Too lazy to remove a crisp packet and cloning out out = sloppy
Seagull ruining an otherwise great shot and cloning out = what's the problem?
Then again.. crisp packet on other side of a fence.... sod it.. clone it out.
Hardly a big deal.
When retouching/processing attempts to make up for lack of photographic talent, that's when it's really sloppy. When it attempts to make an otherwise mundane shot more exciting.. that's beyond sloppy... that means you're not even a photographer IMO.
If there is rubbish and crap all all over the floor in a landscape shot... maybe it should stay in as a comment about the dissonance between our romanticised ideals about "nature" and the "natural" world and the reality of what we actually have.
I think I'll start taking landscape shots... chocolate box pretty, gushing with sentimentality... but include the crap and rubbish usually seen at places of "outstanding natural beauty". I reckon that would be interesting... and as an added bonus, would freak the a lot of the OCD types out