Hi Craig, Having a major catch up, then hope to try and stay a bit more up to date
Stark - Poor tree looks like its had a bit of a tough time. Good find but maybe a little to busy at the bottom to be really stark but the top branches stand out well against the blue sky.
Over - Really like this one. Good choice to have it in B&W and I like just having the one word and button in focus
Age - Not sure about this, I don't think theres too much wrong with it but it just feels like there is something missing. I was once told if you were arranging a display of anything you should always do it in multiples of 3, so maybe its just that stuck in my head
Sharp - Like a little lego scene, wasn't sure about the big shadow in the bg but actually it makes me think that there is giant behind the lego man waiting to pick up the knife. If thats what you were going for it worked
Guard - I like this too, the lever at the front is a little distracting but I love the wheel and the mud guard against the green bg. dof is spot on I think
Thick - Nice white snow so good exposure and it is pretty thick. I think you must have had quite a bit more than us but to be honest thats not hard