Wedding photography and the recent requests for freebies...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why is recieving guided tuition a condition of exchanging services for mutual benefit?

I could spend £110 going on that staged wedding shoot that is advertised on the wedding forum. The OP of that thread has made it clear that it is not a course and doesnt contain any guided tuition. Ok you do have the added benefit of other pro's being there that you can chat to.

If a client wants to offer me the same service as above - but instead of charging me £110, simply asks for a copy of the images instead - what is the difference?

Sorry I dont really get your point.

What I will say is a live wedding is more benificial (cost and experience) than a staged wedding. So my £100 is therefore better value than your £110.
 
Because you lose out on the advice of those who are, after all your peers. You lose out on the guidance they offer, you lose out on the networking opportunites that could open the door to you shooting with them in the future. You lose out on having their phone number so you can call them and ask their opinion and you lose out on potentially profitable working relationships.

£110 for that as well as the images is a bargain. And it's why I will be there.

I do use staged shoot images as well as real live limages. All the stuff on my website is real life and some of the stuff in my sample albums is from exactly this kind of event. So long as i point out which are which to clients (and I do) then I see no problem at all with at least having them. Denying yourself these opportunities is a benefit how exaclty?

Who is denying the opportunity. I would have liked to have attended this event - but as I already said - I cant.
 
The difference is you can screw up on a staged shoot with no consequences - screw up on the real thing and you have a problem!

Not if all parties have agreed beforehand that they know what they're getting into...
 
Would it not be a better idea for pro's to offer positions for second shooter with pay or tuition rather than potentially putting someones wedding day at risk? This works very well on other forums.

It would - I agree. I started out thinking that was the way to go. I have approached several pros who were offering "assisting" positions and have never even had a reply.

I have also posted adverts asking for assisting positions and heard nothing (from the wedding side at least - I have done a few event assisting jobs).

I would happily stop shooting weddings for free if I could get an assisting position - any takers?
 
Also - I have seen pros complain about people using such shots in their portfolios as they do not represent a real wedding scenario.

If they have had no input to the shot then they cannot/should not display it as an example of their work.

Dont get me wrong about the workshop quoted its a very good idea for anyone wanting to get into weddings but at the end of the day how much will you learn from a day with no tuition?


If anyone wants to come with me on a real wedding and see how it works I'd be happy to take their £110. :thumbs: Plus the images would be of a real bride & groom .... fat or thin, tall and/or small, wind and/rain etc. ;)
 
It would - I agree. I started out thinking that was the way to go. I have approached several pros who were offering "assisting" positions and have never even had a reply.

I have also posted adverts asking for assisting positions and heard nothing (from the wedding side at least - I have done a few event assisting jobs).

I would happily stop shooting weddings for free if I could get an assisting position - any takers?

I have a small civil wedding on Saturday 5th Sept. Anyone wanting to come and watch/assist is welcome. First hand experience at a tricky location is priceless. First come first served as I can only offer to one person.
 
Dont get me wrong about the workshop quoted its a very good idea for anyone wanting to get into weddings but at the end of the day how much will you learn from a day with no tuition?

A whole bunch considering the people who ARE attending :D

Not so much people "wanting to get into" but a fair few who are doing it very sucessfuly.
 
It would - I agree. I started out thinking that was the way to go. I have approached several pros who were offering "assisting" positions and have never even had a reply.

I have also posted adverts asking for assisting positions and heard nothing (from the wedding side at least - I have done a few event assisting jobs).

I would happily stop shooting weddings for free if I could get an assisting position - any takers?

Unlikely - think: if Wedding Pro's are getting twitchy about the possibility of toggers on here offering to do weddings for free, what chance do you really have of getting one of them to actually train someone who'll be in direct competition with him on his own patch?

All this talk of courses, networking etc is just BS - it screams to me of insecure photographers who've cornered themselves into a niche market, terrified that their rice-bowl is about to taken away from them by hordes of lower-priced (or free) competition...

Diversify or die... and as I've said on other threads many, many times - if your images are good enough, you will survive...
 
My god, this still going on??

Why don't you all just live with the fact that there are some more confident than others who don't need 2 years worth of practice to jump in on their own and go for it.

