Thats a very strong image - well composed and thought out.![]()
Very simple, very striking. Great job, well done.
Nice one Andy.![]()
Yes, certainly on theme Andy, no 'ish' about it IMHO.
A minimalist feel to the image but very effective. I never saw the original but this edited version is technically very good, I don't really have any crit to add. Cheers![]()
Andy another cracking image.
look forward to your rustic shot now
Greed....Simple and very effective with a small explanation to show your weakness, I agree it would look good printed large.
Angle...Red White and Blue, should have posted it on St Georges day, nicely done and something I need to have a go at.
![]()
Hi ya matey
Angles...cold even begin to crit that shot as have never managed to do a smoke trail
Like it very much , nice simple layout, great colors...yup![]()
Great work with the smoke art - looking really bright against the black.
I can see the angle - no problems there.
Red, white and Blue working really well too.![]()
Nicely caught smoke trails nice BG whats not to like well I perhaps would have liked to see them closer together to bring the crop into more of a portrait size rather than square![]()
Greed: You can never have to many toys, or so my oh likes to think!!
Angles: Great shot, very eye catching!
That's really nice!
The detail and DOF in panels 1 & 2, and then the 3rd panel sort of tying them together. Bang on theme too, rustic with extra rust!
The only suggestion I would make is that, for me, the red/pink tones are a little much in the middle panel, when compared to the other two.
Nice idea Andy. I have a similar idea - funny how some subjects seem to lend themselves to multiple images.
Good detail and dof on them all and a good range of tones. I agree with Nick that the central one is a bit pink in comparison.
Good inclusion of vegetation on #3 and i quite like the use of the 'torn paper' frame - all on theme.
Nice one![]()
Rustic, and suits the triptych. nothing to fault at all there, really like it.
![]()
Hi
Like your rusty rustic shots. Good idea to put three together to get different views.
I like your rustic tryptic Andy, it looks like a great subject which has a lot of photographic potential. You must have been spoilt for choice on the detail shots?
I particularly like the colour tones, they have a warm feel about them which I feel adds to the theme. Good work matey![]()
Hi ya matey
Rustic.....lovely olde worlde feel to it , nice warm tones , great framing & use of tryptich...wonder what a contrasty B&W would like
![]()
Very rusty...rusticnice details and dof in the first 2, I would have like to see a much wider shot though showing it and it's location.
Thought of a wider shot but it was so overgrown you would'd see much![]()
Our very on DD always carries a knife to do a bit of trimming if necessary although it sound like you might have needed a flame thrower.
BTW the B&W look great too.
Have to say I prefer the B+W the colour seems a bit too light for me nice triptych really works well. I also saw your flower pic for the 12 challenge very nice![]()
Hi Andy
Rustic - Very nice mate, love the colours, a real nice set![]()
Rustic: WOW. Excellent, I prefer the B&W.
I wish I could do that 3 images in one thing, I never seem to be able to do it to my satisfaction. Any tips?
great rusty rustic triptych there andy - great details spotted and captured on all three panes.... initially thought the first could do with a slightly greater DOF, but looking again thinks its pretty much spot on.
It is tricky keeping all the colours the same across the three frames, the middle is a bit pinky, much prefer the colour one out of the two, the greens could come down a little for me, but as it was sunny that's probably how they were, so...![]()
Great triptych, all go together well and love the colours.
I like the b&w but think the colour one edges it in this one.
Hi Andy,
I think your kind is close to being on theme but feel it just needs a little something else to make it home. Perhaps a pair of hands applying the plaster to show the act of kindness
I do like the lowkey(ish) feel to the image with the eye drawn to the plaster which is well lit.
Post and be damned![]()
I'm not sure what I think, theme-wise, but I like the shot. The DOF falls off really gently and the plaster really jumps out.
Cheers, Nick, crowbar is the word you're looking for![]()
It was a tough theme!
As I look through the threads I find it's very much a secondary consideration for me, a good pic is a good pic.
Kind, Like the lighting in this one, might be tempted to crop above the sock?
Rustic, I like the triptych, great subject choice and I like the b+w
Angles, Great colours in the smoke! Must try this! What was your setup?
Greed, Interesting take on the theme I like it,
Joker, lovely shot of the shell, great colour and nice bg
Tacky, made me laugh
direction number 5 is my fave out of your choices, dof is just right.
electric, prefer the colour version, I like the richness of the colour.