Wedding photography and the recent requests for freebies...

Status
Not open for further replies.
You think so?
No really, Im not being picky, my interest in wedding photography is quite new, and Im not sure whether it will be serious one, so all this is pretty new to me.

What I am sure of though, is that when people are spending an awful lot of money on something, they tend to look for places to cut corners, and from what Ive heard/seen, with weddings the photography appears to be one such cut.

Im not talking high end weddings, where the monied can afford not to worry, but how long will it be before the midstream brides cotton on and come up with a sob story as to why they cant afford a photographer.


By assisting another photographer.
As AliB said, networking is the key is it not?
Photography clubs, friends, contacting other jobbing wedding togs and asking if they need/will let you help.

Im not sure Im quite making my point here. Im NOT against anyone doing a freebie wedding, but I am against promoting it, and IMO a section dedicated to it on TP is doing just that.

Well, yes I do think so, and this is borne of frequenting wedding forums. People offering their services for free get a limited response - most people DO put their pics as a prioirity and WILL pay for them.
There will always be people looking for a bargain, and I think that's a good thing, for the people who are just starting out.

L
 
I think the thing that has shocked me so much about all of this is the reaction to 'freebies'. I'm sure I read a thread on here recently which had some extremely helpful info in it (not to say that lots of TP threads are not useful). The thing about this post and it related to business was that an offer of a limited offer of 'free' service was actually a success financially as it brought in additional revenue. Offers of 'freebies' happen in business that does not mean they are always bad thing.

Paul
 
By assisting another photographer.
As AliB said, networking is the key is it not?
Photography clubs, friends, contacting other jobbing wedding togs and asking if they need/will let you help.

Im not sure Im quite making my point here. Im NOT against anyone doing a freebie wedding, but I am against promoting it, and IMO a section dedicated to it on TP is doing just that.

Fair enough - but I still think its catch 22 based on my experience so far. Better to try and get something together that I can market myself to pros with.

I see what you are saying about a dedicated forum for this kind of stuff - and I agree it shouldnt be neccesary - but its formation was prompted by the rather cold response the OP's of the now infamous threads got when making enquiries.

If the people who were not interested had simply kept it to themselves we wouldnt be having this conversation. As it stands - these topics got far more publicity both here and elesewhere than they ever should have.
 
Offers of 'freebies' happen in business that does not mean they are always bad thing.

I agree. I bet everyone here has a friend or family member that knows computers, can tile, plaster, do a bit of plumbing, knock up a dress or a cake - or even........... take a decent photo.

When we call on such peoples services do we consider the damage we are doing to these trades?

I myself have done PC worlds "help desk" out of thousands of pounds as I am usually the first port of call for any family related IT issues.
 
Asking/expecting help from a close friend or family member is a whole different world.
 
Because I did my neices wedding for now`t as she is family,I sure as hell wouldn`t do a complete strangers for now`t.

Just my way of eeking out an existance...........:)
 
Anyway, it is clear that some people have no appetite for robust and frank debate, well the mods at least, but since they daren't ban it, hide it somewhere obscure and hope it goes away. Which stikes me as a bit strange on an open forum, but there you go.

Of course we have an appetite for robust and frank debate. :)
Disagreeing doesn't mean we're not open to member input and opinion. That's why this thread was created in the first place :thinking:

Nor is it a question of daring to ban it. We own the forum, if we wanted to ban it we would! Just banning the topic would have no benefit to anyone. This can open up some good opportunities for an amateur to get some valuable experience. That's why we don't *want* to ban it.
As for hiding it away somewhere obscure. We don't want it to be a big attraction for fear of it becoming too popular with wedding parties (See previous concerns mentioned by others). A small, allowable controlled environment is what we propose to do. Where do you think it should go, as a main forum in the listing? I personally don't feel it should, one for the aforementioned reasons of us not wanting it to be a popular attraction. Nor will it be anywhere near busy enough to warrant taking up front forum real-estate.

I can assure you we're listening to all concerns raised. Since day one we've been about getting members input on things, but unfortunately we can't please everyone all of the time.
Sure, at the end of the day we admins will make the decision whether it goes ahead or not, but we will take on board the concensus and opinions of the members, and we are listening.
 
:agree: I think you mods do a great job, which is why I continue to enjoy being part of TP even when some try to spoil it for others.

:3 cheers smilie: for the mods.

Paul
 
However, we won't allow our members to be exploited as an avenue to get 'freebies' just for the sake of it.