All your arguments are ignoring the important aspects of natural ability and confidence. Someone lacking in both may need a couple of years of practice and training and still not be anywhere near as good as someone who's attended 1 wedding as a second and then goes in on their own.
 
All this talk of courses, networking etc is just BS - it screams to me of insecure photographers who've cornered themselves into a niche market, terrified that their rice-bowl is about to taken away from them by hordes of lower-priced (or free) competition...

Oh that's C*** Rob! I've just set up myself in January and without knowing the people I know and without their help, encouragement and assisance I'd have got absolutley nowhere and still be shooting for nothing!

Why make mistakes when you can learn from others who have walked in those shoes?
 
Unlikely - think: if Wedding Pro's are getting twitchy about the possibility of toggers on here offering to do weddings for free, what chance do you really have of getting one of them to actually train someone who'll be in direct competition with him on his own patch?

All this talk of courses, networking etc is just BS - it screams to me of insecure photographers who've cornered themselves into a niche market, terrified that their rice-bowl is about to taken away from them by hordes of lower-priced (or free) competition..

I agree to a point - however I think the threat of "freebie" wedding togs is really being overstated.

Nobody is going to shoot weddings for free - forever. The experience of shooting weddings will either put them off - or show them that it is the way to go and they'll start charging - just like everyone else.

People who want a freebie photographer are going to find a way - and I dont think these people were ever going to be on the radar of a paid pro. The ones I have done so far were simply going to get their mate who got a DSLR for Christmas to take a few snaps.
 
My god, this still going on??

All your arguments are ignoring the important aspects of natural ability and confidence.

And that is ignoring completely what goes into a good wedding shot. All the natural ablity confidence won't stop you making basic errors if you don't even know what the errors are.
 
I agree to a point - however I think the threat of "freebie" wedding togs is really being overstated.

Nobody is going to shoot weddings for free - forever. The experience of shooting weddings will either put them off - or show them that it is the way to go and they'll start charging - just like everyone else.

People who want a freebie photographer are going to find a way - and I dont think these people were ever going to be on the radar of a paid pro. The ones I have done so far were simply going to get their mate who got a DSLR for Christmas to take a few snaps.

I agree. I don't see the threat remotely. In fact, I think it is good overall for the industry as it gives people a chance to get started, get some images, and work and improve. I have more of a problem with people trying to charge others a few quid when they are stating from a base level of no experience whatsoever. Why would I pay someone to learn their job?

L
 
I agree. I don't see the threat remotely. In fact, I think it is good overall for the industry as it gives people a chance to get started, get some images, and work and improve. I have more of a problem with people trying to charge others a few quid when they are stating from a base level of no experience whatsoever. Why would I pay someone to learn their job?
L

Exactly how I approached it. I could not in good concience charge somebody for a potentially sub standard product. But to give them something that they wouldnt have otherwise got (i.e. on top of what they were planning to have) - then even if the shots arent great - they still gain, even if its simply a more comprehensive record of their day.
 
Oh that's C*** Rob! I've just set up myself in January and without knowing the people I know and without their help, encouragement and assisance I'd have got absolutley nowhere and still be shooting for nothing!

Why make mistakes when you can learn from others who have walked in those shoes?

Agreed, my earlier point about attending seminars, professional bodies and second shooting.Thats how I learned many years ago, although I dont recall anyone offering free weddings in those days. Possibly because eveything was shot on film and therefore had a cost and far more than a few pence for a CD.
 
I started doing weddings in my teens with no experience whatsoever. I can put my hand on my heart though, and say that while I was jumping in the deep end, I was at least confident in my own photographic ability to function under pressure. If you don't have that confidence in your own ability and a good grasp of photographic principals and technique, then it isn't a question of if you'll fark it up, but just a question of when and by how much.

That's what's wrong with this whole wedding trend thing on this board IMHO - we seem to be bending over backwards to accomodate people who want some magic wand painless formula to start out in wedding photography. The same people will no doubt be posting threads days and even hours before the wedding, asking how to use a flash and what mode the camera should be in. I don't think we should be encouraging this for one second.
 
