Guessing Peter was referring to the black velvet...
Looks a real tricky one to light, shiny bits, curved bits, highlights, etc. Think you've done a good job here - and being able to critique your own work means you should have a much shorter route to getting what you want.
Light on the gold *ahem* chain is very good, touch hard to read the writing on the tall bottle but it all ties together well.
Thanks for looking and commenting PhilI quite like the lighting on the chain Elaine Think the chain and the small bottle go well together , not too sure on the tall bottle or the folds in the bg though
Thanks for looking and commenting Mercurius. I suppose that I should have given my rationale for the bottles shot when I first posted it. My thinking was that the two bottles were linked to start with because they contained the same fragrance. The chain links were to physically link them together and also a more esoteric link in that they might all be worn together (and thus linked) for a special occasion. The black satin fabric - in my mind anyway - added (or was linked!) to the general luxury/special night out feel of the items I used.Swirl - another vote for the scarf. Unusual take on the theme and I like the folds.
Linked - not sure I get the link between the chain and the bottles.
.... but the opportunity for the joke was too good to pass up
Nooooooo that's the best reason for sure, sounds like you thought about the shot a lot and tried other angles, so the best you could get - PerfectThanks DK. I wasn't happy with cropping the top of the monitor but the problem was that the room's too small for me to stand any further back and if I'd got the top of the monitor in at that angle I would have lost all but a sliver of the keyboard, which I was even more unhappy about, so I decided to use the grey toolbar on the screen as the diagonal. I did try it square on, but it just looked too flat to me. Maybe the wrong decision
Thanks DavidThe second is ace. Nice angles!!
Thanks Phil. The mono conversion was more of a necessity than pre-planned because the artificial light does the bottle green carpet and off white walls of the stairwell no favours at all . I've had a second try at it this morning now that the lights have gone off, but there isn't enough natural daylight on the mid-level staircase to get a decent looking shot.Prefer the 2nd Elaine, for me, the angle creates more interest it certainly suits the conversion to B&W
http://www.talkphotography.co.uk/threads/2014-photo52-challenge-week-13-step.523119/Second one
[Off Topic ... I think there's a thread somewhere announcing the theme ... anyone got a link?]
Thanks Judi. I've just noticed that there's a little corner of the brick wall I was leaning on in the middle of the bottom of the curvy shot, which I meant to clone out. Must remember to do it if I put that one on the main thread.Gosh a lot of steps there Elaine, I like step around the best the curves and the lovely willow tree gives it a spring like feel, the goose step two step has to come a close 2nd
haha had to laugh at the goose step... I liked the step around pic but the B&W original steps really catch the imagination...
Thanks AdamI prefer the second shots in both the sets. the diagonal lines across the frame in the first really add depth and make it look 3D, the mono conversion works well too. the composition in the second is spot on with the steps leading your eye across the frame. well done.