It‘s always difficult to decide if people are being ‘wise after the event’ in these cases, especially where there are so many mobile elements. I’m not sure it matters if there’s an element of serendipity as the skill comes in recognising/selecting the shot as well as the planning. Abel says he “had to decide whether to leave the red bucket in” and I don’t see how that can be an accurate description of the process since the bucket is going out of shot. It might be true that he spotted the red bucket ‘liked it’ and fired the shutter but it can’t have been a “leave it in or leave it out decision” unless he was reviewing a series of shots, much as you/we are doing in this thread.
Abel’s is a great shot which does seem to pop up everywhere but I think it’s more the case that he was doing all the right things and looking for a composition like that and was lucky it all came together that day … unless of course he staged the whole thing and had that guy with the red bucket walking back & forth all day
.
I wonder if the two cows in the background are the mothers — now that would be hard to stage!