I think I would rather have the burger in focus, as that's more to the point for the theme, but without seeing it, hard to really say. no reason why you shouldn't post both images to your personal thread (just not to the main one) if you're in two minds.
Why f/2.8? Looking at the exif you could probably have gone to 1/60th sec and f/4 which would have given a bit more leeway on the DoF (I don't know the 1D3, can you push the iso above 800?)