My opinion, for what it's worth, is the more you try to regulate it with rules the more you're going to end up with something messy. Surely you just need to step back to a basic question - do you allow these kind of requests or not. And working on the basis you that you will, you must then decide how to accomodate them. I would have thought a forum open to all and demanding intelligent non-abusive on-topic posts with a disclaimer from TP and some heavy post deleting by the mods as required would suffice?

As for protecting members from being exploited, thanks but I can manage that for myself guys, as can most folks here I suspect.

Personally I say keep it simple if you do this. However, I'm not sure this is a move i'd agree with. I do like being given an opportunity to comment on it though! :thumbs:
 
I would have thought a forum open to all and demanding intelligent non-abusive on-topic posts with a disclaimer from TP and some heavy post deleting by the mods as required would suffice?

It seems I'm being misunderstood I think. That's exactly how I propose we do it. Open to all, but with guidelines and a disclaimer, and with sensible moderation.

When I say we won't allow our members to be exploited, we won't be getting involved in any of the agreements or deals at all. It will be through the structure of the forum and the requests, and the ensuing moderation should it be required....that's all ;)

I've edited the line in the first post to be clearer
However, we won't allow our members community to be exploited as an easy avenue to get 'freebies' just for the sake of it.
 
It seems I'm being misunderstood I think. That's exactly how I propose we do it. Open to all, but with guidelines and a disclaimer, and with sensible moderation.

When I say we won't allow our members to be exploited, we won't be getting involved in any of the agreements or deals at all. It will be through the structure of the forum and the requests, and the ensuing moderation should it be required....that's all ;)

I've edited the line in the first post to be clearer

Quote: Marcel
"However, we won't allow our community to be exploited as an easy avenue to get 'freebies' just for the sake of it."

But that's just the point Marcel. If the community wants to be 'exploited' as you put it, and clearly some members are quite keen for this to happen when it suits them, then why not let them?

Just delete that last sentence and the warriors for free speech will probably be happy. I will be (if you're bothered ;) :D ).
 
if someone wants a wedding photographer free or not they can post in the wanted section :D

IMHO basically the forum is changing from what was a forum into what should now be a website, the more you try and cater for the more messed up your navigation/forum and main aims are going to be.

dunno if you've got one but a simple mission statement drawn up by the head honchos without thinking about anything anyone wants apart from the simple forum direction would be my suggestion and then see what fits in with that.

as you've said you can't please everyone all the time and you can't do everything all the time.

couldn't be arsed to read the full lot of this but scanned to try and get a jist, apologies if my above post is moot :D

+2p
 
Hopefully, putting the 'Trolling For Cheap/Free Togs' into a seprate section will reduce the amount of arguments I get involved in as I can just stay out of that section altogether...
Let's hope others who have as much difficulty as I do in keeping my opinions to myself will do likewise...

If you fancy a bit of work-experience, dip in and have a look, if not then you can Stay Out...

Seems pretty simple to me...

absolutely spot on !
 
Because I did my neices wedding for now`t as she is family,I sure as hell wouldn`t do a complete strangers for now`t.

Just my way of eeking out an existance...........:)

I agree with this line of thought. I am not saying that no photographer should ever do a "freebie", but there is a danger that you may never move away from that. If it is a hobby and you are well off, then that is not a problem, but it will impact on the industry if too many people do it. I have done two weddings - one for a niece a couple of years ago, and one for a friend, who liked the results, but was very demanding on the day, and afterwards.
As I have said on another post, the friend has recommended me to a friend of his wife, and suggested that I may do the job purely for experience - thanks, but no thanks. I have not even been given a chance to set out any terms and conditions. I am sure that a lot of people think that modern wedding photography just involves shooting as many images on auto as you can, and then handing the unedited disc over to the happy couple - job done! I suppose you could do that, and then wait for the next person to come along and expect the same treatment.
In the short time I have been here, I have browsed through the portrait section, and seen some stunning wedding photography, much better than I can produce at the moment, but I wonder, how much of it was done for free?
 
I've been quite busy lately so only just stumbled across this post.

Firstly I cant believe it took 28 replies before someone objected to this idea. I've been shooting wedding for 25 rears and never covered one for free. When I first started I attended seminars and joined professional bodies just to learn what to do and what I needed to do it with.

As a mod on another forum recently I read about a "freebie" wedding that turned sour to such a point solicitors had got involved. The poor(?) photographer didn't know what to do in the end as the bride seemed to want more and more. I have no idea about the quality of photography or how the day was organised for the wedding but clearly there is now confusion which has cost both parties.

If any amateur is looking to start covering weddings then shooting for free is definitely not the way to go. Far too many mistakes will/can be made and on a day that cannot be rectified.

