Street Photography - what's it all about?

I'm also intrigued by the assertion that it has to be up close and personal, 50mm or less presumably, as a 200mm shot isn't street photography apparently. So if you're that close - do you ask to take someone's photo? Or just shoot it anyway and wait for the 'What the f-ing Hell are you doing?' comments???

DD

Street is street @ 200mm or 50mm, its true, the closer you are with 50mm, the more involved you as the tog and the viewer feels.
The best street shooters have a method, an art, a way to disappear as they shoot, or they "ask" with a nod an expression...body language, some use words, some don't.
Its not easy, I've tried it and I cant do it with a big ole SLR.
Watch Joel.
Ok, Tadcaster on a Wednesday night isn't NewYork, but the same principles apply
 
Agreed. Thats why the purists use a range finder. Its easier to blend in with that than a 30D + grip + 24-70 + hood. May as well wear a pink flag and quack.
 
Agreed. Thats why the purists use a range finder. Its easier to blend in with that than a 30D + grip + 24-70 + hood. May as well wear a pink flag and quack.

Hmmm - so Pete - a D2Xs and 20mm f1.8 is a big beast - where do you recommend for the duck outfit?

Surely you're not saying if you're 'seen' to be doing SP it doesn't count?

DD
 
Probably the best example of street photography I have ever seen.

LINK

Try and get that in a studio environment.
 
BB - excellent link - he has some fantastic shots.

But ........ I'm not so sure that's street photography in the way that DD was meaning. They're more like portraits taken outside. Stunning nevertheless, but he takes the time to speak to his subjects and gets to know something about them. Then he takes their photo (at least as I understand his methods)

As I understand the phrase "street photography" its about un-posed, un-rehearsed moments. Generally of people you don't know.

And as I'm typing this, I can see that I'm potentially opening up a debate that isn't necessary (ie the definition of SP) and is one that I don't really want to get into. So BB, please don't take this as an argument with you or your post above.

I'd like to make one comment on DD's original post, and again, this isn't meant to be confrontational, just an answer to his question - namely (to paraphrase) SP is boring, requires no compositional skills and is little more than a snap.

Which is where I disagree. A good photo always has good composition. That's why we are drawn to it - maybe sub-consciously, but we are. Whether it be lead in lines, or lead out lines, or rule of thirds, or whatever it is - a good photo will make you look again.

It can be analysed technically if you wish.

And, on a personal note, I think street photography is bloody difficult. Its a real challenge. And I'm impressed that DD is going to have a go.
 
so if those people were taken into a studio a decent tog wouldnt be able to get the same result? i think they would.

Natural light is the effect he gets. And the moment. Those pics would never work in a studio. It couldn't be done.
 
I think there's nothng wrong with street photography. In some ways it's a good way of recording society and how it changes over the years. Blimey I sound like a sociologist now!!
 
BB - excellent link - he has some fantastic shots.

But ........ I'm not so sure that's street photography in the way that DD was meaning. They're more like portraits taken outside. Stunning nevertheless, but he takes the time to speak to his subjects and gets to know something about them. Then he takes their photo (at least as I understand his methods)


Exactly MV, this is a great portrait which may or may not be in a street. Backgrounds, buildings or otherwise, are easy in insert if needed so I'm sure a close copy of this shot could be done in a studio. But other than this being a great photo - is says nothing about the man or his environment, which many here say is the point of SP. Without reading he's homeless, how could you tell?

Thanks Idwallis - I'm sure there's more of us hereabouts, others not saying so for whatever reason


Current plan then... Barnsley market this Wednesday afternoon (weather/work permitting)...

Quick question... re the stall-holders - do I just shoot images or do I ask them if I can? [I don't mean so they stand there and smile sweetly at me, I mean that at some point I take pics with them in it]

:help::shrug::help:

DD
 
I love using the markets for SP, never asked a stall holder (or anyone else for that matter) for permission to take a pic yet, and never had a problem. Some I get a smile off if they see me, most just carry on with more important things, ie selling their stuff.

