Phil
Unattractive, an interesting take on the theme, nice colours and dof works. Highlights in background a bit distracting.
Shadow, I think that would have been better than your unattractive shot.There are shadows which are better in the flickr version.
Beautiful. To taste maybe, but not as displayed. most of the detail is not in sharp focus.
Low, Nice Image with good colours in the sky and water. Cropping parts of the boats in the foreground may have been handled better.
Music, Good Image there, lots of action going on in his face and position. Good light.
Creatures, well focused Image on that criiter. Don't know what the green bits are.
Pete