How would you like it if receiving a phone call from your day job telling you not to come in next week as someone has offered a weeks work for free? Well if no one worked for free then this would not happen and couples would have to pay for their photography or go without. You never hear of cars or suites or florists offering their services for free so why should photographers? If you dont have the experience then dont do it until you do. However I have no objection to second shooting for free. This works both ways for you and the photographer plus you learn correctly and under supervision and he received additional cover. Only a couple of months ago I offered someone on this forum the chance to "tag" along on a wedding just to get the feel of how it was done.

There are of course a few "must haves" before shooting any live events. Camera insurance, PL insurance and PI insurance. Having the correct equipment plus sufficient back up bodies,lenses etc. Preparation before the day is vital then the simple job (for which you are paid for) is knowing what and where to shoot. Posing for formals, posing for "candids" and actual candids. Even today I see simple mistakes that P/T and even so called full time pro's make simply because they don't see what they are looking at.

The idea of of this site offering free weddings to unexperienced amateurs is in my opinion unthinkable. If anyone wants to learn to shoot weddings then do it correctly and hopefully no ones day will be ruined and doesnt end with a court case.
 
I have to agree with Graham - if this 'service' takes off it will be a recipe for tears sooner or later.
 
I can assure you we're listening to all concerns raised. Since day one we've been about getting members input on things, but unfortunately we can't please everyone all of the time.

:clap:

Exactly - you are taking the time to ask what the members think and as is always the case people will have differing views and thats because vaiety is the spice of life - if we all thought exactly the same what a boring place this would be.

Personally I find TP to be one of the friendliest forums relating to photography on the internet. I have dabbled in others but I find that they can be very standoffish and unless you know all the jargon, have the best equipment and take amazing photographs they don't want to know. This place is very beginner friendly and everyone seems to get on well and thats why I come back here and not to the others.

I think you are doing a great job :)

This issue always cause a debate just because the whole freebie thing always does!
 
good to see everyone has an opinion...snapzz did you read the proposed guidelines? the reasons are simple, we dont want to stop people asking for help, and some folk want to do it to help and get experience..
 
good to see everyone has an opinion...snapzz did you read the proposed guidelines? the reasons are simple, we dont want to stop people asking for help, and some folk want to do it to help and get experience..

Yes I did read but still dissagree with the idea. This year church wedding bookings have been reported to be the lowest since records began and weddings in general at their lowest since the 60's. Everyone if fighting for their share of this market but pro's cannot compete with freebies.Please remember it is our living, we have no other job. If a couple decide they cannot afford a professional and decide to go without then that is their decision. These days they know they can advertise for someone free and will continue to do so untill the practice stops.
 
I've been quite busy lately so only just stumbled across this post.

Firstly I cant believe it took 28 replies before someone objected to this idea. I've been shooting wedding for 25 rears and never covered one for free. When I first started I attended seminars and joined professional bodies just to learn what to do and what I needed to do it with.

As a mod on another forum recently I read about a "freebie" wedding that turned sour to such a point solicitors had got involved. The poor(?) photographer didn't know what to do in the end as the bride seemed to want more and more. I have no idea about the quality of photography or how the day was organised for the wedding but clearly there is now confusion which has cost both parties.

If any amateur is looking to start covering weddings then shooting for free is definitely not the way to go. Far too many mistakes will/can be made and on a day that cannot be rectified.

How would you like it if receiving a phone call from your day job telling you not to come in next week as someone has offered a weeks work for free? Well if no one worked for free then this would not happen and couples would have to pay for their photography or go without. You never hear of cars or suites or florists offering their services for free so why should photographers? If you dont have the experience then dont do it until you do. However I have no objection to second shooting for free. This works both ways for you and the photographer plus you learn correctly and under supervision and he received additional cover. Only a couple of months ago I offered someone on this forum the chance to "tag" along on a wedding just to get the feel of how it was done.

There are of course a few "must haves" before shooting any live events. Camera insurance, PL insurance and PI insurance. Having the correct equipment plus sufficient back up bodies,lenses etc. Preparation before the day is vital then the simple job (for which you are paid for) is knowing what and where to shoot. Posing for formals, posing for "candids" and actual candids. Even today I see simple mistakes that P/T and even so called full time pro's make simply because they don't see what they are looking at.

The idea of of this site offering free weddings to unexperienced amateurs is in my opinion unthinkable. If anyone wants to learn to shoot weddings then do it correctly and hopefully no ones day will be ruined and doesnt end with a court case.

Sorry Graham - but although I hear what you're saying, much of it just smacks of protectionism to me...
A lot of what you're saying here is relevant if you're a Pro, but not for the amateur photographer hoping to get 'some' nice images...as long as the client knows what they're getting in advance...