That's what's wrong with this whole wedding trend thing on this board IMHO - we seem to be bending over backwards to accomodate people who want some magic wand painless formula to start out in wedding photography. The same people will no doubt be posting threads days and even hours before the wedding, asking how to use a flash and what mode the camera should be in. I don't think we should be encouraging this for one second.

What? I can't wait to see the results! :D


Oh, the Humanity!!!
 
I thought this was a well intentioned thread about creating a positive environment for all parties to have a mutually beneficial debate.

I was wrong.

It turns out to be a misguided and rather self righteous attempt to protect the dwindling business interests of a handful of professionals on here. They are going to have to learn to look after themselves.
 
I thought this was a well intentioned thread about creating a positive environment for all parties to have a mutually beneficial debate.

I was wrong.

It turns out to be a misguided and rather self righteous attempt to protect the dwindling business interests of a handful of professionals on here. They are going to have to learn to look after themselves.

:lol:

I so agree...
 
I agree. I don't see the threat remotely. In fact, I think it is good overall for the industry as it gives people a chance to get started, get some images, and work and improve.

As most couples only get married once each wedding is usually a oneoff event.If you dont get it then its gone, rather like an airplane seat.

If couples do decide to use "Uncle Bob" and he messes up then thats their problem. They are hardly likely to sue him are they?

Regarding experience, then how does a novice wedding shooter know how to improve if not told? Ok he may have (or not) a good eye and may see a mistake or an improvement but many do not unless told.


I have more of a problem with people trying to charge others a few quid when they are stating from a base level of no experience whatsoever. Why would I pay someone to learn their job?

You simply wouldnt. But would you pay someone (if you were a novice) with many years experience or maybe an award winning photograher or pay to attend a seminar ran by a professional body?
 
But snapzz, that is the couples decision to make, and hey, some people actually don't worry THAT much about their photos. Horses for courses, innit.

I would pay for seminars AND to get the experience of other photographers - just like we do in portraiture for the studio

L
 
Oh dear Hoppy you are not getting it, I'm actually trying to HELP those starting out and encourage them to do it the right way. That way nobody is going to end up getting sued.

If you listen to any of the trainers in the business they will tell you that one of their prime motivations for doing it (as well as being good business) is to try to raise the bar because there are genuine concerns about the level of photography on offer. Those trainers have recognised that there is a need for the fledgling pro to raise their game and thus get a foot on the ladder before they drown.

And I can look after myself quite nicely thank you, perhaps you would prefer if I didn't share any experiences and just kept my own council and let others drown? Which if you notice is exactly what is happening, how many of our resident pro togs even bother responding to wedding threads now?

I did say a few months back that I would stop responding to weddings threads myself perhaps it's time I took my own advice.
 
I did say a few months back that I would stop responding to weddings threads myself perhaps it's time I took my own advice.

Way to go - that's what we should all do. End of problem! :D
 
And that is ignoring completely what goes into a good wedding shot. All the natural ablity confidence won't stop you making basic errors if you don't even know what the errors are.

Sorry, I totally disagree. 70% of a "good" wedding shot is the natural ability to spot or setup the shot creatively. Otherwise you get very ordinary shots, however well exposed.

The technical side of photography is learned, and it's implied that if you're starting to shoot weddings, you'll have the basics of exposure already.
 
yeah and those "What settings should I use" threads can go away too :)
 
Oh dear Hoppy you are not getting it, I'm actually trying to HELP those starting out and encourage them to do it the right way.

What makes you the authority on "the right way"? :shrug:
 
Sorry, I totally disagree. 70% of a "good" wedding shot is the natural ability to spot or setup the shot creatively. Otherwise you get very ordinary shots, however well exposed.

The technical side of photography is learned, and it's implied that if you're starting to shoot weddings, you'll have the basics of exposure already.

Really? Have you seen some of the underexposed poorly composed stuff that has been on offer recently!

How many mashed faces have we seen where people don't know how to shoot a couple kissing?

White balance errors?

Bad cropping?

All basic stuff, all posted on here. It's a heck of an implication!
 
What makes you the authority on "the right way"? :shrug:

Having set up my own business doing it!

Which is more than most of the people questioning my intentions have ever done. Being a member of several professional organisations.

NOT being sued.

And you?
 
I'm not going to waste any more of my time on people who are only here to stir and cause an arguement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top