Edit: Have had one or two pose with their stock after they see I've taken a shot, and ask me to re-take it, guess they're thinking 'free advertising.' :)
 
The photo of the homless guy isn't street photography. That guy simply takes portraits. As for inserting buildings, for shame :p
 
re : my link.

I can see where your comming from about it not being 'proper' SP and more just a portrait of a homeless guy.

But I do still see it as a form of SP, only not 'candid' SP, which is the difference here.

I just thought I'd throw that tog's work into the equation as its another form of SP.

DD, you say you cant see anything about the man and his environment in that shot. To me that shot screams out the emotions of that man, even without the story I can feel what he must be feeling. So there must be something in it.

Anyways, Good luck on Wednesday and please do let us know how you got on !!

Its not as easy as it looks.. take that from a NON expert..
 
I think its like this. Its as much street photography as taking photos of cars in a car park at a track day is motorsport. Sure its a great photo, yes it was taken on the street but its not "street photography." If you get me. I always try and make it clear that I'm taking street portraits when I'm out and not doing street photography as I feel theres a line.
 
I'm impressed with D-D's assertation that none of these photos will ever be printed out or hung on a wall etc when I'm sure there are loads of people on her with street photography printed out and hung on the wall and slmost certainly a handfull who've made some money floggin images taken on the street.

Personally I can think of nothing more hideaus than a high key portrait of a a kid string at me off my living room wall, maybe that'll change when I have kids but I'm sure I'd rather have a nice candid shot of them enjoying life.
 
Yup I've sold street photography prints, exhibited them and had them published in magazines. Cartier-Bresson made his life from it.
 
Personally I can think of nothing more hideaus than a high key portrait of a a kid string at me off my living room wall, maybe that'll change when I have kids but I'm sure I'd rather have a nice candid shot of them enjoying life.

Each to their own eh?

Those hideous shots make lots of photographers lots of money and lots of families happy too

Pete is an exception on TP as someone making money from SP I suspect, in fact, I rather suspect there aren't many pros (as a %) making a living from purely this sort of work

Personally, I'd find nothing more hideous to hang on my wall than some bloke/woman I don't know having a fag while on their mobile walking down a street somewhere

Hey Ho

DD
 
But why is it nessisary to make money from it?? I think your missing the point of street work entirely.

Again your comparing two forms which are completely different. I personally would find nothing more hideous to hang on my wall than a posed standard studio shot.
 
I also wouldn't want a photo of some random person walking down the street smoking and talking on their phone, unless it had meaning. Unless I emotionally connected with it. Technically there's no difference between that and studio pics for families. Why do they buy it? Its simple, they connect with it and enjoy the photo. It means something to them so they buy it.
 
I think its like this. Its as much street photography as taking photos of cars in a car park at a track day is motorsport. Sure its a great photo, yes it was taken on the street but its not "street photography." If you get me. I always try and make it clear that I'm taking street portraits when I'm out and not doing street photography as I feel theres a line.

OK, my bad...
 
But why is it nessisary to make money from it?? I think your missing the point of street work entirely.

.

Good point

I was kinda using money as a means of measuring 'use'

People like to see 'pretty' pics - be that their kids, pets, landscapes, etc. - gritty pics don't have such wide appeal

I've been a club member for years locally where we have 9 comps a year, and we've had many inter-club comps too. Then there have been wider club exhibitions I've been to - and to my recollection, no SP images have ever been entered or exhibited

Perhaps it's a niche (and a small one at that) or perhaps it's just too hard to do well so those that try it, don't enter it - or maybe like me, most just don't appreciate it

DD
 
Perhaps its just outside your circle of photography. Gritty pics don't have a wide appeal, er? I'm not even sure where to start with that one...
 
Perhaps its just outside your circle of photography. Gritty pics don't have a wide appeal, er?


Fine Pete - but if your circle has hundreds of snappers in it, and they don't shoot or exhibit it; and your market is families who don't have it on their walls either... I'd obviously go with 'fag smoking blokes stood in the street' isn't widely appealing

Angst ridden youth and students, probably - but I've also spent 4 years at uni too and I don't recall SP on their walls either

Look at the mags in WHSmith, of hundreds on offer, few will have SP in them so as a population it can't be widely appealing can it

DD
 
Every single day I see gritty street photos on Flickr's top 500 photos. Flickr being the biggest photo sharing site in the world makes me think you're wrong about this.
 