This seems to be the key bit that everyone here is ignoring - as long as both parties are aware of what they're getting into, then where is the problem? Get them to sign a waiver before the wedding to this effect...

If a client comes here looking for a 'freebie' or even a 'cheapie'-photographer, but is really hoping for 'professional-quality' images then we should be able to steer them towards hiring a professional - hopefully someone on this Forum...

Maybe by educating them gently and politely that their original expectations were a little... unrealistic and that to get a 'proper' job done they need to spend a bit of cash...

If they're genuinely not concerned then it's all good - either way, the members of this Forum win - either someone gets to shoot a wedding for the experience for nothing and hopefully gets some decent imagery, or a pro-Wedding photographer again from this forum, gets the referral...
 
Yes I did read but still dissagree with the idea. This year church wedding bookings have been reported to be the lowest since records began and weddings in general at their lowest since the 60's. Everyone if fighting for their share of this market but pro's cannot compete with freebies.Please remember it is our living, we have no other job. If a couple decide they cannot afford a professional and decide to go without then that is their decision. These days they know they can advertise for someone free and will continue to do so untill the practice stops.

I think it's safe to assume that bookings are on the decline because there is a recession on and maybe it's not due the influx of amateurs offering freebies?

Many talented pro's here (I am not one of them) do not and will not feel threatened by amateurs.

Sorry Graham - but although I hear what you're saying, much of it just smacks of protectionism to me...
A lot of what you're saying here is relevant if you're a Pro, but not for the amateur photographer hoping to get 'some' nice images...as long as the client knows what they're getting in advance...

This seems to be the key bit that everyone here is ignoring - as long as both parties are aware of what they're getting into, then where is the problem? Get them to sign a waiver before the wedding to this effect...

If a client comes here looking for a 'freebie' or even a 'cheapie'-photographer, but is really hoping for 'professional-quality' images then we should be able to steer them towards hiring a professional - hopefully someone on this Forum...

Maybe by educating them gently and politely that their original expectations were a little... unrealistic and that to get a 'proper' job done they need to spend a bit of cash...

If they're genuinely not concerned then it's all good - either way, the members of this Forum win - either someone gets to shoot a wedding for the experience for nothing and hopefully gets some decent imagery, or a pro-Wedding photographer again from this forum, gets the referral...

Good points Rob. :thumbs:
 
However I have no objection to second shooting for free. This works both ways for you and the photographer plus you learn correctly and under supervision and he received additional cover.

Honestly - I think this sums up perfectly why some pros are opposed to this idea.

Why does your own argument of "You never hear of cars or suites or florists offering their services for free so why should photographers?" not apply in this instance.
 
Sorry Graham - but although I hear what you're saying, much of it just smacks of protectionism to me...

Er yes as it is my living!


A lot of what you're saying here is relevant if you're a Pro

Thats because its my living!

but not for the amateur photographer hoping to get 'some' nice images

Covering a wedding is not about "getting some nice images" its about creating a series of consitantly good images that tell the story of the day.
Its also about knowing what to do and where to do it. Its about knowing how to get the best from a couple and their guests in a short space of time that will provide happy memories for the rest of their married lives.
 
This seems to be the key bit that everyone here is ignoring - as long as both parties are aware of what they're getting into, then where is the problem? Get them to sign a waiver before the wedding to this effect...

This is the key. I made my clients sign a two page contract making it absolutely clear that I had very little experience. Here is the key part:

The couple agree that they do not consider the photographers to be an alternative to a paid professional photographer. The couple understands that at this point in time the photographers have limited experience in wedding photography and as such cannot guarantee the quality (both aesthetically or technically) of any images supplied. The couple agree that, after viewing examples of the photographers work, they have of their own volition chosen to request the services of the photographers.
 
Honestly - I think this sums up perfectly why some pros are opposed to this idea.

Why does your own argument of "You never hear of cars or suites or florists offering their services for free so why should photographers?" not apply in this instance.

Because this balances its self out.

To put another way suppose I charge £100 fee for offering live tuition and as I'm intending to use some of their images £100 second shooter.
 
I think you also have to consider the crossover between amateur and pro. After all why are the amateurs shooting weddings? Usually it's with the aim of getting images so they CAN turn pro. And if it is the expectation of the couple in question that they will be recieving pro levels of service with all that entails then there is a tidal wave of trouble coming. How many amateurs know how to put together an album, are registered with the album suppliers, know how to use the software and can deliver on the finished product? It's not just turning up on the day and taking a few nice pics. There is months of work involved in setting up to deliver anything like a proper service.

