Hi Michael (& Caitlin),
Good job on the catch up
- here goes
Abandoned - I'm going to have to chose your shot for this one, because of the subject matter
. Both well taken, but in Caitlin's the sky is a bit blown.
Living World - Caitlin this time, I think the sheep shot would have been stronger if they had been facing you, shots from behind are always difficult to appreciate.
Topical - Well, your subject matter is obviously the winner
but Caitlin's shot wins due to shooting 'street'.
Artificial - Cuddly doggie for me. Loving the added detail of the half eaten biscuit. The light is on the skew, but not sufficiently to look deliberate imo.
Spiky - The plant against teh sky due to the well captured blue sky in the shot.
Vast - The first one - the composition is stronger I believe with the mountain being the obvious point of interest in the shot.
Technology - Royal Scot is well taken, but the background is a bit distracting and the sky is blown (is Caitlin shooting only in jpg? Maybe using RAW would allow some recovery in post), so the 123is my preference here. It's odd to think that the 125's were introduced only 9 years after the end of Steam.
Horizontal - The Great Western shot, well done avoiding moire in that shot. Are Caitlin's beavers? The detail in the fur is very good.
Flora - I do like the way your shot fills the frame, but both are well taken.
Activity - The little lad pops well from the background, shame it's a bit cluttered. Caitlin's shot has a better background and is very sharp, but doesn't feel quite as on theme.
Colourful - The Pencils win if for me, not competition, although fair play for getting a bit of 'street'. Is that escalator the one at Waterloo by platform 19? If not, it does look very much like it.