe that any you aspiring wedding togs out there aren't already known to friends and family as a handy photographer (whether you are or not - that's their usual perception) and haven't been offered weddings already or even haven't done one or two. That's the way to get started. Doing weddings where you're known to most everyone there, is the most relaxing environment in which to make those early steps. If you want to take it further, it's simply a matter of putting your arse out there and getting known. The work will come by recommendations if you're any good at all. Nobody should have to work for nothing, but charge a rate commensurate with your level of experience and the standard of work you reasonably expect to produce in the early stages. People stating they are doing their first wedding next week and enquiring about the going rate for weddings in the area, frankly beggars belief.

Just get out there and do it, but make sure you know what you're doing before you take it on. It's not rocket science - you'll make your mistakes, but if you have the minimum level of photographic savvy it's unlikey to be disastrous and you'll learn as you go. I can't help but think that some of these people wanting to go the second shooter route are so inexperienced they're looking for a potted photography tuition course thrown in, in which case they're not ready anyway.

If you want to be a wedding tog, grow a pair of nads and go and do it on your own like thousands of others did before there was ever a worldwide web.;)
 
WHATS UP ARE WE NOT ALLOWED TO COMMENT ON MODS COMMENTS :shrug:

Its not rude and i didnt use it just to have a dig at someone its a fair enough comment as far as i am concerned. That "perfectly innocent comment" you say has been a line that i seem to have come acroos a lot latley from matty and all i was doing was expressing my opinions that its a forum about photography weather its wedding/portrait/horses or nude its photography and if some areas of photography create more heated discussions than others then i would of thought it was your (the sites) best interest to deal with it and not keep harping on about banning it and how fed up you are with it, its been said and suggested many times what to do with the subject so i suggest you read those suggestions.

Dave :thumbs:

wow. With the greatest respect, wtf are you on about. :cuckoo:

i said this:

Originally Posted by matty
thanks for all the opinions and comments, further discussions will be done in the staff room...


I havent locked the thread, i just said that we would talk about this idea more in the staff room. The staff room is the bit were the site staff, the people who run the forum, talk about stuff like this thread, its an idea, its not been well received - much like your post. Im not against wedding threads, im against the small minded **** stirring moronic ***** who ruin them, here is a little bit of info for you Studio, i LIKE wedding threads, they are informative and interesting, some of the people who post in them are not!
 
For what it's worth, I'm beginning to agree its not a good idea....

:agree: I think the separate wedding forum section seems to work ok. I just think some TP members need to curb the rude comments and either ignore or treat the request as they would a potential customer. I'm sure if someone approached them direct ie face to face they would not be so rude they would, I hope explain politely the reasons "freebies" can't be done.

My main concern earlier in the thread that the homepage might be inundated with these requests and as they provoke much discussion they push threads relating to the forum's real intention off this page which I and possible a lot of others use was the only reason for asking it to not appear on the main page not to ban or demote that part of very difficult photography to a back water forum.

Hope this clears up my stance on this ...... :shrug:

Paul
 
I hope explain politely the reasons "freebies" can't be done.
Yup. Tesco wont give me tick on my groceries, my garage wont give me a free MOT, the council wont wait for my tax payments, ditto HMRC. Phil Collins wont sing me a free and JK Rowling wont write me a free book, so I don't take free pictures. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top