Jonathan and welcome back to the 52 !!!
Really pleased to see Simon getting in here as your first shot of the year.
As I said to you last year I'd be happy to see Simon every week and I wouldn't care whether it was off theme or a really rubbish photo . . . he's just so cute that you could get away with anything with him
As it happens though, this is perfectly on theme and a really good photo too
Good focus on the eye, brilliant control of DoF and a lovely profile shot. It does have that RSPCA poster feel, but he looks far too well looked after and relaxed to be in a kennel.
The only thing that I'd watch out for in future is the position of the out of focus foreground bars. One of the horizontal ones seems to be crossing just across the top of his eye and it's spoiling that pin sharp focus you'd managed to get.
Week 2 : I'd never heard of Oscar Peterson, but it looks like a fascinating statue and some brilliant curves to be able to photograph.
Personally, I think you were right with your first instinct and the shot you chose the first time. The curve of the piano has much more impact at this angle - it really draws you in and gives a more intimate feel to the photograph.
Yes the cropped foot is slightly irritating, but the curve is so effective at drawing my eye towards his arms that I hardly notice it.