Hi Kathleen,
Smoke - Both are great, but I agree with your choice of #2, because of the variety of colours in the smoke.
Vivid - Love the colours, reflections and strong black background. Nicely positioned. #1 for me.
Large - Large in the frame There would have been a way to hide the cropped tail, massively crop in, taking some of hte head and a fair bit of the body out. Even larger in the frame and an artistic choice.
Hi Kath, I've no idea how I've missed your thread up to now but possibly due to my various catch-ups. I've found you now so just looked through from the start and have picked out my favourites so far, and I'll aim to keep up to date now
Manxmaid and Samuel thank you so much for your kind words they are very much appreciated