Good point

People like to see 'pretty' pics - be that their kids, pets, landscapes, etc. - gritty pics don't have such wide appeal

DD

hmmmmmmmm, have you visited a photo exhibition or art gallery recently. Or had a look at the work of the great conflict and disaster photographers of the 20th century.

I would say undoubtedly the most recognizable and meaningful photos in history are grainy non 'pretty' shots. Take the work of Capa as a benchmark. He even published a book call 'slightly out of focus' yet has produced some of the most distinctive and celebrated photographs in history
 
I don't get street either. Then again plenty don't get sports, c'est la vie :)
 
I think we all know the shot of the little girl running naked from the atomic bomb fallout - but how many have it on our walls? Just because we recognise an image doesn't mean we like it. I recognise images of Hitler but they don't grace my walls, or those of anyone I know (or would like to know for that matter)

There are probably a few hundred Haywains on people's walls for every gritty war photo

Art exhibitions etc. are still niche - even if 10,000 attend, there's 60million who didn't. I didn't say it didn't have appeal, but in the population it's appeal is small

And unless the majority of flicker's images are SP compared to portraits, glamour, kids, landscapes, macro, sport, etc. - it's still small as a %; and even then this is to more arty types who are more likely to find it attractive and are thus not representative of the general populas - the general population who buy images for walls that they like or magazines with images and subject matter they like, aren't flicker users, or exhibition attendees. More people take holidays in the Lake District than Soho

DD
 
Dave, the question you really seem to be asking is:

"What's the point of a shot if you can't sell it to someone to hang on their wall?"

That really opens up a much larger can of worms because you could equally ask why make films such as American History X, Life is Beautiful, etc.? They're not films that leave you feeling all warm and safe inside, they draw you in, provoke strong emotions and create differing opinions. They spark discussion and allow us to learn more about ourselves and the world around us.

A cute shot of little Timmy dressed in saturated colours floating against a heavenly (and neutral) background is, IMO, the photographic version of "Kids say the funniest things" or similar.

Street photography is, IMO, the photographer's attempt to engage the viewer and draw them into the world as the photographer sees it, to trigger questions, empathy in order to learn more about the human condition be it funny, tragic or otherwise.

Perhaps it's better to say that the commercial aspect of this kind of photography is the message rather than the content...
 
I think this thread has become a waste of time a D-D has decided that street photography is a completely non-valid form of photography based on some very narrow criteria and will never change his opinion.

Personally I can't think of a single area of photography I would dismiss so totally obviously there are forms of the art I like more than others but I can still aprreciate them. If I were to decide to ruin my hobby and persue it professionally I can also appreciate that it would be alot easier to make money out of some channels than others because some have more commercial appeal but this in no way makes them more or less valid as an art form.
 
D-D has decided that street photography is a completely non-valid form of photography based on some very narrow criteria and will never change his opinion.

Haven't at all thanks, if I had decided upon that view I wouldn't be planning on giving it a go

DD
 
Late to the debate as always (been busy)

I personally don't do street - in fact I like my shots to be devoid of people (even if that means waiting around until non are in shot).

But I think that the issue here is one of quality - there are "street" shots that have great composition, form and structure. Cartier Bresson springs to mind here. Have you ever seen his contact sheets (exhibited a few years ago) there are a lot of what you might call random shots, with little or nothing to recommend them. But then he only printed the ones that had some artistic value to his own view.

Think of the street as wildlife - many people when they begin to shoot wildlife are pleased just to have caught the creature in the frame - then they progress to getting it in focus, and then to capturing it at the right moment (eagle catching a rabbit etc.) and finally they combine all this with good composition.

The same can be said for Street Photography.

So, the challenge is DD, can you take some street that suits your own creative criteria? If so great - if not, choose another subject.
 
Back
Top