I do worry about the expectation levels of those requesting this from members and I honestly think Matty should put a post on that wedding forum stating quite clearly that professional service levels cannot be guaranteed.

Snapzz makes a very good point though, if you want to become a pro, do it pro. Go and learn by joining professional organisations, undertake training and second shoot. Which is pretty much what I have been saying all along.
 
Because this balances its self out.

To put another way suppose I charge £100 fee for offering live tuition and as I'm intending to use some of their images £100 second shooter.

But that argument works for clients too. They are offering up their wedding to an amateur who wants to shoot (we see that happening with staged weddings all the time - there is even a thread on the wedding forum about it).

And as payment - they get a disc containing the images I obtained.
 
I think it's safe to assume that bookings are on the decline because there is a recession on and maybe it's not due the influx of amateurs offering freebies?

Times have changed and so have couples attitudes towards getting married. When I first started couples got married then moved in to their new home. Today nearly all couples already have an established home and most already have children.

(quote)Many talented pro's here (I am not one of them) do not and will not feel threatened by amateurs.(/quote)

Everyone I speak to is agreeing bookings are down. Digital have changed many things and the way we cover weddings as well as couples requirements.
 
But that argument works for clients too. They are offering up their wedding to an amateur who wants to shoot (we see that happening with staged weddings all the time - there is even a thread on the wedding forum about it).

And as payment - they get a disc containing the images I obtained.

But it doesnt as the photographer is not receiving any guided tuition.
 
Snapzz makes a very good point though, if you want to become a pro, do it pro. Go and learn by joining professional organisations, undertake training and second shoot. Which is pretty much what I have been saying all along.

There are different ways of achieving the same things. Your points are valid and from my point of view:

1. I intend to and have the application forms here.
2. I have.
3. Easier said than done for reasons I have already outlined ad nauseum.

I am simply replacing point 3 and shooting on my own instead.
 
There are different ways of achieving the same things. Your points are valid and from my point of view:

1. I intend to and have the application forms here.
2. I have.
3. Easier said than done for reasons I have already outlined ad nauseum.

I am simply replacing point 3 and shooting on my own instead.

Would it not be a better idea for pro's to offer positions for second shooter with pay or tuition rather than potentially putting someones wedding day at risk? This works very well on other forums.
 
There was a post here on TP yesterday about a wedding workshop

http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?t=159817

The chance to attend a top notch venue and shoot some classic images with everything laid on. Minimal cost compared to anything I've ever come across.

How many of those who constantly bemoan the fact that you need to shoot weddings for free to get portfolio images even bothered to reply to that thread?

It's what I've been banging on about all the way through this debate. If you want to do this seriously then there was a prime chance to network and fill a CF card full of goodies.
 
But it doesnt as the photographer is not receiving any guided tuition.

Why is recieving guided tuition a condition of exchanging services for mutual benefit?

I could spend £110 going on that staged wedding shoot that is advertised on the wedding forum. The OP of that thread has made it clear that it is not a course and doesnt contain any guided tuition. Ok you do have the added benefit of other pro's being there that you can chat to.

If a client wants to offer me the same service as above - but instead of charging me £110, simply asks for a copy of the images instead - what is the difference?
 
The difference is you can screw up on a staged shoot with no consequences - screw up on the real thing and you have a problem!
 
How many of those who constantly bemoan the fact that you need to shoot weddings for free to get portfolio images even bothered to reply to that thread?

It's what I've been banging on about all the way through this debate. If you want to do this seriously then there was a prime chance to network and fill a CF card full of goodies.

Ok - so the fact that we havent replied to that thread means we havent looked into it. I looked at it with great interest - but unfortunately due to work and personal commitments, I cannot attend on that date. If it will make you happy - i'll go over there and state as much.

Also - I have seen pros complain about people using such shots in their portfolios as they do not represent a real wedding scenario.
 
Because you lose out on the advice of those who are, after all your peers. You lose out on the guidance they offer, you lose out on the networking opportunites that could open the door to you shooting with them in the future. You lose out on having their phone number so you can call them and ask their opinion and you lose out on potentially profitable working relationships.

£110 for that as well as the images is a bargain. And it's why I will be there.

I do use staged shoot images as well as real live images. All the stuff on my website is real life and some of the stuff in my sample albums is from exactly this kind of event. So long as i point out which are which to clients (and I do) then I see no problem at all with at least having them. Denying yourself these opportunities is a benefit how exactly?

You also gain to opportunity to use some different techniques that you might have picked up on but dare not risk on a live wedding. Something that obviously does not concern some though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top