Hi Michael,
Spread - I prefer the close-up of the seals for this, even if the connection to the theme is not as obvious. There's more detail, and I like the comp. The wide angle shot has more of a quick snap-shot feel to it.
Together - I think this is cute, but the way it's photographed and processed, it doesn't have a 'happy' together feel to it, if you know what I mean. I would have liked to see it against a brighter, perhaps white, background, and less dark overall.
Pack - Not sure about this. To me, the subject itself isn't terribly interesting, and the way it's been lit, unfortunately, it doesn't do a huge amount for me. Sorry!
Hi Michael, here goes catch up!
Change, I like the money one best. Great PP and bang on theme
Natural is a gorgeous shot; so simple yet so effective.
Age; yep, definitely on theme, and a nice treatment for a landscape. I can almost feel the cold!
Spread doesn't really say spread to me, but no matter; it's a lovely photo.
Together, I don't like these ornaments one bit, BUT, you've photographed it nicely, and the B&W works for me.
Pack yes, it's on theme and well taken. Not a have, but a good shot none-the-less.
Art is lovely, and the way you've photographed it has brought it to life.
Hi Michael,
Apologies for not keeping up but you know the score I've been away at sea for a few months.
By the way 'Defender 06' was originally named as 'AL MAJIHAD' and built at Brooke Marine, Lowestoft for the Sultan of Oman's Navy but they gave it back!. I have no idea who owns it now but it doesn't belong to HM Forces or HM Coastguard so probably in the hands of a private collector. Lets hope the gun has been decommissioned !
Spread - Nice image of seals basking. looks like you had some difficult lighting conditions so you've done well. Good focus too.
Together - I think you final re-worked image is the best one of the set. works well for the theme.
Pack - Nappies! I guess your going to be very busy soon. Bang on subject although i think i would have preferred to have seen the original in colour.
Art - Nice image. Again bang on theme and very colourful !
Hi Michael
4 weeks to go....
My thoughts pretty much match Nathalie's.... not a terribly interesting image & not so keen on the tone...can';t help thinking a nice baby type surround ( fluffy blankets , cuddly toys etc etc) may have lifted it a touch but still been on theme ?
Art....colorful , on theme , like how you lit it- very imaginative & right on theme .It's lasted well for being in the loft too . Clever wifey you got there mister
Yup, much better!Is it any better?
Hi Michael
Pack - i have looked at both and sorry to say that I cannot get excited by either
As to Art ....- what a contrast - really like that. Terrific vibrant colours which you have caught very well. Naive art and the creases in the paper help a lot. It made me smile - love the drifting smoke from the chimneys.
Just think in a couple of years time you will have lots of these little pieces of art, usually, in my experience, with a little note giving a declaration of love. Not long now.